Tutte le storie

Commentare su r/detrans senza aver fatto la transizione

Femmina · Desistito/a164
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna sulla fine dei venti che non ha mai pubblicato la propria storia di transizione, ma commenta regolarmente su r/detrans consigliando di non fare cambiamenti permanenti al corpo quando si è incerti. Ho descritto tre problemi di salute tra i 19 e i 21 anni che mi hanno depressa ma che alla fine ho accettato, e questo mi ha permesso di godermi otto anni di vita nonostante tutto. Sono critica verso le comunità trans online che hanno fretta di affermare giovani vulnerabili e mi aspetto che emergano molte altre storie di detransizione. Consiglio Irreversible Damage e il libro di Deborah Soh, e non ho descritto di aver fatto ormoni o interventi io stessa. Non mi identifico come trans.

Storia completa

I have never posted my own story here, but over the years I have written a lot of comments to people who are questioning or considering transition, and what I say to them reflects what I have been through and what I now believe. The clearest thing about my own timeline is my age. In August 2022 I wrote that I had "suddenly gotten 3 issues that heavily affected my quality of life on a daily basis (age 19-21, I'm now 27)." So I am now in my late twenties, and whatever happened to me in my late teens and early twenties shaped how I talk to people here. I have not described those three health problems in detail, only that each time I thought it was the end of the world, that I would sink into depression or try to deny that the problems might not go away, and that in the end I accepted them and moved on with my life. I said I have "really enjoyed 8 years of life despite them" and that "suicide is robbing yourself of so much joy." I do not describe having had hormones or surgeries myself. What I do say, repeatedly, is what I wish other people would do: don't make permanent changes while you are uncertain. In July 2022 I told someone, "Give everything some time and air to breathe. Don't make any permanent health decisions if you're on the fence. If you're on the fence now, who knows where you could be the rest of your life if you permanently change your body." I added that after the cheering and support from the online trans community fades away, "you're stuck with the changes you made to your body and you'll have to deal with them if you're happy or not." In August 2022 I put it more bluntly: "If you're uncertain just don't do anything permanent to your body. Everything else goes away but the damage doesn't." And to someone worried about being a masculine girl: "There is nothing wrong with being a girl who likes some masculine things. It's normal and comes and goes. The important thing is to not do anything that permanently damages your body. Everything else will sort itself out." I am clearly writing from a female perspective — I talk about being "a girl who likes some masculine things" as a normal, ordinary thing, and I frame the risk as damage to a developing body. I also commented approvingly on someone who apparently avoided surgery, saying "Yeah good thing you didn't do any surgeries." What led me to the views I hold now is a combination of my own health experience and what I have seen in these communities. I am critical of how quickly the online trans community will affirm people: I warned that "they seem to label everyone as an egg but usually, they're just tom boyish or just gay." I have called out what I see as arrogant, gatekeeping behavior from people who push others toward transition, calling it "so dispicable." I am worried about vulnerable young people specifically: "So many people are drawn in at a very vulnerable period in their life by these communities," and I distinguished between the annoying side of that and "the real damage... the damage someone does to their body when they're developing." I expect more detransition stories to surface. In July 2022 I wrote, "I feel like there will be a lot more stories like yours coming out in the next 5 years and a lot that don't in fear of being transphobic." I have recommended Abigail Shrier's Irreversible Damage and Deborah Soh's book as "really good takes," which tells you where I land politically on this issue — I am skeptical and critical of the current affirmative approach, though I have not described any formal advocacy or activism of my own. My mental health has been a real part of this. I have described sinking into depression over health problems that felt permanent, and I have talked about suicidal thinking in the abstract as something that robs a person of joy — I framed it as an argument against giving up, which suggests it is something I have had to reason myself through. I have not described self-harm or a suicide attempt. As of my last comment in January 2024, I was on the other side of these conversations, asking someone else how their mental space had changed over ten years and whether their feelings about surgery or the community had changed — which suggests I think of these things as shifting over long stretches of time, as mine have. I do not currently identify as trans, and I write about bodies and gender from the standpoint of someone who is female and settled in that, but I have not used a specific label for myself in this transcript.