Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I want to be clear from the start: I was never trans myself. I come to this space to listen and to support what I consider arguably the smallest voice in the LGBT community. I first posted in August 2019 asking people to respect the space, saying it is for people suffering greatly due to societal pressure to transition and the aftermath of that. I wrote that many of these people have to live with disfigurement and hormonal body problems for the rest of their lives and live in despair, and that they are not bad people, just trying to cope.
My involvement has been as an ally and advocate rather than as someone who transitioned. In October 2019 I made a post titled 'Remember, a majority of the LGBT community is not your ally,' arguing that the love expressed by the LGBT community at large is conditional — that detransitioners are loved only so long as they are silent and invisible, and that the moment they speak out they will be turned on. I told people their experience is traumatic and it is completely reasonable to want their own space, but if they speak out, to do so with confidence, because there is a community willing to support them.
I got into several arguments that month. I said that if you try to speak up you will be attacked and silenced, on Reddit, on Twitter, and within LGBT media, and that it is not just some individuals but the rhetoric and philosophy of the LGBT community at large. I stated repeatedly that 'the LGBT community is effectively dead' and that only the 'queer community' is allowed a voice, that lesbians, gays and bisexuals are not allowed to speak on these matters. I also said bisexuals are under attack from both gay people and trans people if you aren't attracted to trans people. I tried to reassure detransitioners that they do have an ally in me, while admitting I am kind of socially awkward and don't fully know my limits. When criticized, I said I was not trying to be political, just angry at the current social climate, and my intention was to let people know they are being thought of and that there is support. In one exchange I told an opponent they were 'oppressive, toxic and divisive' and to 'literally fuck off.'
On October 23, 2019 I posted a longer comment, which got 36 upvotes, arguing that transitioning really should only be done as a last resort and, if it can be, avoided altogether. I wrote that there is such a thing as just being an overly masculine woman or an overly effeminate man and those things are totally okay. I described how a woman who transitions and takes testosterone but then changes her mind has to battle facial hair for the rest of her life, and how men who take estrogen but later want to stay male may have breasts whose removal would result in unnecessary invasive surgery and scars — all of which could have been avoided if they just left their bodies alone. I said once your body is altered it can never be truly restored to its original state, and like a bad tattoo on your forehead it will be a constant reminder of the reckless and foolish decisions of youth. I claimed there are trans people on the internet who send children drugs to stop puberty or start transitioning without their parents' or doctors' knowledge, and some of those kids end up finding their way to the detrans community once they've grown a little. I argued transitioning should never be an automatic reaction, that it should take years of visits to specialist providers and behavioral therapists before the process begins, and that any provider who is quick to help you transition should not be allowed to practice.
On October 30, 2019 I commented that in the previous version of the subreddit, trans people infiltrated modship and got the previous sub to not actually be for detrans people, and that trans people view detransitioners as a threat to their narrative, expending effort to discredit, silence and make invisible detransitioners. I felt the mods should take an active role in eliminating this.
On October 31, 2019 I made a post titled 'Petition for The Detrans Advocacy Network!' and shared the text of a petition calling on the NIH Sexual & Gender Minority Research Office to acknowledge the growing detrans community and allocate funds to detransitioners' unique, urgent and largely unmet medical needs. The petition listed needs including social re-integration, suicide prevention, psychological and primary-care and endocrinologist referrals free of gender-affirmation, access to same-sex HRT, hair removal for females, surgical referrals for chest and genital reconstruction, research into organ transplants and laboratory-regenerated implants, guidance on detransition outcomes and timelines, and legal guidance on document restoration. It argued detransitioners are by nature gender-nonconformists and many if not most are same-sex attracted, that the gender-affirmation model has irrevocably harmed many detransitioners mentally and physically, that it is especially harmful to individuals not yet of neurological maturity and to those of atypical neurology, and that research into detransition has been censured for fear of backlash.
My last recorded comment, in January 2020, was supporting someone's appearance: 'You look like yourself, congratulations... you look like you.'
To summarize my position: I am not detransitioned or desisted because I never transitioned. I am an ally who believes transition should be a last resort, that permanent bodily alterations are often regretted, and that the broader LGBT community is hostile to detransitioners speaking about their experiences.