Tutte le storie

Due mesi senza estrogeni, in lutto per ciò che hanno cambiato

Maschio · Detransizionato/a483
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un uomo che ha detransizionato: mi sono identificato come trans, ho preso estrogeni e a febbraio 2024 ero fermo con la TOS da circa due mesi. Mi sento orgoglioso, speranzoso e più sano mentalmente e fisicamente da quando ho detransizionato, anche se piango i cambiamenti femminilizzanti del mio corpo e mi preoccupo di effetti duraturi come una possibile infertilità. Sono apertamente critico verso la transizione, la moderazione di Reddit e le comunità trans, pur riconoscendo in privato che alcune persone traggono davvero beneficio dalla transizione e che gran parte della mia rabbia è lutto. Non ho descritto interventi né pensieri suicidi.

Storia completa

I was born male, and for a while I identified as transgender — I used to browse MTF subreddits and get euphoric when trans people got validated or when people got banned for disagreeing. Looking back now, I call that version of me "just a confused idiot." At some point I started hormones (estrogen), and by early 2024 I was about two months off HRT, in the process of detransitioning. The physical changes are what weigh on me most. In February 2024 I wrote that I wished I could return my body to how it was before, that I felt "kind of feminine in a way I didn't before" and that it "feels wrong right now." I described myself as "a man with feminized body parts." I had worried I would never recover erections at all, but roughly two months off HRT I was pleased that function was returning. I also told another detransitioner worried about physical changes to check their female hormone levels, noting that testosterone levels can stay high in female detransitioners after quitting HRT — I seemed aware of how hormones behave after stopping. I told someone going off T that I believed there was a higher chance of T coming back than not. Mentally, detransition has been a relief. In February 2024 I said plainly: "I feel proud rather than ashamed. I feel hope instead of increasing worries and desperation. I feel healthier, mentally, physically." By March 2024 I said that although I sometimes felt pissed that I ever questioned my gender and used hormones, "as I'm overcoming the damage, it is getting so so much better." I added that if I were left with something like permanent infertility I'd be "pissed for a long time" — so fertility is a live concern for me, though I haven't stated whether it was actually affected. I don't describe any surgeries of my own. My detransition has been emotional in a different way too: grief. I said that from my first weeks after choosing to detransition I went from "saying some really offensive stuff to some trans people" to eventually understanding that some people really do have a certain nature. I now tell others that developing aversion to trans people after detransition is a product of grief — "Who wants to be a hater?" — and I push back on the idea that figuring out you weren't trans means you've "figured out gender," because there are people who genuinely benefit from transitioning. That said, my public positions are strongly critical of transition. I hold that gender, like sex, is in our chromosomes, and that gender dysphoria is essentially a rejection of one's gender that can be overcome by training your own cognitive abilities rather than by transitioning. I've written that transition "is taking things too far," that males on estrogen are "just rebels," and that a male trying to be female is "very problematic." In a long post aimed at a man wanting to be a woman, I argued that the desire itself is the problem — that it may come from a man's own sexuality or from bad experiences unique to men — and that taking female hormones won't turn you into a woman; I framed the loss of penile function as symbolic: "you don't restart life as a woman, you fail as a man." I believe gender is not a choice and that the path to a happier life is taking responsibility for the body you actually have. I'm also highly critical of how trans issues are handled online. I've complained that Reddit bans people for slipping a slur in detrans spaces while allowing trans subs to "convince teenagers into transitioning," and that Reddit is perhaps the number one social media platform in providing validation for trans people. I wrote a post cataloguing the suffering I'd seen reported by partners of trans people on Reddit — partners describing coldness, panic attacks during sex, demands for open relationships, abuse excused as "transphobia" — and said it was messed up that there's pressure not to call an abusive trans partner abusive. I've said trans subs ostracize anyone who says "you are probably not trans," and that this behavior is what drives detransitioners to become disgusted with the trans community. I've also expressed hostility toward trans women specifically, describing them as a threat and recounting refusing to sell bread to one because they gave me "creep vibes." I recommended a YouTube channel of another detrans person as a good example of "being detrans and talking bout it." On sexuality, I've said I don't obsess over breast size, that I appreciate the aesthetic of a fit female body, and I've argued that women's bad sexual experiences aren't an inherent part of being female but a consequence of moral decay in the world — while also saying men don't live on a sexual pedestal and that women also harm men's sexuality. I try to be understanding of how the female body can feel like a curse or a blessing, and I've said men making women feel they owe them their bodies is wrong. Current status: I am a detransitioned man. I live as a man, I've been off hormones for a couple of months as of early 2024, I feel mentally and physically healthier than during transition, and I'm working through grief and physical changes — some of which I hope continue to reverse. I'm outspokenly critical of transition as an approach, while acknowledging (in quieter moments) that some people benefit from it and that my own anger is partly grief.