Tutte le storie

Dubbi a 15 anni, risolti da una ragazza, un lavoro e una palestra di arrampicata

Maschio · Desistito/a38
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un uomo che ha fatto detransition/desistito e ha evitato del tutto la transizione medica dopo che i primi dubbi sul mio genere si sono risolti quando ho trovato successo sentimentale, un lavoro e degli hobby. Credo che la maggior parte del disagio di genere nasca da status sociale e appartenenza più che dal genere in sé, e sono critico verso la facilità con cui si distribuiscono ormoni. Attribuisco alla comunità detrans e a podcast come Calmversations il merito di avermi fatto sentire meno solo. Ora ho una ragazza, una famiglia vicina e hobby appaganti tra cui musica, arrampicata e videogiochi. Sostengo la desistenza come scelta predefinita più sana per i giovani incerti.

Storia completa

I was born male and desisted early, before ever going through any medical transition. I describe myself as having felt "pretty crap as a guy (bio boy lol)" for most of my life, and I was very sex-and-love obsessed, which made me unsure about my gender especially when I couldn't get romantic success, didn't have a decent salary, and didn't have hobbies. My doubts about being "good enough" or "a real man" only stopped once I accumulated romantic encounters, a job, and hobbies — so I now frame my gender distress as rooted in social status and belonging rather than in my actual sex. I had conservative but very warm parents who were fine with me being gay, just not with me dressing feminine, and they didn't judge me for certain styles or outfits. Because of that, I feel my social situation was at an acceptable level, and I only went through brief periods of sexual frustration and alienation — never enough to seriously consider transitioning. I did check my hormone values at one point, and doctors told me it was "not a medical issue," which scared me in hindsight: "Fuck, I could have gotten real fucked up." I'm explicitly grateful I didn't go down a medical path, and I say I'm "a bit scared of what would have happened 10 years later when the trans-cult and medical pipelines are in full swing." Before desisting, I had friends I met in PUA (pickup artist) communities who later transitioned and then detransitioned after falling into what I call the incel-trans "transmaxx" pipeline. One friend who transitioned was, in my words, "super lucky that he never got sterilized and now has a loving wife and son." These experiences shape my current views strongly. I have never had therapy specifically for detransition described here, but I do credit a YouTube podcast called "Calmversations" and the detrans community on YouTube with helping me feel less alone. I also read and think about political theory — I reference Marxist arguments about making everything political to force centrists to take a side, and I'm critical of what I see as a "lefty zeitegeist" that insists everything is internal and self-love should always be present, when in reality people need external achievements, belonging, and hope. I now believe that for most people, gender distress is really about social situation or status, not gender itself: "Most of the time the issue is with your social situation or your current status, not actually your gender." I think transitioning is not appropriate for about 95% of the people currently allowed to do it, and that most people who want to transition are really imagining they'd be at the top of the other gender, which isn't the typical experience. I also argue that most males and women have wanted to switch gender at some point, largely because of that fantasy. I see modern culture as having over-complicated gender: "You just have to be born female to be female. It doesnt go away just because you took hormones." I support desisting as the healthier default when someone is unsure, because it lets the body self-regulate naturally. I also hold a somewhat controversial view that many people who become trans in recent years are essentially escaping an unstable "emotional/identity ecosystem" in the way others historically became drug addicts, alcoholics, anorectics, or munchausen-syndrome patients. Currently I have a girlfriend, a family I'm close to, and I occupy myself with music, games, climbing, building muscle, and friends. I advocate for channeling obsession into something other than the idea that changing one thing (gender) will fix everything, and I encourage others to keep improving incrementally ("0.01% everytime") rather than waiting for perfection. I'm critical but not hostile in tone when responding to people considering transition — I try to get them to see things from an outsider's perspective and question whether a sex-change would really help an unsure young person. I don't describe any surgeries, hormones, or puberty blockers because I never had them. I don't describe any formal mental health diagnoses. I don't describe suicidal ideation or self-harm. My regret is mostly counterfactual — gratitude that I avoided medical transition rather than grief over losses I actually sustained.