Tutte le storie

La transizione che non ha mai fatto, e il timore che l'avrebbe fatta

Maschio · Desistito/a277
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un uomo cisgender sui 35 anni, critico verso la transizione e solidale con chi fa detransition, che non ha mai fatto la transizione ma dice che forse l'avrebbe fatta se fosse cresciuto con l'ideologia di genere di oggi. Ero un bambino magro, AuDHD, preso in giro perché non abbastanza mascolino, e ho imparato ad accettarmi invece di mettere in dubbio il mio genere. Ho opinioni critiche sull'ideologia di genere dominante, vedendo la transizione come spesso una distrazione dall'accettazione di sé, anche in parte osservando amici che l'hanno fatta. Partecipo alle community detrans offrendo una prospettiva invece di condividere una storia personale di detransition. Non dichiaro alcun rimpianto per il mio corpo, dato che non ho mai fatto la transizione.

Storia completa

I'm a guy in my mid-30s, born male, and I never transitioned — but I spend time in detrans communities because I feel strongly about these issues and want to offer perspective to people questioning transition. I grew up in the early-to-mid 2000s as a teenager, before gender ideology was discussed mainstream, and I describe myself as having been "skinny af" as a boy. I was asked if I was gay by many people simply because I was skinny and talked a lot — I mention having AuDHD (autism and ADHD). I got made fun of for looking wimpy, and had guys hitting on me because I looked like a "classic twink." I was on the lower end of the totem pole of popularity and sexual attractiveness when young. Because gender ideology wasn't mainstream then, I say it was "completely unacceptable in my brain" to entertain thoughts about whether I'd fit better as a girl, so I didn't. Instead, being unpopular and seen as unattractive forced me to learn to accept myself, give a middle finger to the haters, and be unabashedly myself — and once I started doing that, life got "100x better" and my nervous insecurity from my teen years shook off. I explicitly say that if I had been born in 2004 and gone through adolescence with today's gender ideology, "I might not have had a dick by now" — implying I could have been drawn into transition. I've never identified as trans or detransitioned personally. My views on transition come largely from observing friends. My first and oldest close friend came out as trans (MTF) a few years ago (as of late 2024); I've known them 25-28 years. They're in their mid-30s, went to a ritzy music school instead of college, never took the SAT, never got a job, lived in their parents' home into their 30s, and have earned only a couple thousand bucks from music ever. Their parents had lots of money — I describe them as coddled, including an anecdote about their mom bringing them Taco Bell on a playdate at age 10. I describe this friend as one of the most narcissistic people I've ever met, unable to admit they're wrong, with a girlfriend who does their chores. I believe their transition was a coping mechanism for failing to "grow up from boy to man," and that transitioning lets people be treated like "a little prince(ss) who can do no wrong." I also have an FTM friend who was heavily molested as a little kid and had a dad who wanted a son — I frame that as a recipe for hating feeling like being a girl made them a target, and adopting a masculine role in the bedroom as the dom rather than sub. I've never used hormones or had surgery. I'm close to 6 feet tall and gained weight to near 200lbs as an adult; I mention being sucker punched before. I had a 5'4" ex who trained BJJ for over a year and I pinned her in 5 seconds despite my routine being "PC gaming and driving to fast food." I hold critical views of mainstream gender ideology: I think being trans has become "the go-to answer" for not feeling like your birth gender, that it implies buying into stereotypes (less of a man if you don't look like Schwarzenegger, less of a woman if you don't look like Scarlett Johansson), and that it replaces self-acceptance. I say transitioning often "serves to distract/delay somebody from doing the hard emotional work of self-acceptance and self-love," and that transition should be a last resort only when not transitioning is truly unbearable. I believe gender is something you're born with, not chosen. I've engaged in discussions about trans women in women's sports (noting potential lingering testosterone advantages), online radicalization of LGBT communities, and scientific studies on sex differences. I don't describe formal advocacy or activism beyond posting these views online.