Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto la detransizione/desistenza, che non ha mai fatto una transizione medica ma ci è andata vicino: mi identificavo come agender e ho preso seriamente in considerazione un cambio di nome sociale e la transizione prima di desistere dopo i 18 anni. Attribuivo la mia disforia a un intenso dismorfismo corporeo (seno piccolo, busto grande) oltre al non rientrare nella femminilità stereotipata, all'amore per il karate e all'avversione per trucco e pettegolezzi, e al disagio attorno alle altre donne. Ora mi accetto come femmina, mi alleno e respingo la pressione a essere "più femmina", anche se a volte provo ancora un'agonia per il mio corpo e per la reazione della società verso di me. Sono critica verso la transizione come fenomeno politico/culturale e sostengo attivamente gli altri nelle comunità detrans. Non ho diagnosi di salute mentale, interventi né uso di ormoni dichiarati.
Storia completa
I was born female and grew up as a tomboy who never felt 'female enough' for the stereotypical version of womanhood my peers seemed to demand. Looking back, I told people I was 'agender' because I was uncomfortable with my body and my social status — girls my age were expected to be extremely feminine in a stereotypical way, and I never fit that mold.
There were several things that pointed me toward transitioning back then. First, I didn't feel 'female enough' to be a stereotypical woman, so I concluded I must not be a woman — I felt very intense body dysmorphia that I interpreted as gender dysphoria. I never felt adequate as a woman because of my small cup size combined with a large torso. Second, I really enjoyed karate and I hated gossip, makeup, and heels. Third, I never took care of my appearance as much as most women I know do. Fourth, I always felt uncomfortable in places with too many women. Fifth, I can fix stuff and open bottles and cans. All of that put together made me feel that maybe I was born in the wrong body.
During that turbulent period I started wearing only black clothes and jeans, stopped combing my hair, started dating only women, and was considering a social name change and transitioning. I was moving toward it but never actually started hormones or had any surgeries — I was lucky enough to not transition, I just really started looking forward to it but I desisted.
Eventually I grew up and, after 18, felt much more comfortable with my body and understood that I'm an individual and there is not one right way of being a female or male — people just are. I stopped putting pressure on myself to 'be male' and started pushing back on people's pressure to make me 'more female' (for instance friends telling me to wear makeup). I gave up referring to myself as 'agender' because I didn't 'feel female' most of the time, and I wouldn't say I'm 'non-binary' either. I just AM a female and I don't have to feel comfortable about people's expectations or society's pressures at all times.
A specific moment that helped me accept myself as a woman was when I decided to play fight with my ex and, in a fraction of a second, he turned me into a little ball on the ground. He didn't have to try hard or struggle — he's just a man. That was painful for me to accept but it taught me a lot: trying to be a man will never make you one. I understand times are tough and I hope my journey of self-discovery keeps getting more fun.
I still experience a degree of 'agony' over my body and my gender plus society's reaction to my existence, but it's possible to survive and just be, without becoming someone else. I don't think dysphoria existing implies transition is an obvious solution to all possible issues. I also think gender roles are imposed on us by biology and society, gender isn't a very well defined box that everyone will neatly fit into, and there are many ways of being a man or a woman.
I picked up the habit of going to the gym, which helped me feel more wholesome, and I focused on finding myself outside of gender and other labels — looking for things I like to do and people I like to talk to, eating and sleeping well, exercising, and having good friends who won't judge me for labels and aren't scared of having different opinions.
I've been active in detrans communities offering support to others. In one notable exchange I wrote a long, highly-upvoted comment to someone who had been through a lot, telling them to be gentle with themselves, that they're still human and lovable, and that many people who never transitioned also have issues with their gender. I've encouraged others to check out other detrans people's journeys as a way out of agony and into healthier self-discovery.
I hold critical views about transition as a political and cultural phenomenon. I've argued that cults and disenfranchised groups are useful for intellectual maniacs to push their ideology, citing Herbert Marcuse's essay on liberation as an example of how intellectuals weaponize confused young people and poor populations for political ends. I believe such thinkers destroy solid concepts and institutions by deconstructing them and causing confusion, then propose nothing realistic to replace them. I've pointed to what I see as serious risks in the scientific literature on transitioning that, in my view, no one inside the movement will talk about, and I've argued that after you've served some political group's interests you're no longer useful to them. I've also said things like 'Biology doesn't care about our feelings' when challenged.
I've been critical of the idea that women should transition because of abuse and a feeling of lack of control, saying they will not become powerful if they try to be a dude — even men are afraid of other men. I've advised having reasonable expectations and standards for yourself and finding your good qualities. When criticized for this, I responded that it's just my opinion versus theirs and that biology doesn't care about our feelings.
I don't have any stated mental health diagnoses, but I've described intense body dysmorphia that I mistook for gender dysphoria, and periods of feeling drained and exhausted. I've dealt with a painful breakup and separation from someone I trusted with my deepest fears, and I related to the feeling of 'I gotta learn to stfu.' I recommended writing as a way to vent, meditation, deep breathing, and looking at other detrans journeys for motivation.
On sexuality, I started dating only women during my questioning period. I don't state my current sexuality. I don't describe any family rejection or support, and I don't mention career or fertility concerns.