Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono nata femmina e non ho mai fatto una transizione medica, ma da giovane ho attraversato un periodo in cui mi identificavo con un'identità trans, e ora mi definisco una donna eterosessuale che ha desistito e non è trans. Ho un dottorato in biologia e sono fortemente critica verso ormoni e interventi per il disagio di genere, le cliniche del consenso informato e la transizione infantile, sostenendo che la professione medica sta venendo meno al suo dovere di cura. Dentro di me continuo a non sentirmi una donna e ho detto che, se potessi, forse sceglierei un corpo maschile, ma ho accettato la mia biologia e mi concentro sul lavoro, sugli hobby, sugli amici e sul mio ragazzo. Mi sono impegnata a consigliare i detransitioner e i desistenti più giovani e nell'attivismo per i diritti basati sul sesso e contro il linguaggio imposto. Non mi identifico come trans e non ho mai fatto ormoni né interventi chirurgici.
Storia completa
I have been posting in this community for years, and looking back over what I've written, a lot of it is me working through my own experience while advising others. I was born female. I have a PhD in biology, which shapes how I think about these debates — I've said plainly that I've "yet to be shown any evidence for gender being a thing at all."
I don't remember a specific age when body discomfort started for me, but I've described it as a phase I went through when younger: "It's a phase for quite a few people when they are younger, or when they are over 25 but dealing with difficult life situations." I've told others that almost all young people have some issue with their developing body or social role, and that "It isn't an illness." I never pursued hormones, surgery, or a social transition as far as anything in my posting history shows — I've said explicitly "I don't identify as trans."
What I do carry is a persistent mismatch between how I feel and my body. I've written: "I don't feel female either but I am. You can't change your sex." And: "If I was just a floating brain and had to choose a body, I might choose male instead of female... But that's not how it is so I just live life focusing on things I can control." I've also said, more recently, "I'd like to look in between, but my hips dont lie," and that I've thought about changing my body but never done it — "If it was risk free, maybe I'd do it." I don't love my body, but I describe myself as having accepted it: it's healthy, functional, and I don't require medication.
Sexuality has been part of my own story too. I've written that as an adolescent "First i thought i was bi. Turns out I'm really just into men (in my 30s now)... I'm a boring old straight." I've also described myself as goth, with an ex-boyfriend who was quite effeminate, and I currently have a boyfriend — I've mentioned that my breasts are small and that he likes big breasts, and I'm fine with that.
On the transition question generally, I'm strongly critical of how it's currently practiced. I've argued that hormones and surgeries "are not indicated for emotional/mental health issues" because there isn't enough evidence of efficacy and safety, and that the medical profession has a duty of care that isn't being met — comparing it to a barkeep serving a drunk. I've said informed consent clinics shouldn't exist in this form, that self-diagnosis plus drug selection shouldn't be possible for something this consequential, and that historically transition was rare (I cited roughly 1 in 50,000–100,000), reserved for older adults after years of therapy and a real-life test. I think childhood and teenage transition is especially wrong, and I've said the people to blame for a teenager's medical harm are the doctors, therapists, and guideline-writers, not the teenager.
I'm also critical of the social and ideological side. I've described trans communities as "members of a cult that peddles this ideology with hormones and surgeries," been sharply dismissive of AGP-identified males, and opposed things like males using female toilets. At the same time, I've said I don't care what others do as long as they don't involve unwilling people, children, or vulnerable people, and I've argued for teaming up with people I disagree with on other topics as long as we share this one view — otherwise the movement can't get big enough to push back.
I've given a lot of advice to younger detransitioners and desisters: be patient with reversing changes, don't rush reconstruction, keep busy with work, education, hobbies, exercise, get therapy, move out of your parents' house before making big decisions (I've said people should be at least 23, ideally late twenties), and remember that your life isn't ruined. I've told people that facial hair can be removed, voices can be trained or owned, breast forms and eventual reconstruction exist, and that you are still worthy of love. I've also suggested writing to the professionals who "helped" someone transition once they've processed things.
On my own advocacy, I've engaged heavily in these debates — arguing about duty of care, informed consent, compelled speech and pronouns, sex-based rights, and the science (or lack of it) behind gender. I've recommended resources like PubMed and a drug's SmPC for people doing their own research, and pointed others toward standingforwomen-type organisations. I've also advised someone to record a meeting where they were being pressured about pronouns, and suggested filing a sexual harassment complaint against a classmate who was pushing them to identify as trans.
Current status: I'm a detransitioned/desisted woman — I never medically transitioned, but I went through the psychological pull toward it, identified with it at points when younger, and now identify as straight, female, and not trans. I still don't feel like a woman internally, but I've accepted that I am one and focus on my job, hobbies, friends, and partner instead of my body.