Tutte le storie

Contare solo gli ormoni, non i nomi

Femmina · Detransizionato/a126
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una femmina che ha fatto detransizione e che ha detto che la sua transizione era «medica» e che aveva circa 16 anni a fine 2022, dopo averne avuti 7 nel 2013. In questi post non ho esposto una cronologia completa della transizione, ma conosco gli antiandrogeni e considero la HRT e la transizione medica il segno distintivo dell'essere trans. Sostengo con passione online che le statistiche sui trans dovrebbero contare solo chi fa davvero una transizione medica, non chi si limita a cambiare nome o pronomi. Sono critica verso certe figure trans di spicco e verso quelle che vedo come tendenze incel misogine tra gli uomini detrans. In questo materiale non ho descritto la mia identità attuale, il livello di rimpianto, la salute mentale né la qualità della vita dopo la detransizione.

Storia completa

I was born female. I have said that my reason for transitioning was medical rather than purely social or identity-based — when someone suggested otherwise I replied simply, "mine is medical." I was around 7 years old in 2013, which places my birth around 2006, and by late 2022 I was roughly 16 years old and active in detransition and trans-related discussions online. I have not written out a full timeline of my own transition in these posts, so I have not given ages for first dysphoria, coming out, hormones, or surgeries. What does come through is that I was on hormones and had experience with anti-androgens: when another detransitioner described their own experience, I asked directly, "what AA were you taking," which implies I had knowledge of, and likely personal experience with, anti-androgen medication as part of a feminising or masculinising regimen. I also argued strenuously that the meaningful measure of trans identity is medical transition itself — that "being transgender requires you to you know... be transgender.. and actually transition" — and I equated "become transgender" with "people who take HRT and medically transition," saying they were the "same thing." That framing suggests medical transition was central to how I understood my own experience. In debates about rising trans identification, I was sceptical of counting people who merely use new names or pronouns. I dismissed non-transitioning identity-only people (whom I referred to as "theyfabs") as irrelevant to transition-rate statistics, saying "the vast vast majority of them never transition so including them is stupid." I pushed repeatedly for hard data: "post rates for hrt or bust," and I asked whether anyone had "a study that compares the rates of hrt administration." I also warned against anecdotal reasoning, invoking survivorship bias and arguing we should look at actual rates rather than "extrapolate a bunch of maybe's and probably's based on huge assumptions." I defined being trans as "desiring to be the opposite sex." I was combative and dismissive toward people I saw as appropriating or distorting the discourse. I mocked the idea of surgical addiction with sarcasm: "hey doc could you hook me up with some extra mastectomy? that stuff really is addictive" followed by "yeahhh no." I was hostile toward Oli London ("yeah no, not oli london"), and I made a pointed comment about an older gay man, saying he was "angry that he aged and doesnt look like a teenager so gay men arent attracted to him anymore," and separately accused him of "loathing the fact that you dont look like a teenager anymore because gay men arent attracted to you anymore." I was also quick to dismiss interlocutors I found illegitimate, saying "literally no idea who you are" and accusing one of being "definitely not a sockpuppet created to make detransitioners look bad." On the question of detrans men specifically, I offered a blunt social analysis. Asked about detrans men, I said "Most of them are misogynistic incels and keep to themselves because of that," and I told someone to "just interact in male detrans spaces and you'll see." This suggests I had some familiarity with male detransitioner communities, at least observationally. I did not describe surgeries, complications, fertility concerns, or a formal detransition date in these comments. I did not discuss therapy, mental health diagnoses, trauma, family dynamics, sexuality, or current relationship status. My regret, if any, is not articulated here beyond the general framing that my transition was medical and that I now engage critically with the culture around it. I have not described any advocacy work beyond arguing in online comment threads.