Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna di 34 anni che ha fatto detransition e che si è identificata come trans dopo essere cresciuta come ragazza autistica non diagnosticata e sola, svergognata per non riuscire nella femminilità e a cui online dicevano che in realtà era un ragazzo. Sono tornata alla mia identità di nascita dopo aver capito che il disagio verso il mio corpo era emotivo e non risolto dagli ormoni, e ho trovato pace trattando il mio corpo come neutro, circondandomi soprattutto di donne, mettendo in ordine vita e salute e infine conoscendo la mia compagna. Sono critica verso l’ideologia trans basata sull’autodichiarazione e verso gli interventi medici irreversibili, e sostengo che i «sentimenti da donna» siano incoerenti come concetto oggettivo. Non riferisco ideazione suicidaria né autolesionismo dopo la detransition.
Storia completa
I was a lonely autistic girl who grew up feeling like there was something fundamentally different inside me from the other kids. I wasn't diagnosed as autistic right away — instead I was shamed and browbeaten for being so bad at being a girl. Girls are supposed to be in touch with their feelings and good at communicating, and my struggles with those things seemed unfeminine to the people around me.
I didn't have a lot of real-life friends, and the ones I did have didn't really know me. They liked the mask I had learned to wear to avoid punishment for being a failed girl. It was easier to communicate online, where I could just use my words instead of tone and facial expression, and have time to choose the right words instead of stammering and having things come out wrong. Those online people got to know what felt like the real me — the one that couldn't come out through my failed girl body. They told me I was probably bad at being a girl because I was really a boy. It sounded right, because boys aren't supposed to be good at feelings and talking, and these people felt like they knew the real me.
They didn't really, of course, because they weren't looking at me — they were looking at a projection of themselves, looking for proof of concept for their own worldview. But it was an easy mistake to make for a lonely autistic girl who wanted to be good at being a person for once.
I eventually came to see my body not as a prison but as neutral — the vehicle my brain uses to interact with the world. Because I'm not my body; my thoughts and personality are in my head, and my body doesn't say anything about what I'm like as a person. When people treat me a certain way because of it, it's because their minds have baggage associated with bodies. That realization eventually helped me.
I also found peace by largely not interacting with men outside of absolute necessity. If you only really engage with and mostly see women, it erodes the mental significance of your own sex. I'm fortunate to be in an extremely female-dominated workplace, and my social group is made up of lesbians — I've gone weeks without a face-to-face conversation with a man. That was a huge help, though I know it's a rare situation.
I also had to work on myself after a long period of unhappiness with my body. I took care of myself the best I could and spent some years focusing on friendships and getting my life and health in order, figuring I'd probably end up romantically alone like my dad, but not totally alone in terms of human connection, because I treat people better than he does. I got noticed more often once I stopped sitting alone with my thoughts. I went to places and events I would ordinarily avoid, alone. I was off social media for a pretty long while. I got a dog, and it turns out if you are walking a dog lots of people will smile and be open to light conversation. I met my partner eventually. I liked them enough that I would rather try and get rejected than let the opportunity pass me and watch them find someone else. It worked, and I believe it's because I got my head in straight and stopped giving myself time to think about all the things I didn't like about myself. My teeth are still kind of fucked up and the big scar on my face didn't go away, but I don't think about them much anymore.
I'm now 34 and in a relationship with another woman. The person I saw myself as at 19 is unrecognizable to me now. I believe saying 'I am a man' or 'I am a woman' is a change that leaves no trace unless you start doing things like surgery, which is definitely not something you want if you want kids someday. I don't think permanent life decisions need to be made at 19 — nothing about life at that age is set in stone, identity especially.
I'm critical of the current framework of trans thinking, which holds that there is no barrier to the definition: you don't need dysphoria to be trans or to meet any criteria except to think that you are trans. If someone detransitions, that means either they used to be trans but aren't anymore (meaning it can be a phase you leave behind, unlike sexual orientation), or that it's possible to think you're trans and be wrong, or that gender is made up and possibly not worth building your entire life around. And if any single one of these things is true, then it means they've paid all this blood, sweat, and tears into something that was never going to pay off the way they wanted it to.
I've argued that claims about 'woman feelings' being objectively real and unique from man feelings are incoherent — when asked to describe what feeling womanish feels like and how it differs from feeling like a man, people can't. You can't claim woman feelings objectively exist and are unique from man feelings when you can't even explain what they are. Feelings can't be both subjective and ineffable and a scientific phenomenon at the same time.
I also believe that a partner has a right to know before marriage whether they're legally and financially binding themselves to a man or to someone who identifies as a woman. And I've said that phalloplasty is simply not advanced enough at this moment in time to make it worth the risk and expense — the results are just not as good or reliable as vaginoplasty. I know what it's like to feel like the real me is just my brain and my body is a prison for it.
I think that when someone has tried both testosterone and estrogen and is unhappy with both, the issue is emotional, not chemical or neurological. It's like someone who keeps moving because they think their problem is that every new city starts sucking as soon as they get there. There is a fundamental discomfort with the body that demonstrably persists throughout all the modifications made to it, and that needs examination of one's history, beliefs, and thought patterns rather than continually trying to turn the body into a new person. The treatment for anorexia isn't liposuction — the treatment is getting your mental health straightened out.
I've also noted that detransitioners and desisters are often shunned by former friends who had previously been very supportive when we reconsidered and returned to our birth identity. People have decided that your gender is a personal attack on their values, and it's painful to have to keep silent or lie about a major development in your life. I've argued that society will treat women like actual women no matter what, which is why transitioning becomes a fruitless endeavor for us — women's feelings are tolerated only when they're a sign of submission or compliance. I've also pushed back on claims of female social privilege, arguing that women face real material disadvantages.