Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna detransizionata/desistita, una lesbica butch e mascolina che si è identificata come transmasculina/non binaria e nel 2018 ha cambiato legalmente il nome in una versione maschile, ma non ha mai iniziato gli ormoni dopo aver saltato l'appuntamento alla clinica del genere sentendosi sollevata. Ho passato circa un decennio immersa online nella teoria trans e queer a partire da un'adolescenza solitaria e ricca di arte su Tumblr, e l'influenza dei coetanei, con tutte le mie amiche butch che diventavano FTM, mi faceva sentire che «il mio momento stava arrivando», insieme a dismorfia corporea, una balbuzie legata alla depressione, genitori assenti e un'infanzia turbolenta. Tagliare i ponti con quei circoli all'inizio del 2019, ascoltare donne detrans e vedere a una festa i cambiamenti dovuti alla T in un'amica un tempo bellissima mi hanno convinta che la T non facesse per me. Accettare di essere una donna ha richiesto quasi sei mesi di non sentirmi come se mentissi a me stessa; oggi dico di essere una donna che è anche molto mascolina e che va bene così. Gestisco l'immagine corporea con il sollevamento pesi e costruendo un fisico mascolino, e ho sostenuto che la vita e la salute mentale delle persone vadano indagate a fondo prima della transizione medica.
Storia completa
I was born female and have always identified as butch or masculine, realizing I was a lesbian as a kid. I'm in my mid 20's now (as of mid-2019). I've had many depressive periods throughout my life, my self-esteem is poor, and my body image has been poor too. My dysphoria centered mainly around the shape of my body — how girly and, when I was younger, how fat it was — so it wasn't quite the typical dysphoria I associated with transsexualism, but I desperately wanted, and part of me still wants, a body built more like a man's. My voice also made me uncomfortable because it is a woman's voice, but with a little digging I realized my hatred of my voice and of speaking stems from an intense stutter that developed when I had my first depression.
I was fairly lonely as a teenager and didn't have many friends. I spent most of my time online, did a lot of art, and was on Tumblr a lot, where I was constantly bombarded with different ideas and beliefs. One that stuck with me for years after I deleted my blog and stayed off social media was the idea that "if you think you're trans — you are trans" or "if you ever question your gender, you are trans." I spent, or wasted, a decade of my life in circles surrounding trans and gender politics.
I was certain that going on testosterone would help me feel so much more at home with myself: it would give me the body I wanted, more strength, more muscles, and easier size gains at the gym; my voice would get deeper; and people would take me seriously when I spoke up in crowds. I thought solving those issues would literally clear out my recurring depressions. Another reason I wanted to transition was that literally every one of my masculine/butch friends had started T and were all FTM now, as were many people I used to follow online — I just felt like my time was coming up. With my recurring depression, I know it is mainly because of absent parents and a turbulent childhood.
Last year (2018) I changed my name legally to a gender-neutral, more masculine-leaning version of my name. At first I loved it and it felt so right. I live in one of the countries that requires approximately two years of therapy and counseling prior to getting help with hormones and surgery, so I got in line for an appointment, which would take many months. I eventually got a date at the gender clinic, but I missed the appointment by a week — I had thrown away the letter, didn't remember the exact date, and have huge issues with making calls — and I felt relieved. By that time I had realized I felt at a loss about my new name: I felt like I was living in disguise, everyone treated me differently, not wanting to accidentally offend me, and I could never relax around people because I felt I could never be my normal self. I had been keeping up an idea of a trans identity.
Earlier in 2019 I came to terms with and decided to cut myself off from most trans/queer theory circles around me, mainly on social media but also in real life, after realizing that applying their rhetoric to myself only made me hate myself and my body even more. Ever since then I've taken a step back, worked through my thoughts, and listened to a lot of interviews and videos of detrans and desisted women, coming to realize where many of my feelings come from.
A concrete turning point happened earlier this year (2019) at a party: one of my friends who had started T was there. I used to think they were absolutely gorgeous pre-T, and my girlfriend — who is only into very masculine women — used to think this person looked great back then too. But when we met them at the party we were both shocked by how there was no attraction towards them. That experience really made me certain that T wasn't for me. It also helped reading this subreddit about the negatives of starting T — sexual organ atrophy and hair loss being the main ones I can think of. Especially the first seems horrible, as it causes a lot of pain and can make sex and orgasms painful, and it can even be deadly.
Once I started questioning everything and trying to understand why my "being true to myself by being ftm/non-binary/transmasculine" only made me more alone and isolated — the answer being that no one outside the queer community understood or was comfortable with it, and it was a pipeline where all my thoughts, interests, time and energy got wasted on things that didn't progress my life at all — the absolute hardest part to come to terms with was accepting me being a woman. It took me almost six months to not feel like I was lying to myself by calling myself a woman. The truth is, I am a woman, a female. It's not a feeling. No one who is "cis" feels like they're a man or a woman, they just are a person. Today I can finally say that I'm a woman who happens to be very masculine, who thrives on being seen as manly, and that's okay.
I have dealt with a lot of disordered eating and got ridiculously bad body dysmorphia, though I have never dealt with anorexia or been in clinical contact about those things. One thing that has helped me deal with the anxiety that female fat distribution gives me is weightlifting/bodybuilding — lifting weights and building muscle is the only thing where we can decide what part of our body grows bigger and what part we don't emphasize. I focus mostly on building the muscles that give a more masculine build, which has helped enormously with my dysphoria/dysmorphia. The pro is that it requires healthy food and sleep habits; the con is that someone inclined toward obsessive food/health choices could develop that here too. Masculine women who inspire me as body goals include Ehea Schuerch (a CrossFit competitor), and jkiillem and momomuscle on Instagram.
Since I peaked, I've unfollowed everyone who identified as trans in any way but who wasn't on T. I've also been impressed by what voice training can achieve — I saw an example that sounded completely female. I have never undergone hormones or surgery; I never got past the intake appointment at the gender clinic.