Tutte le storie

Ho smesso di leggere i forum e ho iniziato a costruirmi una vita

Maschio · Desistito/a644
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono nato maschio e sono stato vicino a fare la transizione ma alla fine ho deciso di no, scegliendo invece di smettere di leggere le comunità transgender e di rimettere al centro della mia vita lavoro, relazioni e accettazione di me come uomo. Non descrivo interventi medici specifici nel mio caso, ma sono arrabbiato con i terapeuti e i chirurghi che a mio avviso spingono i giovani uomini verso cambiamenti irreversibili, e vedo il lato medico della transizione come un'industria al limite della setta. Attualmente mi identifico come maschio, con le mie parole 'sono un maschio ma sto ancora imparando a essere un uomo', e passo molto tempo su questa bacheca ad avvertire altri giovani uomini sui costi di ormoni e interventi. Non descrivo ideazione suicidaria, autolesionismo né tentativi di suicidio nel mio caso. Sono molto critico verso la transizione per la maggior parte dei giovani uomini con cui parlo, anche se non descrivo un attivismo formale oltre ai post.

Storia completa

I was born male, and I've spent a lot of time on this board talking with young men and boys who are thinking about transitioning, because I want them to think harder than I did. I don't have a neat, tidy story with ages and dates — most of what I can tell you is what I've come to believe and what I've decided for myself. I came to see transition as, in my words, "a cultural trend to solve personal issues (lack of parents love, oppression etc) via gender stuff," and I've come to believe that "gender is not the solution, but the consequences might be severe." I went through my own period of seriously considering it — of wanting to "make an experiment, trying to live in an opposite gender, since sex hormones are available" — and I eventually decided against it. When I talk about the costs I list them plainly: "social issues, no sperm and lack of sex drive, low chances to make a couple with smb, lack of energy, since man body works on T." I told myself and others, "I'd better don't begin. Love yslf as a guy, because if you don't love yslf, how can u love smb else." The decisive moment for me was when I finally said out loud, in a thread about professionals pushing people toward transition: "You can have fantasies and sexual fetishes, great imagination about your deep feminity, which is mixed with you masculinity. But your life is not about it in a whole. If start taking hormones, your social path and career is changed, reproductive system damaged etc. does it worth it? I personally decided not." That sentence — "I personally decided not" — is the closest thing I have to a clean statement of where I landed. I also told someone else, in a moment of real anger at the system: "How dare the so called 'professionals' to advice u to transition. In fact, there is a huge choice, which is only yours." I don't describe surgeries, a specific diagnosis, a specific medication regimen, or a specific date for anything in my own case in these posts. What I do describe is a period of confusion in which I read transgender groups and found that it fed the wrong thoughts. I eventually stopped: "I did and stopped finally. JUst refocus." I've told others to do the same — "stop reading transgender groups!!! All that gendrd/cis/non-binory f*cking stuff which is actually extremely overestimated." I've also said that my own attraction to the idea felt more like a fetish than an identity: "The idea of transitiong is a kind of sexual fetish, quite noising and intrusive." And I've been honest that the pull doesn't vanish instantly: "Dude, I feel the same. It's like a sexual excitment. But to look at is not the same to pass through it." I have a lot of anger at therapists and surgeons. I've written that "therapists shall be punished, since they allow and promote young guys to make such experiments with their bodies, despite it can ruin their lives," that "SRS was a tragedy. these operations must be stopped," and that the whole thing is "an industry. Humans sterelization industry. One day it will be revealed for public." I've called the medical side of it something close to a cult: "Who is responsible for their broken lifes? Seems noone if transgenedrism becomes a sort of religion or a cult." I've also said the trans community "has some sights of sectarian behavior. They are so prone to call transphobes anyone who dare to doubt." On the medical side, I've given practical advice to detransitioners trying to recover: I've pointed to gonadotropin therapy to restart testicular function, linked to drugs.com on gonadotropins, and told people to see an endocrinologist and get bloodwork to compare pre- and post-transition testosterone levels. I've been realistic that recovery varies: "Some dettransitioners say their testicles function has restored quite fast. Others report they still have suppressed function (low T, little sperm). So, it's quite individual." I've also told people that body fat aromatizes testosterone into estrogen and linked to an Army article on belly fat in men. I've noted that the body keeps growing "till 23-25 age," which is one of the few concrete age references I've given about male development. I don't talk much about my own mental health in these posts, but I do talk about the mental health of the people I'm writing to, and I've said some heavy things: that young people "get suicide after transitioning, since they don't become happier but ruine their social life, their body." I've described intrusive thoughts as "the most hardest thing" and talked about needing to "find the balance, to cope with your brain somehow." I've framed a lot of the pull toward transition as stemming from ordinary problems — shyness, socializing issues, feeling inferior to other men, feeling like a "beta male" — that transition doesn't fix: "its seems u are just a shy guy who has socializing issues. Lots of men have the same stuff, but it doesnt mean that the transitioning could be a solution." On sexuality, I've been direct. I've told gay-identified men who are questioning that if their sex hormone is testosterone and they don't have dysphoria about their male appearance, "you'd better be gay male." I've told people with a male body who want to be with a straight woman that it's "a kind of illusion to be a girl in relationship with a straight guy, since your reproductive system is a male one and no surgeries can change it." I've also said that "man sexuality is very vague in fact" and that skinny guys are attractive to plenty of people. I don't describe a partner, a family, a job, or a specific current living situation in these posts. What I describe is a decision: I considered transitioning, I stopped reading the communities that were pulling me toward it, and I chose to refocus my life on work, career, travel, falling in love, and caring for other people. I've told others to do the same: "Just refocus! Fell in love with smb, take care of other people, focus on your social realization as a specialist." I don't use a label for myself in these posts beyond being male. I've written, "P.s. I'm a male but still learning to be a man." That's the most direct statement I've made about where I am. I don't describe regret over specific medical interventions in my own case because I don't describe having had any. My regret is more about how close I came and how easily it could have gone the other way — and about how many young men I've watched go down a path I chose not to take. I've told people who realized it in time that they're lucky: "great that you realize it quite soon as well as you haven't made irreversable things with your body." I don't describe suicidal ideation, self-harm, or a suicide attempt in my own case in these posts. As for what I think about transition for other people: I'm opposed to it for the vast majority of the young men I talk to, I think the medical system is failing them, and I think the risks are underplayed. I don't describe formal activism — no petitions, no organizations, no media appearances — but I spend a lot of time on this board pushing back, offering endocrinology links, and telling people to refocus. That's the advocacy I've done.