Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition/desistenza e che per un periodo si è identificata come transmasc senza mai fare una transizione medica, e oggi mi identifico come maschiaccio che ama essere donna. Attribuisco a un momento di riflessione su di me il merito di non essere andata oltre, e faccio risalire la mia identificazione trans a un'infanzia che imponeva rigidi standard femminili e al risentimento verso la misoginia e i ruoli di genere imposti, più che a un desiderio di essere maschio. Sono critica verso la cultura della transizione adolescenziale, l'ossessione per BL/manhwa tra i transmasc e quelle che vedo come richieste irragionevoli sui pronomi da parte di sconosciuti. Non ho riferito interventi medici, ideazione suicidaria, autolesionismo né rimpianti per interventi, dato che non ne ho mai fatti.
Storia completa
I posted a vent in November 2024 about what I see in a lot of teenage trans men — kids who call themselves he/him while acting, in my words, "like drunk mentally blocked people" obsessed with gay manhwa, wearing emo fits with bright blue or red hair, pushing away contact with women, and then complaining that nobody wants them and everyone around them is transphobic. I said I worried about their futures because I don't think that act is sustainable once people grow out of their "hormone aided phase."
I never medically transitioned, but this could have been me. In a reply I wrote, "Could've been me too. Thank god I hesitated for a moment of self reflection first." I identified as transmasc for a while, and I never had an mlm relationship during that time, but through thorough reflection I realized what I actually wanted was to be treated as an equal rather than being "the girl" with the typical girl stereotypes in relationships. I wrote that I love being a woman but I hate misogyny, and I hate the rules about "being a woman" that stop her from appreciating life out of fear of "not being ladylike."
I traced a lot of that back to my childhood, which enforced every female standard — do chores, look pretty, do everything FOR A MAN — while boys could do anything without worry because "they're boys." I said I'm not currently comfortable with being "feminine" because of all that, but that it's not about wanting to be a man, it's about wanting to be equal. I've accepted that I'm just a tomboy. I also said I wish I were seen the way a boy is seen — not in a trans way, but in an equality-between-both-genders way, as a genuine person and not "a vessel of blood and flesh just there to birth a child and do chores." My conclusion was that women shouldn't feel like they have to BE a man to be treated equally.
I'm critical of the online culture around this. I think the backlash against fujoshis pushed some kids to want to be different, and that it gets weird when obsession turns into wanting to become a character in a gay anime/manhwa. I said I don't watch anime anymore and don't get the hype. I also said I'll never understand "gay trans femboys" — being gay, trans, and feminine as a person born female and calling yourself a femboy is, in my words, "literally just premium straight at that point." I argued that most BL relationships actually follow typical straight relationship standards (one who cooks and cleans, basically a wife, plus a strong breadwinner), so the only difference from straight ships is that they're both guys — meaning "i love gay relationships" is probably more like "i'm a straight girl obsessed with guys in general." I agreed that people appreciate mlm characters because they're depicted with actual feelings and personalities and treated like equal human beings, whereas most female representation is housewife, dramatic/obsessed girl, or other labels that degrade women, and I said more people would be comfortable in their female bodies if women were represented equally.
In January 2025 I commented that I don't have anything against trans people in general, but I'll never understand masculine-looking trans women or feminine-looking trans men complaining on TikTok about strangers using the wrong pronouns — noting it's never about people prominent in their life, but a single stranger not complying with their life choice being enough to ruin their day. I also described someone as a "positivity obsessive," saying you now have to be careful not to be "a little sunshine all day when you simply state the facts."
Current status: I identify as a woman, a tomboy, and I'm critical of transition, particularly for teenagers.