Tutte le storie

Undici anni in una clinica del genere, ora osserva sua figlia

Femmina · Desistito/a246
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un'infermiera professionista che ha lavorato circa 11 anni in una clinica di riferimento per il genere e LGBTQ+ prima di andarmene nel 2011, e sono arrivata a questa comunità come madre di una figlia di 13 anni che mi ha detto di «poter essere trans». Non descrivo la mia transizione in questi post; scrivo invece come genitore preoccupato ed ex professionista di una clinica del genere, convinta che mia figlia non sia trans ma una ragazza non conforme al genere, ansiosa, forse autistica, influenzata dall'attivismo trans online. Ho monitorato il suo uso di internet, collaboro con la sua psichiatra (prende farmaci per ansia e depressione) e cerco di guidarla verso il dubbio anziché lo scontro, mentre la mia terapeuta mi consiglia di lasciare che si trovi da sola per tentativi ed errori. Sono critica verso quella che vedo come un'assistenza avventata, solo affermativa, e verso clinici di parte, e sostengo con forza una terapia non focalizzata sul genere, ricerca corretta e imparziale sulla detransizione e sul rimpianto, e che i giovani smettano il testosterone e diano tempo al corpo prima di prendere decisioni irreversibili. Mi sono descritta come tutt'altro che transfobica e credo che alcune persone traggano davvero beneficio dalla transizione, ma sono frustrata dal fatto che sollevare queste preoccupazioni faccia etichettare le persone come transfobiche o TERF.

Storia completa

I am a registered nurse, and I worked for about 11 years — from roughly 2000 until I quit in 2011 — at a gender and LGBTQ+ reference clinic in my town, the kind of facility that is the local reference point for trans people. I am also a mother. My involvement in this community came about for what I have called a very personal reason: my 13-year-old daughter told me in tears that she 'might be trans,' and I found myself reading and posting here while catching up on the science I had lost touch with after leaving my clinic. On my own transition-related history, the transcript does not contain a personal account of me transitioning or detransitioning; what I bring instead is my professional background and my experience as a parent. I have described myself as 'anything but a transphobe' and said I am proud of the inclusiveness and results of the service my clinic provided, because I do believe there are people for whom transition is the only answer and the right care. At the same time, I have been open about how I see things now: I believe many professionals are scared of being labeled transphobic for suggesting that low self-esteem, depression, bullying, internalized homophobia, patriarchy, and the position left for women in society may be playing a role in so many young women developing gender dysphoria. I have said I cannot and won't accept being called a TERF, but that I can see clearly that my daughter isn't trans even though she thinks otherwise. My daughter was screened for autism spectrum disorder twice and didn't 'make the cut,' though I have always suspected she was on the spectrum and she behaves 'so much like an aspie.' She struggled with social skills, preferred to be alone, was extremely stubborn, and had a 'know it all' attitude. She was never a stereotypically 'girly' child, but I take responsibility for part of that because I deliberately did not raise her under gender stereotypes — she liked animals, legos, and dragons. She never said she was a boy as a child, never played with boys' toys, accepted her breasts growing and was 'super chill' about her periods. She was diagnosed with anxiety and PTSD two years before my March 2020 posts (so around 2018) after we moved from her beloved hometown and after a huge fight with her best friend in 7th grade. She later identified as 'asexual' — her psychiatrist thought her medication was inhibiting her libido — and then, months after joining Twitter to follow YouTubers and gamers, came to me with the trans talk. She fit the Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria definition as I understand it. She learned online that because she 'isn't like other girls,' likes games, doesn't like makeup or dresses, and hates her breasts, she must be trans. At exactly the same time she had her first depressive episode, for which her medication was adjusted and which worked well; afterward she settled on the 'non binary' label. She says she can't explain why she thinks she's trans and cries when I ask. She is fine with her birth name and she/her pronouns, loves her long hair, shaves and dislikes facial hair, doesn't want to take testosterone, and buys very girly clothes — she just hates her breasts, which I see more as body dysmorphic disorder. I have been trying to guide her without direct confrontation. I respect what I have called her 'phase' and try to point out what I learned working with trans people for a decade. I monitor her internet use, YouTube history, Twitter and Discord, and I try to get her offline by taking her along on errands and dog walks, because if I openly limit her screen time she throws major teen tantrums and calls me a boomer. My own therapist told me her behavior reflects a need to be part of a group and to be special, and advised me to step back and let her find her true self by trial and error. I have said my goal is to ask her the right questions and let her see for herself, and that someday I want to present her with the stories of detransitioners here, because 'you are the real deal, and your stories are so valid and important.' She has a small set of real-life friends who are all like her — gamers and anime fans who dislike sports and working out. I have blamed myself for raising her without gender stereotypes, feeling that it made her vulnerable to what I have called the 'trans cult' or 'trans hype' in the gamer community, and I have wished I had the courage to take away her phone but held back because she is so lonely. A YouTuber she followed came out as a trans woman and detransitioned a couple of months later, which I saw as an opportunity to raise the desistance/detrans debate, but he refused to address the subject again after backlash. In terms of my own mental health care, I have written about my experience with cognitive behavioral therapy: I don't know whether it was the technique or simply having a place to vent, but I used to arrive at therapy feeling like 'the world was about to end' and leave every session feeling I could make everything work out with time and patience. I consistently recommend therapy — specifically CBT with serious professionals working away from gender activism, to avoid biased care — over gender-specialist therapists for people questioning transition. My views on transition medicine are critical and evidence-focused. I have argued that there is no scientific evidence that trans identities are related to hormone imbalances, and that it is 'utterly irresponsible' to tell someone they are trans because they feel better on hormones. I have described HRT as potentially answering an obsessive-compulsive dynamic — obsessive thinking about 'needing HRT' relieved by the compulsive act of taking it — and warned that some patients quit a few months later disappointed. I have listed the medical risks of testosterone for females: changes in red blood cells, cholesterol, bone weight density, weight gain, hairline and voice changes, genital changes, plus effects on libido, erections, and fertility. I have said that in my country the protocol requires at least two years of follow-up with a trained therapist before surgery, but that this wasn't enough to prevent the regret a friend of mine felt — she never considered detransition but is still unhappy. I have also mentioned a trans woman friend who was made suicidal by disappointment with her surgical results and not passing, when she had not been suicidal before transitioning. I have said I have had 'my share of detransitioners who've had a honeymoon with their transition before crashing and burning in reality months or some years later.' I have been an active, vocal commenter here, encouraging young people to stop T and give their bodies time, to seek non-gender-focused therapy, to question rather than be indoctrinated, and calling for proper, unbiased research into detransition and regret. I have expressed frustration and hopelessness that people who raise these questions are labeled transphobic, silenced, and ostracized, and I have asked why a proper unbiased study can't be done 'even to prove us wrong.'