Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono un uomo, nato maschio, che ha fatto detransition: ho vissuto come donna trans per circa tre anni con gli ormoni prima di fare la detransition intorno al 2018. Ho fatto la transizione per insicurezza sulla mia sessualità e omofobia interiorizzata, dopo aver fatto prima coming out come gay, ma ho finito per capire che il passing era impossibile e che essere donna non ero davvero io. Da quando ho fatto detransition la mia salute mentale è migliorata nettamente: l'ideazione suicidaria settimanale, le fantasie di suicidio e i crolli emotivi sviluppati durante la transizione sono spariti tutti quando mi sono impegnato a vivere da uomo. Resto frustrato dagli effetti permanenti della terapia ormonale, in particolare un «viso da bambino» e il tessuto mammario permanente, anche se la mia fertilità è risultata normale. Ora sono critico verso la medicina della transizione e verso le narrazioni della comunità trans, e non seguo più la comunità.
Storia completa
I am a doctor, born male, who detransitioned more than two years before I wrote these comments in March and April 2020, after roughly three years on hormone replacement therapy. I came out as gay first, and then as trans; my motivations for transitioning were complex but almost always stemmed from deep insecurity, in my case insecurity over my sexuality, wanting everything to "line up," jealousy toward straight people, and some internalized homophobia.
I transitioned because I wanted a fantasy rather than actually being the other gender. Over time I realized that "passing" is largely impossible for 99% of trans people, and that even if I could physically pass, internally I would never pass, because while it was me, being a woman was not actually me. I detransitioned for a complexity of reasons, and I came to realize I am happy being male, a man, it is who I am. I now think being a guy is great and I enjoy tapping into my masculinity and the challenges that come with being a man.
On the medical side, I answered questions from others considering detransition. I reported that after stopping hormones I received a fertility test and had perfectly healthy sperm, though there is no guarantee of fertility. I described that breast tissue from hormones is permanent and will not flatten back out, though it may atrophy slightly; that libido increased after detransition; that testicular atrophy reversed; that facial hair became more coarse; and that skin texture changed but did not return to what it had been before. I was actually quite frustrated that HRT left me with a permanent baby face, retaining some feminization and youth qualities even after stopping. Some fat redistributes but not all of it, across the whole body including the face. I also explained that hair will follow genetic male pattern baldness patterns after detransition, and that finasteride can hold that back.
Mentally, detransitioning had very real effects on my mental health. At the end of my transition I had weekly suicidal ideation and what I called fake-suicidal ideation, fantasizing about it as a self-pitying exercise, which I did not have prior to transitioning when I was in my teens. I also had weekly emotional breakdowns where I felt terrible and angry and sad all at once. Since detransitioning all of that disappeared; when I committed mentally, it literally vanished. The pressure and torture over what the future held, trying to make the impossible possible, all disappeared. My mental health improved when I gave up all the fantasies and committed to the fact that transitioning in the way I was fantasizing about it was not possible; it was a relief accepting that fighting for the impossible from a dubious foundation was not healthy.
I hold fairly critical views of transition and of the trans community. I do not think a simple reason can be assigned for why people transition. I have said that trans medicine is a completely novel medical area and should not be treated the same way as far as liability compared with infectious disease, and that suing clinics trying to help people is bullshit, an American way of thinking; people should take responsibility for their actions. I have observed that the desire to retaliate against trans organizations and medical centers comes primarily from female-to-male detransitioners, some of it stemming from not wanting to take responsibility for your own actions, though I do agree that a lot of naive people transition and do not have anyone to challenge them. I do not read trans forums anymore or follow it much in the news, not because I keep myself away, but because I do not care enough to follow it. I told others that it is normal to feel angry at first, but after a while you should not feel angry anymore if you have really left transitioning behind, and that you cannot easily change people's minds about transitioning because they will search for information confirming their biases. I advised focusing on yourself rather than the trans community, and working on your insecurities without the added craziness of trying to be something you cannot be.