Tutte le storie

Dava la colpa al suo corpo di donna — finché l'ha data al sessismo

Femmina · Desistito/a154
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition/desistenza e non ha mai portato a termine una transizione medica; oggi mi identifico come donna e rifiuto l'idea di dover cambiare il mio corpo o comportarmi in un modo particolare per adeguarmi ad aspettative sessiste. Ho faticato a lungo ad accettare di essere nata femmina, vedendo il mio corpo e la mia capacità riproduttiva come inferiori, ma alla fine ho deciso di non fare la transizione perché ho concluso che il problema era una società sessista, non il mio corpo. Credo che gli effetti del testosterone sui corpi femminili siano più rapidi e meno reversibili di quelli degli estrogeni sui corpi maschili, ed è per questo che le donne che fanno detransition hanno bisogno di reti di sostegno più solide. In questo materiale non ho descritto ormoni, interventi o diagnosi formali. Resto critica verso le transizioni che sembrano guidate dal desiderio di sfuggire al sessismo più che da una vera disforia.

Storia completa

I was born female and for a long time I struggled to accept that reality. I used to think of female biology as a kind of curse — I lamented being born into a body I considered physically inferior, with a uterus I figured I'd never use, and what I called "a monthly subscription to hell itself" on top of it all. I held the view that physicality is the only thing that actually separates the sexes — not hobbies, personalities, or intelligence — so feeling physically weaker felt like being dealt a losing hand. What eventually flipped the switch for me was realizing how little brute strength actually matters in modern life. I reasoned that someone being able to bench 200+ pounds doesn't make them more competent as a person, and that society has long passed the era where physical strength had real day-to-day benefits. I also talked myself through the fear around my body: there are weapons and martial arts techniques that let weaker people defend themselves, certain medications can reduce or completely remove periods, and no one I'd want to associate with would insist I have to give birth just because I was born with a uterus. My conclusion was essentially that you shouldn't let it get to you — yes, male bodies have a physical advantage, and historically that was used to claim men were better than women, but a man isn't better than a woman because he's taller or builds muscle more easily. This line of thinking is directly tied to my decision not to transition. In April 2022 I wrote that what keeps me from transition, as a female person, is the hope that society will grow up and stop hurling sexist stereotypes at us based on the sex we were born as. I said there's nothing wrong with me — it's a sexist society that's at fault — and that I don't want to transition just to squeeze myself into another ill-fitting box. I'd rather be me and say "fuck you" to anyone who complains that I don't live up to their sexist expectations. I also believe there's no correct way to act like a man or woman, and that a person can be male and still have feminine hobbies, interests, and mannerisms — so I don't accept the idea that I need to "act" as my sex to be valid. I've thought a lot about why detransition seems harder for females than for males. My theory, which I posted in April 2021, is that testosterone has a greater impact on female bodies in a shorter amount of time — hair gain, voice deepening — and these changes are very difficult to reverse, which is why detransitioning women seem to need a greater support network of others going through the same thing. By contrast, I observed that estrogen's effects on male bodies may be less noticeable at first and less permanent (voice change being the obvious example), so someone may be able to return to living as male without lasting female characteristics. I've also engaged with other people's transition decisions. In January 2022 I commented on a partner's situation where the person considering top surgery was fine with their chest when alone but uncomfortable in public — I read that as possibly transitioning to escape sexism or further abuse, and flagged it as a mild red flag, while acknowledging that surgery is mentally taxing even for someone certain of their decision and that it's ultimately their call to make. In March 2022 I told someone they don't need to "act" as their assigned sex and that they can be male with feminine interests. In May 2022 I agreed with a comment about taking time off hormones or similar, saying "which is what many of us should have been doing in the first place." I have not described undergoing hormones, surgery, or a formal social transition in this transcript, nor have I described a formal detransition — my stance is that I chose not to transition in the first place, driven by a feminist reading of sex and sexism. I don't describe specific diagnoses, mental health conditions, trauma, family dynamics, or sexuality in these posts. My current identity, as far as this material goes, is a female person who identified with the trans/detrans community enough to post there, who considered transition but rejected it, and who now frames her body and sex in explicitly feminist, anti-sterotype terms.