Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto detransizione, ho vissuto come uomo trans per quasi 10 anni e sono senza testosterone da circa 5 anni. Non ho mai fatto la mastectomia ma ho un petto naturalmente piatto, e mi pento profondamente dei cambiamenti alla voce dovuti al testosterone. Gli aspetti mentali e sociali della detransizione sono stati molto più duri di quelli fisici: vengo scambiata per un uomo ogni giorno, evito i bagni delle donne e i vestiti femminili per paura di come vengo percepita e sento di dover dimostrare di continuo di essere donna. Sono critica sia dei «consigli» di femminilizzazione dati ai detransizionati sia di quella che vedo come un'ideologia di genere regressiva che rafforza gli stereotipi. Al momento mi sto facendo crescere i capelli, sperimentando un look butch con i capelli lunghi e, nel complesso, sto meglio, anche se ho ancora giornate brutte.
Storia completa
I was always a masculine-leaning kid, right from grade school, and I got bullied for it. Around age 13, the adults in my life decided I might be a 'boy' rather than a girl based on nothing more than my haircut and the fact that I wore boys' clothes. At the time I was starting to identify as a butch lesbian because I was having crushes on girls and none on boys, and I was questioning my sexuality. I was taken to my pastor, who was openly a lesbian, to talk about it; for reasons I still don't fully understand she brought up gender and introduced me to a thirty-something-year-old trans man who reasoned that because I was a tomboy I might be trans. I didn't object to what the adults suggested because I assumed they knew what they were talking about.
I lived as a man for almost 10 years. During that time I saw myself as one of the guys. I was on testosterone for years; I have now been off T for about 5 years, with only a few hiccups along the way that never lasted more than a week or two. I never had top surgery — I simply don't have much of a chest naturally, and it's flat enough that people have asked if I'm wearing a binder. The voice change from testosterone is definitely a regret of mine. I also have regrets about how my chest looks and the daily misgendering I experience.
The mental and social side of detransition has been much harder for me than the physical side. Accepting myself as a woman rather than a trans man or just 'a man' has been mental gymnastics. I still think 'like a guy,' which is hard because I know physically I'm not one. For instance, I worry about how to interact with women, even platonically, so I don't seem like a creepy dude — I won't walk behind a woman on the sidewalk even if I'm far back, because I know women worry about being assaulted by a stranger. I also avoid crying in front of people, and I've developed anxieties about shopping in the women's section because I worry about being seen as a weirdo or a feminine man.
People refer to me as male about 90% of the time before I correct them, and I assume they then think I'm a trans woman or 'some other flavor of gender.' I don't even dress femininely — I've dressed butch/masc for most of my life — but I have a fear of exploring women's clothing because of how I'm perceived. Even my doctors, who know my sex, don't treat me like a woman; I've had doctors and psychologists tell me I might be trans or non-binary when I tried to tell them I was re-identifying as a woman. I often feel like an imposter in women's clothing; even the shape of a neckline can make me uncomfortable because in my mind people think I'm a man wearing women's clothing and I feel embarrassed and vulnerable, since I always saw myself as a tough guy when I was trans. Going out alone in women's clothing makes me dissociate, though I'm okay at home or with family. I find a lot of women's clothing sexualized, which makes me uncomfortable. I keep getting drawn to women's clothing but then feel embarrassed if I see a butch woman while dressed femininely, like I'm demasculating myself. I do want to grow out my hair — maybe long hair would help me feel better in men's clothes because I wouldn't get misgendered as much — but I also don't know if my desire to wear women's clothing is genuine. I'm currently growing my hair out and experimenting with a long-haired butch look, and I've looked into wigs (including hat wigs) for when I feel like having longer hair.
The social world has been brutal. My own father told me to use the men's restroom because if I dress like a man I shouldn't use the women's — this came after store employees laughed at me while I tried to explain I'm not a dude. I've been 'it'd' by my own family and they laugh about it. Because of how I'm perceived, I avoid women's restrooms and changing rooms. I feel like I have to try even harder to prove my womanhood to people, in bathrooms, changing rooms, and conversation. Being a masculine woman is hard; being a detrans masculine woman is hell.
I think a lot of the pressure comes from how gendered our world is. I'm critical of what I see as harmful advice — both from people telling me to feminize myself to 'look more female' (ironic given I already am female) and from the broader culture. I've said the whole woke/pride/inclusivity thing has been 'nothing but regressive' and 'sexism repackaged,' and that masculine women and feminine men are still treated as others. I also feel detransitioner communities are falling into some harmful habits, particularly around 'do I pass' discourse. I'm frustrated that people sex others based on clothes and hair length, which to me just reinforces stereotypes.
Sexuality-wise, I always seem to develop crushes on straight women — I relate to the Rihanna song 'Te Amo' about being attracted to a woman who isn't attracted to you because she isn't a lesbian. I don't mention any formal diagnoses or therapy. I got a tattoo in June 2024 to represent my detransition and self-acceptance as a woman — I described it to my mother as being about self-acceptance, rebirth, and healing, and told her I had lived for almost 10 years as a man; she didn't comment much but thought the idea was cool. Overall I'm doing much better, though I still have bad days — at least I'm moving forward.