Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono un uomo in detransition/desistenza: ho fatto la transizione sociale e ho iniziato l’HRT verso ottobre 2019, dopo due anni di coming out pubblico e molta terapia, ma ho iniziato a dubitare leggendo contenuti gender critical. Entro marzo 2020 avevo rifiutato l’etichetta «transgender», ero uscito dagli spazi trans dopo essere stato preso di mira per i miei dubbi e cercavo di capire dove collocarmi. Ho descritto il mio disagio come radicato nella biologia più che nella società, e ho detto che la transizione mi aveva davvero aiutato all’epoca, riconoscendo però che può funzionare da fuga dalla realtà. Ho riferito che mi si diceva che «devo essere trans» per la mia diagnosi di disforia di genere, e nel post di dicembre 2019 ho scritto che sapere che non sarò mai una donna mi faceva desiderare «il dolce sollievo della morte». Oggi mi identifico come bisessuale con una forte preferenza per gli uomini e non mi considero un vero detransitioner, ma qualcuno con «molti dubbi e molto pensiero critico da fare».
Storia completa
I was raised in a strictly Catholic household and didn't really understand what sex was until a sex education class around age 11 or 12; I described myself as 'incredibly clueless' and a 'late bloomer.' Any misconceptions I carried into adulthood were cleared up by a proper sex ed class in public high school. From almost crying in that initial sex ed class upon learning I would never be able to give birth to a child, it was clear early on that I was deeply uncomfortable with being male.
I contemplated being transgender for a long time and had been publicly out for two years as of December 2019. My first years being truly 'out' were spent first in outpatient therapy due to a crisis, and then for a year and a half afterward in regular weekly therapy. Around two months before that post (roughly October 2019), I finally started HRT after doing my due diligence to figure out if it was the right choice. From a personal perspective at that time, I believed it was the right choice: being referred to as a woman felt right, dressing in a traditionally feminine way felt right, and I had great struggles with my biological sex.
I had tried living publicly as a gender non-conforming male — it didn't help. I had tried just crossdressing — it didn't help. Social transition and HRT had been the best thing for my deep-seated gender issues up to that point. I also noted that my discomfort with my sex seemed rooted in basic biology — sexual dimorphism, body parts — rather than in society, and that I'd had very supportive family and friends encouraging me to forge my own path isolated from gender roles over the years, so it wasn't simply a matter of individuality or social pressure.
However, around late 2019 I began reading a lot of gender-critical content, which led me to worry I might be hurting others by transitioning. I questioned whether it was fair to expect people to call me a woman when I'm a man, and whether wanting to use facilities aligned with my gender identity was wrong given potential stress to others. I stated that women should have their own spaces and that I didn't belong in them, while still feeling the sting that I was 'born in the completely wrong way.' I called myself 'a fucking man' and a 'disgusting narcissist,' and wrote that knowing I'll never truly be a woman made me want 'the sweet release of death.' I asked whether there was some way to force myself to come to terms with being a man or to 'fix' myself, saying I was tired of the pain and 'so lost.'
I continued therapy after that post and brought these concerns up in session; it was 'a topic that's in the works.' One commenter suggested taking a month away from gender-related material, and I agreed, noting I had largely stopped engaging with trans communities (aside from a private group described as 'a private chamber for surreal memery') and had instead been looking at anti-trans resources. I also resolved to get back into meditation, which I said had been good for me in the past.
By March 2020, I had joined a few trans spaces again, mainly because there were people I genuinely appreciated being around. But when people there learned of my questioning and rejection of the 'trans' label, I was dogpiled: told I was repressing, that I had been 'brainwashed by TERFs,' and subjected to debates over my identity. I said it didn't matter if I stated I no longer found comfort in identifying as 'transgender' or just wanted to be considered my own person. I described the identity push as having been 'aggressively being pushed' onto me — shoehorned into every conversation, with people calling me 'a fucking idiot' for doubting my identity, and arguments devolving into semantics, gaslighting, or verbal abuse. I left those groups, accepting that some friendships would have to die out.
In a comment from March 2020, I expressed bafflement at trans people championing 'respect other peoples' identity' while discarding it for detrans folk, and noted I was being told outright that I *had* to be trans because I was diagnosed with gender dysphoria and experienced it daily. I said it was tough to find somewhere to fit in socially.
On the topic of detransition generally, I said mental health is the main reason a straight man would want to detransition, and that gender dysphoria and trauma aren't unique to sexuality, criticizing parts of Blanchard's typology as 'grossly flawed' while acknowledging other parts as correct. I said I wasn't sure I counted as a detransitioner since I was 'fairly closed to the thought of sex' when I did anything transition-related — dysphoria made sex an incredibly taxing thing to think about — and that transition had been the right choice for me after pursuing multiple different ways of getting treatment. I stated that as of that comment (March 2020) I was bisexual with a pretty large preference for guys. I also acknowledged that trauma can play a role and that transition can serve as escapism — 'literally becoming a different person to ditch your past' being appealing to those who practice avoidance.
I also praised GenderHQ as a 'really, really great resource' that is empirically sourced, while doubting it would be well received in certain spaces.