Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una femmina in detransition/desistenza che ha vissuto una grave disforia di genere fin da prima della pubertà e un trauma religioso dalla scuola religiosa, e a gennaio 2024, quando ho scritto per la prima volta, mi consideravo una potenziale persona in transizione, gravemente depressa, suicidaria e autolesionista. Dopo aver cercato aiuto medico a marzo 2024 per difficoltà scolastiche e di salute, mi è stato prescritto il Lexapro, che nel giro di due settimane ha ridotto in modo significativo la mia disforia e mi ha fatto sentire più a mio agio con una presentazione femminile e aperta all'attrazione verso gli uomini. Ora mi orienterei verso il vivere come persona non conforme al genere piuttosto che come uomo transitato, anche se voglio ancora il testosterone e forse un giorno un intervento, e continuo a sentirmi a disagio quando mi chiamano 'ragazza' o 'lei' e felice quando mi chiamano 'fratello' o 'figlio'. Non ho fatto alcun intervento di transizione medica. Sono diventata una voce attiva nella comunità detrans, difendendo le persone GNC e mettendo in dubbio la ROGD.
Storia completa
I first reached out to this community in January 2024, asking for perspectives on my gender dysphoria because none of the usual explanations offered in other posts resonated with me. I had been a lurker, hoping to find an alternative to transition, but I needed to lay out my own background to get real feedback.
My dysphoria started slightly before puberty. While my female classmates talked excitedly about starting their periods and becoming women, I was praying my chest wouldn't grow. When puberty did start for me, I felt ashamed — I hid the fact that I'd started my period from classmates, and I became extremely uncomfortable with my body and the changes it was undergoing. I had foolishly expected my body to just grow into a man's body, so seeing myself take on female anatomy was incredibly distressing.
I was raised and educated in religious elementary and high schools, where I developed religious trauma. I've argued to myself that my dysphoria and my religious trauma (RTS) have no correlation, though I've invited others to dispute that. In my own interpretation of my faith, masculinity is defined by what a man does — his role in family and community — rather than by looks. This family/community-centered view of manhood is something I feel deeply connected to. I want to be a father, a husband, a brother. I want to do the things associated with manhood and I want to be perceived as a male, point blank. I accept I'll never have the specific experiences or biology of a biological man, but I can't accept associating myself with womanhood when there's a disconnect in my head.
I tried to convince myself I might just be gay, but I felt very disconnected from the idea of being a woman who likes women. I tried indulging in feminine things, but remained detached from everything I associated with womanhood. I do have a deep appreciation for women, femininity and womanhood — I see it as a tough, thankless yet rewarding journey — but that admiration is all it will ever be. I don't identify with terms like non-binary or genderqueer because, in my view, I'm either a woman or a man; I'm conservative on that because of how familiar those two categories feel.
I'm not from the West. I'm North African, living in a Western country for now, but surrounded by my community. In my home culture there is essentially no concept of gender dysphoria — it's either unknown or considered a deviance. There's no space for questioning your gender; my peers and I weren't exposed to gender identity at all. I had difficulty following gender expectations without having a dissociative episode, and it took me a while to understand my experiences were tied to gender dysphoria rather than just wanting to be a 'hardcore tomboy.' For every trans person I met in my community, I met two desisters. I've also noted that faith is used as a coping mechanism for dysphoria by people in my community who recognize it — an acquaintance of mine got much more religious while detransitioning and seems much happier and fulfilled.
At the time of my first post, I was in a horrible place. I was incredibly depressed, felt I was at rock bottom with no hope and a bleak future. I really wanted to pursue sex reassignment surgeries because of how bad the dysphoria was affecting my mental health. I lived in constant fear of my loved ones finding out who I truly was and believed they would never accept me. My dysphoria had come to define me in certain ways — I would dress to 'hide' myself and talk in vague terms to avoid using feminine descriptors on myself. I considered suicide and did engage in self-harming behavior. I had also suffered from severe gender dysphoria to the point of suicidal ideation more broadly.
I also dealt with introspection and isolation as my primary coping tools for my trauma, using them to recognize patterns and behaviors stemming from it. I noted my situation wasn't well suited for therapy at the time, though I was open to trying Acceptance and Commitment therapy.
Things began to shift in March 2024. I was facing academic difficulties because of my physical and mental health, and I decided to take my own advice and seek help. I landed on an expensive but incredible clinic. The doctor was kind and, for the first time, I felt heard by a medical professional — though I did not tell her about my gender dysphoria because I didn't want it on my medical file. She told me I might need treatment for my mental health. I was hesitant but decided to give it a shot since I couldn't go lower than rock bottom. She prescribed me Lexapro.
Within about two weeks of taking it, my dysphoria felt significantly less severe. I became more comfortable experimenting with my gender expression and even my sexuality — I had initially assumed I was only attracted to women, but I found myself more open to liking men. I stopped being harsh on my own body; I was wearing a necklace and earrings and looking at myself in the mirror with a smile instead of feeling the need to rip them off. I was more inclined to lead a life as a gender non-conforming person than as a transitioned man. I still want to take testosterone at some point and am still considering surgery — just not under the 'transgender man' label necessarily. I'm still uncomfortable being called 'girl', 'sis' or 'she', and I still dislike imagining being called a wife, daughter or sister, and I'm still happy being referred to as a brother or son. But I no longer feel as hopeless. I suspect my dysphoria may have roots in my trauma or depression.
I've also become vocal in the community. I've defended gender non-conforming women against hostile comments, argued that women and men don't owe anyone conformity, and pushed back against the idea that GNC presentation should be policed in a support space. I've also expressed confusion about ROGD, questioning how dysphoria could be both caused by personal factors like trauma and autism and also 'contagious', and I've distinguished between the trendy 'queer aesthetics' of being trans online and actual gender dysphoria, which I've suffered from severely. I remain somewhat critical of how Western political framing gets extended to non-Western countries with different values and priorities.