Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition e che per anni è andata avanti e indietro: sono rimasta in terapia con il testosterone perché smetterlo mi causava un forte malessere, mentre mentalmente facevo detransition e mi accettavo come donna con un’esperienza transmaschile. Ho iniziato il T nella prima ventina, dopo anni di attesa perché i miei genitori erano cristiani fondamentalisti, e sono dichiarata come trans da una dozzina d’anni. Ho cominciato la detransition dopo essere stata aggredita verbalmente per la mia attrazione per persone dello stesso sesso, e da allora ho ripreso la transizione medica in un periodo, senza mai voler rifare la transizione sociale. Ora penso che la transizione medica non valga la pena: voglio preservare la mia fertilità per partorire e ho concluso che il mio problema è nel cervello, non nel corpo. La disforia mi torna ancora a ondate brutte, ma lavoro per una vita più semplice, meno centrata sul genere.
Storia completa
I was born female and I've been dysphoric for as long as I can remember — since my first memories, though I'm still not entirely sure why. My parents were and are fundamentalist Christians, so I couldn't transition as a young teen; I waited years and started testosterone in my very early twenties, and I'm now in my late twenties. I'm glad in hindsight that I went through my first puberty and fully developed before starting T.
I spent about a dozen years out as trans. I like the changes testosterone gave me — I like looking superficially male, and I'm read as a man in day-to-day life by most people, based on my face and voice, with or without binding. When I first tried feminizing early on, people assumed I was a Black trans woman, which was uncomfortable. I've had bacterial vaginosis on and off for several months early in taking testosterone, which resolved eventually; I suspect it may have been linked to T but I'm unsure. My nose also got slightly bigger on T, and it looked smaller when I was off it. I've had bottom growth, and my partners have liked it.
I tried going off hormones at one point and it didn't go well — I had never been more sad about being female, it felt like I was grieving my life, and it caused dysphoria. Because of that I prefer to stay on hormones. Sexually, T made my sexuality confusing rather than changing it: on T I had a high sex drive with no clear direction and identified as an aromantic, sex-favorable asexual, but off T I was blatantly and clearly attracted to women. Going back on T made me feel directionless again, so I think it's the T.
I've gone back and forth about detransitioning for a long time. I identify strongly with my femaleness and have sentimental feelings about being a woman, a lesbian, and about motherhood — I feel a strong desire to give birth and breastfeed, and things about motherhood make me feel most sentimental about my body. I'm changing careers to a female-dominated field. I feel deeply connected to women. At the same time, I don't like that I want to be a man; I feel imposter syndrome when people address me as a man and I look in the mirror and see a female. I feel caught between a rock and a hard place — both transition and detransition give me distress for different reasons. I've largely let go of trying to be a cis man and have started accepting myself as a woman of transmasculine experience, or adjacent to men rather than a man. I like being a brother, a boyfriend, and the future concept of being a dad on a social level, and I wouldn't want to change my pronouns — I know lesbians who use he/him as an expression of masculinity, including me. I also value femininity and feminine traits over masculinity even though I present masculinely.
I eventually started detransitioning because I was berated for being same-sex attracted. I decided everything transition-related is entirely cosmetic and doesn't make me a man to any degree, no matter how many people read me as one. I want to preserve my fertility — I want to be a parent in the future and give birth — and I don't want to remove organs off feelings. I decided my problem is in my brain, not my body, so I should have mental-health-related treatments. It was also the little things: it's annoying to inject myself every week, and I looked older on testosterone. I've had really bad bouts of "dysphoria" since detransitioning, and I did retransition at one point and have considered retransitioning — but only medically, not socially; I don't think I ever want to socially retransition. For me it goes up and down and feels normal. Lately I've concluded medical transition just isn't worth it — I don't want to be a patient forever, and the less I do to my body, the less I think about gender and the simpler my life is.
I've struggled with dissociation, which I've called torture, and with feeling my body is "incomplete." I also felt that accepting I'm a woman was protective: if anyone called me a woman it couldn't hurt me because I'd already accepted the thing I was trying to obscure. I've been self-conscious in public — when someone calls me sir I feel I need to hunch over and hide my chest so they aren't uncomfortable if they see I have breasts, and I've felt weird dabbling in wearing bras while being read as a man. I've also dealt with feeling male-averse generally, which makes my own desire to be male confusing and aversive to myself.
On politics and community: I'm a leftist, but I feel disconnected from the trans community and trans liberation spaces, and I don't like a lot of the popular rhetoric in activist spaces. I think the sexes of male and female are real and that acknowledging them is a good thing, and I'm dissatisfied with the circular logic of "a woman/man/nonbinary person is someone who identifies as one." I watched the Daily Wire/Matt Walsh documentary and wrote detailed notes — I found Walsh's buzzwords and the deceptive interview setup frustrating, I thought Scott Newgent's segment on the pharmaceutical industry profiting off transition was important, and I related strongly to the therapist Sara Stockton's concerned-but-supportive stance. I was upset by Dr. Marci Bowers dismissing BIID as a fetish, and disappointed by Dr. Michelle Forcier prescribing blockers and hormones to young children. I don't want this issue framed as conservative vs. progressive. I've advocated for better informed consent — I think people should be assessed for the full range of consequences including detransition — and I believe responsibility for treating gender dysphoria as a medical condition lies substantially with doctors. I also think detransition is a real possibility people should factor into their decisions, regardless of how long or intensely they've had dysphoria.
I've given a lot of advice to others in the community — about waiting, about the lighter regret of waiting versus the heavier regret of transition, about bodies and self-acceptance — and I like seeing detrans and questioning stories because it makes me feel less alone. I do these conversations one-to-one with my inner circle, but I'm not vocal publicly; I just can't or don't know how to.