Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I was born female and grew up in a family with Mexican heritage — both of my grandpas were native, and my mom grew up in Mexico in the 1980s. I wasn't allowed to be a tomboy as a kid, and I think that manifested later. My puberty was rough: I started getting gender dysphoria, and then I was sexually assaulted for the first time, specifically having my breasts groped. I was young, and it's still very hard for me to talk about. I never made the connection at the time of whether that made my hatred of my chest even stronger, or whether it was the reason I was assaulted. I was also molested and SA'd as a child. Around age 12 I had ovarian cysts, one of which ruptured so badly I passed out before I could get a CT scan — doctors had repeatedly dismissed my pain, and I said this left me not trusting doctors.
I discovered yaoi at 11 and transgenderism at 12, and I wonder sometimes if I'd still be trans if I'd had restricted internet access. I socially transitioned at 13 and was set on transitioning — I was very hard-headed about it. I had severe gender dysphoria and social anxiety: my dysphoria was so bad I wouldn't speak in class because of how feminine my voice was, and just existing as a woman made me want to break down and cry, so I'd isolate myself in my room for weeks. I developed an eating disorder because of my gender dysphoria. I also had OCD and obsessively watched trans YouTubers when I was young, and now I find myself doing the same thing but with detrans YouTubers. My mom has OCD and ADHD (maybe autism — I might have autism too but was never tested), and she told me she thought she was a boy when she was young and would have been told to transition if she'd been born in the 2000s; she says she has a 'butch personality.' I hated when she said that because I thought it was transphobic, but the longer I sit with it the more conflicted I feel — if I'd been born in the 1980s I might just have turned out a butch lesbian, and it's scary to think I might have been happier that way.
I started testosterone at 16. Nobody warned me about the physical damage T was doing to my body despite my being 16. My prescriptions were inconsistent because the pharmacy was being difficult, so I was on T for about 1.5 years. My voice changed during the first month, I passed by 4 months in and stopped getting 'miss'ed, and my voice only cracked between 2-6 months on T. I got a thick but patchy beard (my brother had a full beard at 16), male-pattern baldness, hot flashes, mood swings that sent me into depressive episodes, water retention in my face, and acne. I felt like my body was 'decomposing' but pushed those feelings away because I 'might as well go through it since I'm here' and didn't want to be seen as a 'fake trans.' I got 'downstairs problems' and refused to go to the gyno because of dysphoria. I felt my kidneys were giving me problems on T; my GP told me 'T doesn't affect the kidneys' and I felt swept under the rug. After stopping T I stopped feeling numbness where my kidneys were, and the sharp stomach pains went away. I planned at the time to take T from 16 to 21, stop, and restart around my 30s. I eventually stopped cold turkey when I started balding and getting hot flashes — shaving my head and going bald were not the same at all, and I knew I couldn't stay on it, though it made me ashamed for 'not being a true trans.' I had no exact detransition date; once the pharmacy made it hard to refill I took it as a sign to stop. I went through withdrawals but was fine after a month.
In transmasc circles I was told I had to be happy with every side effect of T or else I was a 'trender,' that if I didn't want to cut off every part of my body I was a 'trender,' and that I wasn't allowed to express myself outside the binary. I forced myself to like T's side effects even as I became insecure about my hairline, acne, and facial water retention. Truscum/transmed rhetoric was the reason I transitioned medically — according to them, if I really had gender dysphoria I'd transition and chop off body parts. I left the transmed community because they're 'crabs in a bucket' with an 'I'm not like other trans' mentality. At 17 I was already being pressured into getting a hysterectomy because I didn't like having periods, when they could have offered therapy or coping mechanisms instead. I had been dead set on top surgery since I was 14, but my first sexual partner (a woman, after I transitioned) told me how nice and perky my breasts were, and that was enough to make me reconsider — I changed my mind about top surgery even though I'd wanted it for years. I had been binding for 6 years and only stopped about a month before May 2022; binding messed up my ribs and made them bigger. I was considering getting rid of my binders because of how much they hurt my tissue. I have a small chest, probably around a B cup, and I've gone to the gym to try to make it smaller.
I've been off T for about 2 years as of mid-2022. My face changed a lot on T and hasn't gone back to its pre-T shape — it's a bit softer but I don't think it could return to how it was. My facial hair is a major problem: despite only 1.5 years on T I have a lot of beard hair and have to shave every day, and two days before one post I spent 2 hours just plucking my chin. I can't afford laser or professional waxing because all my money goes to rent and bills. My chest hair went away a lot, my stomach hair is slowly going away, and body hair has grown slower since stopping T, though I've always been hairy from Mexican genes. My hair became softer and more luscious after stopping T. My fat distribution feminized — the quickest way I regained female fat distribution was losing weight and then gaining it back. My figure didn't change much on T; I still had hips and a big butt, only my waist got thicker. My voice is deep and immediately gets me read as male even when I otherwise look female; I know voice change is permanent and I've asked whether it softens years after stopping T. I like my deep voice, especially when I sing, and I'd like it to be more androgynous but I'm okay either way.
