Tutte le storie

Un uomo «vero» o un ritocco estetico: lei non ha scelto nessuno dei due

Femmina · Desistito/a2,6K
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha fatto detransizione/desistenza: non ho mai fatto la transizione medica, ma mi sono identificata come uomo trans e poi come non binaria prima di riconoscere i miei sentimenti come risposte al trauma, misoginia interiorizzata ed escapismo legato ai fandom. Sono stata violentata e abusata sessualmente da uomini, ho avuto l'anoressia e credevo che diventare un uomo mi avrebbe protetta e fatto sfuggire all'essere donna. Non ho mai portato a termine la transizione perché sapevo che non sarei mai stata un uomo «vero» e che sarebbe stato un rimedio estetico a problemi più profondi. Sono critica sia dell'attivismo trans mainstream sia della destra gender-critical, e ora mi identifico come donna e lavoro per riconciliarmi con il mio corpo e costruire solidarietà con le altre donne.

Storia completa

I am a woman, born female, and I live in the Global South. I am a leftist, not a liberal, and I am deeply critical of both mainstream trans activism and the gender-critical right. I never medically transitioned, but I came very close to identifying as a trans man and then as non-binary, and I want to tell that story because I think it matters. Growing up, I was always a bit of an outsider. I spent my teenage years deep in fandom spaces on Tumblr, reading and writing BL (boys' love/yaoi) and slash fanfiction. I identified with the feminine male characters — the bishonen, the pretty anime boys, the kpop stars. I wanted to be them. I now understand that what I was really drawn to was the freedom they represented: in those stories, a boy could be pretty and soft and still be loved, still be a full person. As a girl, femininity felt like a prison, an expectation, not a choice. I also grew up on anorexia — I was very skinny — and I thought that if I became a man, a really thin man, I would never be sexually abused again. I had been raped and sexually abused by men in the past, and the idea of being a man felt like a shield, a way to make being touched by men okay, or to make men leave me alone entirely. I never went through with transition because I knew, deep down, that I would never be a 'real' man. I would never be a sinewy bishonen. Transition would have been an aesthetic solution to a much deeper problem — trauma, misogyny, internalised homophobia, and a total lack of female class consciousness. I didn't see other women as allies; I saw womanhood as something to escape. When I briefly identified as non-binary and genderqueer, it felt like a mental shield, a way to opt out of being a woman without fully committing to being a man. But I eventually realised that if every woman on the planet started identifying as non-binary tonight, women's oppression would not disappear tomorrow. You can't stop being female. What moved me toward detransition — or rather, toward never transitioning in the first place — was a combination of things. I started reading feminist theory, including Andrea Dworkin's Right Wing Women. I found role models: butch lesbians and gender-nonconforming women who talked about their own dysphoria with compassion and intelligence, like a woman on Tumblr who runs a blog called laundryandtaxes. I also started to see the bigger picture: that the trans movement, at least in the West, had been co-opted by capitalism, by pharmaceutical companies that want lifelong patients, by a liberal identity politics that reduces everything to individual feelings and pronouns while ignoring the material realities of sex-based oppression. I came to believe that no one is 'born trans,' that the theory of sexually dysmorphic brains has been debunked, and that gender itself is a social construct — one that should ideally be destroyed, not reinforced. I am not against transition for everyone. I believe some people, especially older trans people who pass and are stealth, live lives that are genuinely better because of transition, and I have compassion for them. I also know that the movement originally began to help transsexuals who were denied housing and employment, forced into prostitution — people who are still oppressed today, especially in the Global South and among black and brown trans women. But I am deeply critical of the current state of things: the social media contagion, the Tumblr and TikTok kids who worship male characters and decide they must be trans gay men, the way the community shuts down any criticism, the way autogynephilia and predatory behaviour are hidden. I am equally critical of gender-critical people who ally with conservatives like Matt Walsh, who hate trans people and women alike, and who use detransitioners for their own political agendas. I lost a friend over these disagreements — someone who couldn't engage with my opinions and talked behind my back. It showed me who my real friends were. I am bisexual. Before transition, I struggled with internalised homophobia and the feeling that being a woman who loved men felt wrong, tainted by everything bad about heterosexuality. I thought that if I became a gay man, I could experience love and sex the way it was 'supposed' to be — romanticised, equal, free from the weight of misogyny. Now I understand that was a fantasy, a product of the fiction I consumed, not reality. Gay men have relationship problems too. And being a woman who loves men is not inherently degraded; it's the world that degrades us. My regret is not for medical changes, because I never made them, but for the years I spent lost in these ideas, the friendships I damaged, and the time I could have spent building solidarity with other women instead of trying to escape womanhood. I am still working on fully reconciling with my body, on unlearning the internalised misogyny that told me femininity was a weakness and womanhood a curse. But I am okay. I am female, and there is no wrong way to be female. I am learning that now, and I want other girls and women — especially the ones deep in fandom, the ones who hate their bodies, the ones who think becoming a man is the only way to be safe — to know that they are not alone, and that they are not ruined.