Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I have been active in detrans and radical feminist spaces since at least early 2019, and much of what I've written there reflects how I think about womanhood, gender, and my own path.
Early on, in April and May 2019, I pushed back against the idea that clothing or presentation should determine gender. I argued that "dresses being feminine is a cultural construct" and that plenty of cultures have men wearing dresses. What I hoped for was a future where "every gender can wear whatever they want and present however they want without someone telling them they need to take hormones and go through life altering surgery." That framing matters to me because it captures my core objection: I don't think nonconformity should be medicalized.
Around the same time, in May 2019, I was openly grappling with what it means to be a woman in a patriarchy. I said plainly that "I didn't feel like listing all the reasons I hate being a woman," and I linked that to losing agency over my body, including abortion rights being stripped away. I also argued that it makes sense that people would want to be male, "because men are treated better in our society," and asked rhetorically whether someone would want to be "the more privileged group." In a heated exchange I defended the reality of women's oppression, saying women "were considered property" not long ago and that the mindset hasn't disappeared. I also stated my view that women detransition "because lifelong hormones and life-altering surgery is traumatic," and that "women are resilient. They learn self love and they eventually accept their womanhood." I did not give specifics about my own medical history in these comments, so I won't invent any.
I also hold a biological view of hormones and temperament. In June 2019 I cited studies (mostly animal) showing testosterone increases aggression and estrogen produces docility, arguing that "hormones do play a big part in behavior" and that higher testosterone makes someone "more prone to aggression, on average." I don't think men or women are inherently anything, but I do think natural hormones shape behavior.
Politically, in July 2019, I accepted an invitation to a community by saying "I support radical feminism." That's an explicit statement of my political alignment.
I've also tried to support others in the community. In June 2019 I wrote an encouraging message to someone struggling, telling them "you aren't alone," that they "WILL get through this and be happy again," and advising them to cut out negative influences: "any subreddit that you find puts you in a bad mood, any people that after you talk to, you feel more drained than before... get rid of it." In October 2019 I told another person that they can't change what others write about them and that "Your energy is better spent focusing on you and the next version of you." I also believe in self-reflection through solitude: "Every time I needed to learn something real about myself, I had to take a break from other people and just nurture my own thoughts and feelings. The right answer is inside of you."
I've been critical of certain transition narratives and of people I see as exploiting identity for gain. In August 2019 I said a given situation was "100% for their blog and to gain popularity and money," and questioned why "liking sparkly things as a kid" would make someone "a woman inside." In October 2019 I also questioned received wisdom about sex differences, asking whether women actually have thinner skin or whether it's like the myth about muscle number.
On motherhood and societal expectations, in October 2019 I was direct: "I don't want to be a mother" because mothers get blamed for everything and are expected to handle all child-related work, and I don't want to be asked whether I'm choosing career over family. I acknowledged that as a woman, that expectation will be put on me when I have kids, "biological or not," but I said that's society's problem, not mine, and that I won't base my decisions on external pressure.
Overall, I come across as a woman who has accepted her womanhood after what I describe as a traumatic medical path, who is critical of medical transition especially for gender-nonconforming people, aligned with radical feminism, and who values self-reliance, introspection, and cutting out toxic influences. I don't give a detailed timeline of my own transition or detransition in these comments, so I can't fill in ages, dates, or medical specifics beyond what's here.