Tutte le storie

Ungheria conservatrice a 16 anni, e la comunità che l’ha dissuasa

Femmina · Desistito/a-19
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna in detransizione/desistenza: mi identifico come donna cis, a volte “o qualcosa del genere”, e non ho mai fatto un intervento genitale. Crescendo nell’Ungheria cristiana e conservatrice, a 16 anni mi sono interrogata sul mio genere, ma la comunità trans mi ha dissuasa dalla transizione, e a questo attribuisco il merito di avermi salvato la vita. Ho ADHD (Ritalin), PCOS, un ginocchio malandato e in passato una diagnosi errata di psicosi invece di BPD, di cui incolpo lo psichiatra e non la cura. Sono una sociologa bisessuale e ora sostengo uno screening psicologico approfondito prima della transizione, pur sostenendo con forza la transizione per chi ne trae davvero beneficio, e incolpo il gaslighting medico e la sanità privatizzata anziché le procedure in sé. Sono critica verso il discorso dispettoso e cronicamente online sia nei subreddit detrans sia in quelli trans.

Storia completa

I was born female and grew up in Hungary, in a conservative Christian background. I first questioned my gender around 16, when an older trans woman told me, "Just because you don't meet the conventional standards of womanhood, does not mean you are not a woman." That sentence, she says, "spun my world around as a 16 years old, and continues to define how I see gender." I spent time in trans communities, which I credit with keeping me from transitioning: "At the end of the day I am alive today because they were there. Because a community (not ideology) was patient enough to sit with my stupid ass and was inclusive even if I was unsure." I describe myself variously as a "desister" and a "detrans female," and also as a "cis woman" — at 22 I say "I am a cis woman or something of the sort." I never wanted bottom surgery. I have PCOS, which causes facial hair growth, and I have double-D breasts that I dislike mainly because "my back is dying from them," not because they make me feminine; I don't want children. I have a bad knee that I manage with a cane and was pressured toward knee replacement surgery by private care, which I refused. I was also prescribed Ritalin for ADHD, and I describe a past misdiagnosis: a psychiatrist treated me for psychosis when I actually had BPD — "I am hella mad at the psychiatrist who fucked up my diagnosis." I have a degree in sociology and work in food service. I am bisexual, having dated six boyfriends and one girlfriend, and I experience biphobia from lesbians, gay men, and straight people. I have a trans woman roommate and many trans friends, none of whom had an issue with my detransition. I identify as a gender abolitionist, egalitarian, and feminist, and I believe gender is a social construct. I strongly support transition for those who want it, while insisting on thorough psychological evaluation beforehand: "Should there be tons of psychological exames before one transitions... YES. THERE SHOULD BE." I blame individual doctors and a profit-driven, privatized healthcare system rather than the treatments themselves: "The real enemy isn't the surgery, it's medical gaslighting and a profit oriented Healthcare system." I am critical of what I see as chronically online, spiteful discourse on both detrans and trans subreddits, and I argue that banning transition does not help, citing Hungary's ban and high trans suicide rates there.