Tutte le storie

Sei anni da non binaria, senza contatti con i genitori

Femmina · Desistito/a183
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha desistito: mi sono identificata come trans/non binaria per circa sei anni, dalla tarda adolescenza/primi vent'anni fino alla fine del 2022, ma non ho mai fatto una transizione medica. La mia identità trans è nata da gravi abusi emotivi e controllo da parte dei miei genitori, da sintomi di PTSD/CPTSD, dall'autismo, dall'essere lesbica e dalla misoginia interiorizzata: mi ha dato un modo per dare un nome al mio dolore e un senso di me stessa separato da mia madre. Interrompere i contatti con i genitori nel 2019 e desistere nel 2022 sono stati entrambi necessari per iniziare a guarire. Lotto ancora ogni giorno con la salute mentale e sento che l'identità mi ha bloccata emotivamente per anni, ma la sensazione di fondo «c'è qualcosa di molto sbagliato in me» si è risolta solo dopo aver tagliato i ponti con chi mi abusava. Ora ho opinioni sfumate e critiche sia verso l'attivismo trans estremo sia verso lo zelo gender-critical, credendo al tempo stesso che esista una vera disforia di genere e che alcune persone traggano beneficio dalla transizione.

Storia completa

I was born female and I only ever socially transitioned — I never took hormones or had any surgeries, so I can't speak to the medical side of things. I identified as trans/non-binary for about six years, roughly from my late teens/early twenties until the end of 2022. Growing up I had very emotionally abusive and controlling parents. I've come to understand that I didn't have a sense of self that didn't rely on what my mother told me to think, and when I got a little distance from that I felt completely empty and had no idea who I was. I have a lot of symptoms of PTSD/CPTSD from that upbringing, though I've never been diagnosed with BPD. I also later came to see that a mix of trauma, autism, being a lesbian, and general misogyny — the feeling that I wasn't being a woman right — was probably behind a lot of what I experienced as gender dysphoria. The first time I heard a friend in college use they/them pronouns for me casually in conversation I felt genuinely good, and at the time I read that as gender euphoria. In hindsight I think it was really just the experience of someone caring about how I felt — something entirely new after a lifetime of being told what I felt was wrong or didn't matter. What I felt was more relief and a self-esteem boost than euphoria: my trans identity gave me something to point at and say, 'this is what's wrong with me! I don't have to pretend I'm not in constant pain and discomfort! I have clear cut goals for what I can do to feel at peace with myself.' I also used the trans identity to explain the trouble in my relationship with my parents in a way I could understand — 'they don't accept me because they're bigots' was much easier than confronting that they had been controlling my mind and feelings for 20 years and that I felt like I couldn't breathe in their presence. I went no contact with my parents in 2019 as the full picture of the relationship revealed itself. I questioned my trans identity around that time but didn't actually desist until the end of 2022. I think both things needed to happen for me to start truly healing. There was an almost three-year period where I was no contact with my parents and still identified as trans, and I could have started medically transitioning during that window and didn't — partly because I didn't actually want to, and partly because before I separated from them I wouldn't have had the financial resources to transition or the ability to hide it from them, even in my twenties. Their lack of support therefore played a real role in whether I medically transitioned, which is confusing for me: I'm glad I didn't do it, but I don't feel their stance came out of love. There's also a part of me that's thankful they didn't let me start testosterone, because I'm fairly sure I would have regretted it. While I was identifying as trans I did some things in the name of dysphoria I now find ridiculous — for example buying a more 'manly' wallet and not carrying a purse even though I liked them because they were 'too girly.' After I desisted, a male coworker saw the wallet at work and asked why I had a man's wallet. I felt embarrassed at first, but it also highlighted how stupid the whole thing is — it shouldn't matter. I also felt that my sexual desire for women was a 'man' thing. Even after seeing examples of lesbian couples, there was a sense that passionately wanting women was a male experience; I didn't know many lesbian couples in real life and felt media often portrayed lesbians as 'best friends who hold hands and kiss sometimes' rather than two people who passionately want each other. I now think wlw attraction and straight men's attraction to women are more similar than not, and that doesn't make us men. Desisting didn't magically fix everything. I still struggle majorly with my mental health and I haven't dealt with all of my issues — it's hard every single day — but the only thing that made the persistent 'something is very very wrong with me' feeling go away was completely cutting contact with my abusers. I was in an in-between stage for many years of hating myself and believing 'everything will be fixed when I medically transition,' and that emotionally stunted me for a long time. I've also realized I threw every 'wrong' feeling into the gender bucket even when it had nothing to do with gender. I briefly went down the rad fem rabbit hole when I first stopped identifying as trans, which I'm somewhat ashamed of, and I've seen disgusting material on that side too. I spent a long time in extreme trans circles, so I'm skeptical of hardline labels from either direction; I've gotten into the habit of judging for myself to avoid ideological echo chambers. I don't identify as gender critical, though some trans activists would label my opinions that way, and I'm not insulted by it because my views come from real experience rather than ignorance or hate. I have issues with parts of the trans community for erasing biological reality and relying on gender stereotypes, but I don't hate trans people and I do believe some people have genuine gender dysphoria that benefits from transition and deserve support. I also think the mental effects of identifying as trans for a long period need to be talked about more, whether or not someone medically transitioned, and I push back on the idea that desisted people were just 'going through a phase.'