I went cold turkey off T. I don't plan to go back on it: the only thing I liked was the voice change, taking T was an emotional rollercoaster, and I felt like I was living in a false reality, trying to convince myself T would make my dysphoria disappear. I still experience gender dysphoria — there are moments where I get severe dysphoria over wanting to be male. I wrote that I believe trans men are men but I don't WANT to be a man, I want to be MALE — I want to be a beautiful man, not an attractive woman or nonbinary person, and no matter how many surgeries or if I retransition I'll never be born male, and the feeling gets so bad I want to die in a hole. I love myself and my female body, but some days are harder than others. I envy men's shoulders and backs, and I envy how beautiful men are seen as majestic and stoic while beautiful women are everywhere; androgynous men are admired while androgynous women are seen as ugly or manly. I've been told I'm spreading misogyny for describing this, but I was describing the societal standards I've seen imposed on women, standards that scared me of being a girl.
I've taken psychedelic journeys — ayahuasca and sapito (bufo) — for cultural and spiritual reasons, and they've made me more gender-nonconforming and more comfortable in my body, helping my gender dysphoria more than any therapist could. I also did DMT, which showed me some things and made it harder to brush off my uncertainty about top surgery. I consider myself more 'two spirited' than anything, though I'm unsure if I can reclaim the term since I'm white-passing even though both my grandpas were native. I still identify as nonbinary/two spirit and have not detransitioned socially — I probably never will. As of May 2022 I said I was 25 and female. I still get gendered male because of my voice even when I dress femininely; at best people think I'm an AMAB nonbinary person, which I don't mind. I use a male name — I was originally named after my bio-dad's ex-girlfriend without my mom's knowledge, and I don't miss that name; my current name gave me a new life and direction, and I liked androgynous/male names even as a kid.
I've struggled to know who I am and found it extremely isolating, constantly reaching out to people to hear what they say about my identity. I've been cruising through life because I never thought I'd live this long, and it's hard to think I have a future. I've been to the point of suicidal thoughts where nothing was worth living and the only thing stopping me was my primal urge to survive. I've turned to drugs and other forms of self-harm in hard times and worried I'd have become a severe addict. I have social anxiety — I want to do roller derby but my anxiety stops me. I go to the gym and parks, but my mind runs at full speed to the point it's hard to fall asleep. I've always had low self-esteem and until 2 years before 2022 I'd never taken a selfie; I'm sad I missed all of middle school and high school never taking photos because I was insecure. I have an eating disorder (recovered-ish) that developed because of my gender dysphoria. I can't afford therapy. I've also said I have a rape kink, shamefully, and that I've strayed away from violent porn and try to only watch vanilla, non-violent porn, though I try not to watch porn at all.
On sexuality: I had my first sexual partner, a woman, after transitioning, and I'm scared I could have just been a masc lesbian if I'd explored my sexuality first. I now say I'm bi but I've only been with a woman and I'm not sure how I'd be with a man; I've been trying to 'get' with a male to find out. I described myself as 'literally a butch lesbian' in one exchange. I have a transmasculine friend I'm close to but otherwise few connections in that world. I was hate-crimed for identifying as trans.
What moved me toward detransition: therapy that could have helped — I wish I'd gotten therapy for my dysphoria and social anxiety instead of transitioning, because most therapists suggest transitioning instead of learning to cope. I wish I'd dated women before transitioning. The trans community helped me hold onto my life and gave me something to look forward to (surgery, medical transition), but looking back it was just something I was living for because I had nothing else. Time, going off hormones, psychedelics, and the detrans community all played roles. I've said I don't regret transitioning, though I wish there were alternatives, and that transitioning helped my dysphoria a lot but isn't a cure-all — you can't truly get rid of gender dysphoria with just transitioning; you have to realize you were born the way you are and love your body. I was sad and depressed when identifying as FtM because I held myself to cis male standards I could never meet.
My current attitude toward transition for others: I don't discourage people from transitioning, but I think there should be different methods of treating gender dysphoria besides medical/social transition, that therapy and coping mechanisms should be offered, that HRT should be reserved for people with severe gender dysphoria, and that surgery shouldn't be pushed onto trans people — it should be an option on the table. I tell people to stay away from SRS. I tell people not to try to talk others out of surgery they've decided on, because from experience no one could have convinced me not to go on T — my mom, whom I trust dearly, tried multiple times. I've been critical of trans spaces: I said transfemme people are put above transmasculine people, that anytime I tried to talk about my own oppression I'd be shut down with 'well, trans women have it worse,' and that in trans spaces people born female are treated as second class. I've also defended trans people's access to healthcare, saying taking away any minority's right to healthcare is genocide. I've been active in r/detrans, sharing my experience and answering questions from people considering transition or detransition.