Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna detransizionata sulla trentina che vive in Brasile e scrive in spazi gender critical e detrans, anche se in questi commenti non ho esposto la cronologia della mia transizione o detransizione. Sostengo che esistono solo due generi, che essere uomo o donna è un fatto biologico e non un sentimento, e che l'espressione di genere è separata dal sesso. Paragono la comunità trans alle sette e alle chiese evangeliche brasiliane perché isolano e ripudiano chi se ne va, e racconto di essere stata respinta nella comunità LGBT per aver espresso queste idee con rispetto. Sostengo che la disforia è reale ma la transizione non è l'unica via d'uscita, paragonandola all'assecondare la dismorfia corporea, e incoraggio la terapia con un terapeuta imparziale. Non ho descritto ideazione suicidaria, autolesionismo né dettagli medici in questo materiale.
Storia completa
I am a 35-year-old woman living in Brazil, and I have been writing in detransition and gender-critical spaces to share the conclusions I have reached about gender, identity, and transition. I have never described my own transition timeline in these comments, so I do not lay out ages for dysphoria, coming out, hormones, or surgery here — what I offer instead is my thinking and how I came to hold it.
I compare the trans community to cults and evangelical churches. I say I do not know what churches are like in the United States, but here in Brazil they act in a way that isolates people from the real world, and when that person decides to leave the church, all ties are broken and the person is completely isolated and treated as persona non grata. I see the same pattern when people leave the trans community. For me, that way of dealing with dissent only shows the fragility of trans discourse: when we are confident in our convictions, we do not need to reject and block people who do not think like us.
I have been rejected for saying what I think, even respectfully. I write that things are extremely confusing in the LGBT community, at least for me. My conception of gender is that there are only two; I do not believe that gender is an individual social construction as they preach — a social construction, perhaps. We are men and women, but how we will be, what kind of men or women we will be, only concerns ourselves. Every gender expression should be valid: a man who likes to wear makeup, or a woman who hates makeup. Neither is any less their gender for that. When I dared to say what I think, even respectfully, I was rejected, and I described that as sad.
I also push back on the pressure to seek acceptance over critical thinking. I write that we live with this idea that all that matters is acceptance and we are discouraged from using critical thinking; we are no longer encouraged to use our brains and really dig deep. When someone goes deeper, questions, rethinks and comes to their own conclusions, that person is rejected, put in a box, and seen as dangerous.
In direct replies to people questioning their gender, I am affectionate but blunt. I tell one person there is no such thing as "being a real girl" — you are a girl just because you were born with the xx chromosome; how you express yourself in a body that has the xx chromosome is up to you, and every way of expressing yourself is valid. I frame this as a 35-year-old woman, a cringe millennial who has seen some changes in the world, and I say we spend too much time trying to fit in and think deeply about things that just are the way they are. I tell them to take care of themselves and not try to be anything other than what they already are.
To another person worried about which gender they "look better" as, I say they shouldn't worry about it: being a man or a woman is not about what suits you and makes you beautiful. You are only a woman because you were born with an xx chromosome, that is a fact. There is no right or wrong way to be a woman, we just are. I urge them to take the time to discover what kind of woman they will be without seeking validation from strangers on the internet, and I say I wrote it with the greatest love, talking to them the way I would talk to my best friend.
My most developed argument is about dysphoria and treatment. I say gender dysphoria is real and many people suffer from it, but it does not mean the only way out of it is transition. I compare it to body dysmorphia: would you tell a person with body dysmorphia that the best way to solve the problem is to accept that they do not see themselves as thin enough and continue toward extreme thinness, bulimia and anorexia, or would you advise mental health treatment? A good therapist who is not biased can help get to the root of the problems and from there help get on the path to a solution. My personal opinion is that being a woman or a man is not a feeling — it is a biological fact. No one needs to feel like a man or a woman to be a man or a woman. If you, as a man, like to wear makeup, wear dresses, do ballet, that does not make you any less of a man. My struggle today is to fight against stereotypes of this type: being a man or a woman only has to do with our biology, and not with how we choose to express ourselves in our bodies. I wish the person happiness regardless of which path they choose.
I also try to be supportive when someone is in pain, telling them the bad feelings will pass, everything is temporary, and that is the only truth in life, and that everything can get better. I have cheered people on in their own journeys with comments like "I'm proud of you" and encouragement to keep going. I have not described any medical procedures, mental health diagnoses, or personal adversity in these comments, and I have not described an advocacy role beyond participating in these discussions.