Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I was born female. I first came across the idea of being trans through eating disorder message boards back when I was active on them — I noticed the forum for guys with eating disorders had a huge number of posts from trans men, which got me thinking about how differently men and women develop eating disorders and how much of that comes down to socialization and body image.
When I identified as trans, I socially transitioned and went on hormones (testosterone), and about five years before March 2021 I had top surgery. I've described that surgery as "the best decision I've ever made" and said I'm grateful for it every single day, even though I was starting to identify as female again around that time. My aversion to the sex characteristics of my body was real enough that I "literally transition[ed] with hormones and surgery."
On what led me toward transition: I don't think guilt about being a "cishet white girl" was the reason for my transition, but I could see it as a factor for many progressive people. Because of what I was seeing on social media I felt ashamed and guilty about being a white, heterosexual, female person, and since good allies are supposed to shut up and listen, transitioning felt kind of liberating — like I could express my opinions without being dismissed immediately for being part of the oppressors. I've also noted that everyone is at least a little gender nonconforming, so that's an easy thing to latch onto and take on as an "oppressed" identity.
I used to align myself with transmedicalism because it gave firm answers to the really confusing discourse around trans stuff. What tipped me off that the transmed view was probably wrong was encountering the claim that there are zero other factors to being trans besides innate transness — there are so many factors that play into it, and that doesn't mean the dysphoria is any less real or genuine. The big appeal of the transmed position for me was that it made me feel validated: I'm not one of those fake non-binary people, I'm *actually* trans. But after reading more I found I no longer agreed that dysphoria equals trans and no dysphoria equals cis, or that transgender is a set state of being from birth. I also dislike the "actually trans" versus "confused cis" framing — it's a false dichotomy — and I've said that if we're going to divide people it shouldn't be trans/cis but dysphoric/non-dysphoric, or that being trans can be understood as a solution to dysphoria rather than an innate sense of being, meaning detransitioners WERE really trans because they transitioned to alleviate dysphoria.
I've worked through my own feelings on gender partly by reading Jesse Singal's Atlantic piece on detransitioners and desisters. I've advised others considering hormones to think about whether they're going on them to be more comfortable in their body versus to pass, or because it's the default next step, and that it's fine to stop hormones and take more time. I've told people that hearing a new name and pronouns can be jarring at first even for those happy with transition, that names can be experimented with, and that detransition is always an option.
Around 2024 I was describing myself as female: "Personally I tell people I'm female but they can use whatever pronouns feel natural for them to use for me." I've come to think of "trans" more like "transitioned" than "transgender" — gender identity, to me, is largely people comparing their traits to gender norms and expectations, which is especially obvious in non-transitioned people, whereas transition is an actual tangible change (pronouns, name, presentation). Under that schema, detransitioned people WERE literally trans but aren't anymore. I acknowledged this view is not shared within the trans community and might be considered transphobic there, and I said I'd been adjusting my interpretation of gender and gender identity for years and would keep processing critiques of my framing.
On adversity and social dynamics: while I identified as trans I saw a lot of transmasculine hate on social media — the trans-inclusive progressive line being that men are trash and therefore trans men are trash — which was hurtful and disheartening, especially when expressing that it hurt led people to double down and tell me to check my privilege. I've also observed that in activist circles transmasculine people go from unauthoritative in mainstream society to unauthoritative in trans culture, while transfeminine people stay authoritative in both. I've noted that this subreddit leans a little radfem, with negative opinions of men and condemnation of trans women as autogynephiles, and suggested people who find that invalidating might look elsewhere. I've also described a specific trauma of being born female as distinct from the trauma of being born a trans girl.
On sexuality and socialization: I've argued that cis lesbians grow up hearing very different things about their sexuality and acceptable gender expression than trans lesbians do, and that because of socialization and biological sex each group faces issues the other never will — and that wanting separate spaces isn't transphobic. I made the same argument about cis-only eating disorder spaces for men.
I've described myself as a detransitioner because of a shift in ideology rather than a shift in presentation, and said it's okay to say you're not trans even if you're on testosterone, using he/him, and keeping a masculine name, though sometimes it's easier to say "I'm trans" to communicate you've had and still have FTM experiences.
I don't describe mental health diagnoses, trauma history, family reactions, romantic relationships, career effects, or fertility concerns anywhere in this material. I don't describe any regret about my top surgery or hormones — quite the opposite. I don't describe suicidal ideation or self-harm.