Tutte le storie

ADHD e autismo hanno riletto la disforia

Maschio · Detransizionato/a361
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un uomo che ha detransizionato: ho fatto la transizione sui primi vent'anni dopo una disforia di genere iniziata con la pubertà, poi ho detransizionato dopo aver capito di non poter verificare un sentimento interiore e dopo che le diagnosi di ADHD e autismo hanno mostrato che il disagio aveva più origini. Ho provato un vero sollievo con la TOS, ma sono arrivato a vedere la transizione come il trattare un problema della mente o sociale come un problema del corpo. Ora mi identifico con il mio sesso biologico e sostengo cautela, valutazione e lavoro psicologico prima dei passi medici. Porto rimpianto per il tempo perso, un rapporto danneggiato con i miei genitori e cambiamenti corporei irreversibili, insieme a depressione, trauma e difficoltà sociali che continuano. Sono attivo nelle comunità detrans, offrendo sostegno e sostenendo che sia le persone trans sia quelle detrans esistono e che la medicina ha bisogno di più precauzione.

Storia completa

I was born male. I started feeling different when I was a teenager, around puberty — my body felt wrong and inside I felt like I should be a girl. It stayed with me through high school, where I looked it up online and found a lot of people saying they felt the same way; that is how I learned about gender identity and later about gender dysphoria. The feeling got stronger, I started picturing myself with a female body, and eventually I started HRT. After a while I felt great — the acne on my face disappeared, I felt happier than before, and I really liked the changes in my body. My girlfriend's parents found out I was on HRT and we broke up after that. After the breakup I started thinking about it again: what is gender identity, really? People say it is an inner feeling, but is that feeling actually real? Can I trust it? I realized inner feelings are just things I tell myself, or the feeling tells me something — no one can prove them. People lie to themselves and to other people too, so what I thought was true might not be true. I asked myself why I should use a feeling I cannot check to say who I am, when I could use facts that are already clear and not in doubt. That is why I chose to detransition. I used to believe that if my inner identity did not match my body then I was the other sex and should change my body to match. Now I think I am my biological sex. The discomfort is real, but that does not mean I have a right to change sex. Identity labels do not have to mean much, and changing the body is usually the wrong kind of fix — it treats a mind problem or a social problem like a body problem. Along the way I also came to see that I had treated my parents as the enemy back then. When I read about another person's mother crying, it brought back how I really treated my own parents as the enemy — I wonder how many others were the same. I have also reflected that in the world we live in, when someone is at their most vulnerable and most needs the right guidance, society often gives the wrong kind of influence instead; you were still very young then, and it's hard to see clearly at that age, so it isn't just on you. I am autistic, and later also diagnosed with ADHD, plus depression and some trauma. I started transitioning around the age of the person I was writing to (early twenties). My parents kept saying I wasn't trans and things got pretty bad between us for a while. Later I got diagnosed with ADHD and the doctor said I should get checked for ASD too; that came back confirmed. After that I slowly realized the discomfort was coming from more than one place, not just 'I must be the other sex,' and the gender stuff faded after that. None of that got taken seriously at first — everything just got dumped into the gender dysphoria bucket. I also relate to having to look all right when I aren't — the hidden grief, the 'tar across the windscreen' feeling, ordinary talk feeling like lying when most of my mind is somewhere else. I've been let down by friends I trusted, which made closeness feel hard, and I know isolation made things worse before: staying in front of a computer for hours tends to turn the anxiety up, not down. I've used breathing exercises my therapist taught me — in through the nose, out a little longer than the in-breath — to take the 'I'm about to be eaten alive' feeling down a notch. I have become more cautious about early medical steps, especially surgery. Psychological work and time should be the default, not the afterthought; the brain keeps developing well into the early thirties. What I have learned is: don't leave myself with no way out, especially when I am desperate to do something. I really wish I could go back ten years so I could avoid all the things which cause the pain I have now. On the wider question, I think the pain of gender dysphoria is real and I don't want it to be denied, and I also don't want it to be used. I really like Dr. Mark Yarhouse's books — he is one of the few experts actually willing to look for many different solutions for gender dysphoria. I think the system needs to help people understand where the distress begins: whether it is driven by depression, autism, trauma, social anxiety, same-sex attraction, isolation, or the internet amplifying the pain, and whether it has been forced into a framework that names every discomfort 'gender.' Medical intervention should always be cautious. Pain is not automatic evidence that the body is wrong; the first step is to understand the pain, not to drug the body in order to serve an image. I have also thought a lot about the wider picture: HRT is in many ways a low-cost solution that was already available and creates a straightforward market, so there is less pressure to develop better alternatives or rigorously track what happens over decades. We still have very limited high-quality data on what 10, 20, or 30+ years of cross-sex hormones actually do. I have friends who work in medical and pharmaceutical research; they told me that although targeted treatments for gender dysphoria are technically possible, the total number of trans people is too small compared with heart disease, cancer, and dementia to be worth the investment, while current HRT has almost no research cost, a stable market, and is very profitable. I have also raised questions about the biology: intersex is a disorder of sex development, not a third sex; and I have questioned the claim that we 'all begin female,' sharing research links on that debate. I have also wondered aloud whether gender dysphoria has ever been observed in animals, since same-sex behavior is, which raises the question of whether it is psychiatric and cultural in origin. I try to be careful in discussion and to repair misunderstandings: when someone pushed back on my intersex comment, I came back and clarified that I agreed with their points and hadn't meant to argue. I have also been critical of how identity and clinical condition have been conflated — DSM-5's Gender Dysphoria centers distress, while ICD-11's Gender Incongruence removed the distress requirement, which shifts the justification for medical intervention from treating suffering to aligning the body with an identity. I am cautious about political framing too: I have argued that policy moves toward more assessment and gatekeeping are closer to the protection I needed at the time, rather than a hunt aimed at people who already transitioned and detransitioned. I believe there are real trans people and real detrans people, and that medicine around gender distress needs more precaution, not more certainty. I have told others that 'there is nothing wrong with the body; it's the mind that needs fixing' should be a normal thing to say, and that regret is real, the body is not the enemy, and people who already went through this should be allowed to talk. I have also advised people to sit with pain rather than change the body, to hold off on irreversible steps through puberty, not to let online groups and schools be the only voice, to remember that an identity can be taken back while surgery and long-term hormones mostly can't, and that 'you'll be happier' isn't a promise we can make because we still don't have ten- and twenty-year outcomes. I have recommended Beyond Trans support groups and Detrans Help as resources, and suggested gender-exploratory therapy rather than therapy that only affirms or only pushes back.