Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono un maschio che ha fatto detransizione (MtFtM), mi identificavo come trans, ho iniziato gli estrogeni con l’intenzione di passare al femminile e circa 14-15 mesi dopo ho deciso di essere cis. Sono rimasto in TOS a basso dosaggio perché mi ha eliminato la grave acne e il diradamento dei capelli, e mi sento molto più a mio agio e sicuro, ma odio la crescita del seno e mi preoccupo per la salute a lungo termine e la fertilità. Mi identifico come un ragazzo e un “femboy in TOS” GNC, rifiutando sia l’identità di donna trans sia la mascolinità convenzionale, e nascondo la TOS ai miei genitori transfobici e alla maggior parte degli amici. Provo una forte ansia sociale riguardo agli appuntamenti, al passare e all’essere percepito, e faccio fatica a trovare modelli maschili GNC oltre i 30 anni. Sono AGP detrans e il mio senso di me è diventato più forte da quando ho fatto detransizione, anche se mi sento ancora un emarginato sociale e vorrei alla fine fare una mastectomia.
Storia completa
I was born male. I first started noticing aggressive balding at 20 and horrible acne that resisted essentially every treatment I tried — skincare routines, tretinoin, clindamycin, spironolactone, multiple dermatologist-prescribed treatments. Friends told me to just 'wash my face.' Nothing worked except estrogen. I also had hair thinning before transition and was self-conscious about my voice.
I started estrogen intending to transition to female. I had debated the side effects for several years before starting. I came out to people before starting hormones — mostly online friends used she/her for me — but I never lived openly as a woman. I was a college student still somewhat dependent on my extremely transphobic, homophobic parents, and I had intense imposter syndrome, body dysmorphia, and guilt from what I later identified as AGP (autogynephilia). I felt like I shouldn't make others play along with me being a woman.
About a week into voice training, I realized transitioning was making me hate myself more than ever. I'd always been self-conscious about my voice and had a nagging feeling that forcibly changing it was the opposite of the self-acceptance I needed. It made me step back and realize I was changing myself to fit society's view of a woman rather than being myself for my own benefit. It took about a year and a half between starting HRT and deciding I was cis. My reasons for detransitioning included: lack of passing, not 'feeling like a woman,' imposter syndrome, realizing outward appearance and presentation has nothing to do with gender, and worsening obsession with dysphoria and the trans community.
I never felt like I had to conform to standards of being a man before I tried transitioning, but after, it felt like I had to change who I was to fit the norms of women. My family made me feel inferior because I was never a very masculine individual. What I really wanted when I wanted to transition was freedom from the 'man' gender role — it was a messed-up way of thinking I'd be accepted better in a different role.
I detransitioned socially but stayed on low-dose estrogen. I've been on hormones or T blockers for at least 6 years. I tried stopping several times but it's never pleasant — my skin breaks out, my chest hurts like when I first got breast buds, and my libido comes back strongly. I can barely miss a day. I developed gynecomastia from HRT which I hate — I wish I had a flat chest — but quitting won't fix it, so I'm hoping to get a mastectomy eventually. I'm worried about hair thinning returning and worsening if I stop. I don't know how my fertility would be.
I still identify as a guy and prefer to be called a man. I consider myself a detrans GNC male, or basically a 'femboy who takes HRT.' Identifying as a man was very liberating — I can do whatever I want and my gender won't change regardless of others' perceptions. This contrasted with having an external locus of control as a trans woman, focusing on stereotypical femininity to cover up my natural gender markers. I now feel no pressure to be less feminine and don't mind being misgendered, but I'm also accepting my masculine qualities rather than despising them. I often get a feeling of wanting to identify as nonbinary, but I see that as giving in to the same culturally constructed stereotypes that made me feel I had to be a woman to express femininity.
I'm AGP detrans. The temptation of transitioning would've haunted me for my life if I didn't try it, even though it wasn't for me. I have OCD and a habit of obsessing over labels, and a bad habit of obsessing over people's opinions and being desperate for people to like me, even at the cost of what I truly am.
My anxiety is made worse by being on HRT — it feels like a dark secret I can't tell almost anyone because people assume I'm transfem. Explaining I'm just a guy on estrogen feels impossible. Most of my friends since starting HRT think I'm trans (mtf, nonbinary, or ftm) — I'm open about being a man but I sort of like being assumed transmasc. I occasionally get assumed female and don't know how to respond. I still hide HRT from my family and most friends.
I have no desire to pursue social transition. I haven't had a physical in 7 years because I'm terrified of discussing my physical changes from HRT, and I'm scared my parents will find out since I'm on their insurance.
Dating is a major struggle. I feel undateable in my current state. Most people, especially women, aren't interested in a guy who takes estrogen and doesn't look masculine. I've had guys not be interested because I was 'basically a woman,' but women who are into women prefer actual women. I'm bi. I've had multiple t4t trans women still be interested in me despite me identifying as a man. I worry a partner would want me to stop HRT or fully transition. Almost all my trans woman friends who aren't online have only dated other MtFs.
I cannot find positive role models of GNC cis males over 30 still presenting femininely — the only examples are people on hormones, fetishists, or bearded men making statements. Even most MtFtM detransitioners revert to conventional male presentation. I want to be a man as a biological category but don't want to claim masculinity. I'm approaching 30 and worry about losing hair, worse skin, and a more masculine body type.
My aversion to masculinity is personal — I often find effects of HRT and transition unattractive in others, though I have no issue with masculine features in partners and often find them attractive. I was quite withdrawn when perceived as more masculine; becoming more comfortable with myself through transition made me able to be a caring person for others. My discomfort with masculinity is likely based on negative experiences in my upbringing, but acknowledging that can't just fix it.
I've thought about the relation between queer identity and Christianity — whether God's desire for queer people is to avoid temptations or persist in being themselves despite prejudice. I'm critical of the trans community's emphasis on gender roles and 'gender performance,' and I think modern feminism has endorsed neo-essentialism while ignoring the harm of gender constructs. I'm supportive of detransition being framed as personal growth rather than failure.