Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I was born female and had what I describe as a normal, girly childhood — I was the girliest girl as a child and grew into a feminine woman. I am 21 years old now (as of early 2024), middle eastern, and I have always been hairy; I was bullied severely as a child for being a hairy girl, and my mom forced me to wax my body hair starting when I was 9. That same year, at 9, I also developed binge eating disorder, and I was always a chubby girl — now I describe myself as an overweight woman with a very feminine, hourglass figure, big breasts and a big booty.
Growing up, misogyny bothered me a lot. I started to feel how disgusting it is to be a woman — I hated periods, hated how estrogen supposedly makes women more emotional, hated the pressure to be a size 0 and wear makeup every day. I felt I had to fit the feminine woman stereotype because I wanted to be loved. When I got tired of everything I had to do to be accepted as a woman, I started thinking I'd be so happy if I were a man. Those thoughts kept coming; I tried to distract myself but couldn't. Eventually I told myself, 'okay that's it, maybe I am a trans man,' and started to accept that as my 'reality.'
Thankfully I never medically transitioned — no hormones, no surgeries — but I did socially transition and lived as a trans man for a period. There were people fueling it, saying things like 'you are really a man, you are not emotional like other women,' which I didn't recognize as sexist at the time. I was too busy feeling happy that misogynistic men were accepting me into their male friend groups. I later came to see that the so-called 'trans joy' was basically male privilege, and that feeling 'free' was really just relief from misogynistic standards that harm women.
What ultimately moved me toward detransition was a combination of critical thinking and therapy for the actual underlying problems. I looked up what I call 'transphobic hate group' detrans subs, gender critical people, professors and scientists, and realized there is no such thing as feeling like a gender. I also had a psychiatrist appointment: when I told her I felt like a man, she said it was not an illness, that I shouldn't go to therapy for it, and that I should start transition — after only one single session with me. I did not listen to her. Instead I researched what I could do other than transition and questioned everything about myself. I realized my 'dysphoria' was actually caused by my eating disorder and the trauma of being heavily bullied for my weight as a child, which had left me disconnected from my body, my soul, and my gender. I started going to therapy for the eating disorder and the bullying trauma instead of seeking a gender change, and after that I feel better, secure, totally okay in my body, and connected with my womanhood.
I also came to believe that gender roles, not dysphoria, were driving a lot of what I felt. I questioned whether what I called dysphoria was really just trying to meet the standards of what a man 'should' be. I now think gender or sex is just what you're born with, and that defining genders by stereotypes is wrong and offensive — there are masculine women and feminine men. I also came to believe that misogyny is a main cause for many trans men: the media we consume overwhelmingly features male protagonists, and I noticed that when I asked myself what gender I wanted to be, the answer was 'a man' because I wanted to be the main character, not the boring village girl the main character marries. I see that pattern in myself.
I also posted about an eating disorder and body image: after trying to lose weight unhealthily and failing, I disconnected from my body and felt like a gross human being who didn't deserve love, even with my hourglass figure. I felt inferior to people who are fit, and feeling not feminine enough to be a woman traumatized me so badly that I coped by thinking I was a man. Consequences of bullying, unrealistic beauty standards, misogyny, lookism, and body shame all fed into it.
On March 6, 2024, I posted that I miss being a woman — I miss being his girl, his soon-to-be wife, I want to carry our child and get pregnant, I miss girlhood, sisterhood, and sapphic spaces (I am bisexual). I am now in a heterosexual relationship with a man. I wrote that sometimes I still feel 'deceiving thoughts' but that I am a woman, that my body, my vagina, and my breasts don't deserve to be removed, that my body needs love and doesn't need to be fixed — I just need to learn how to love it. I also asked for help learning to love being a woman, noting that the fetishization of yaoi and yuri manga/anime at a young age can mess up someone's mind, and that being a guy had seemed 'freeing, happier, something desirable, no more heavy breasts, no more periods, muscles.' I want to romanticize and see the beauty of being a woman again, and I want to be a mom.
I have also become quite vocal about the ethics of transition medicine. I posted asking whether it is even ethical to perform trans surgeries, especially bottom surgeries, arguing that people who want top and bottom surgeries should be sent to a psychiatrist to find the real reason behind the desire — personality disorders, autism spectrum, body image issues, derealization, dissociation, traumas, sexual assault, misogyny, patriarchy, bullying. I noted that I've seen detrans people say doctors approve hormones after one single session, which mirrors my own experience with my psychiatrist. I believe nobody should be given hormones and surgeries when there are other issues going on, and I said (perhaps intemperately) that I've never seen a trans person without mental issues, adding that I myself have an eating disorder that was the cause of my dysphoria. I also said I am not going to vote for it but don't think it is ethical to perform surgeries on people who are clearly not mentally well and need therapy instead. I believe bottom surgeries are riskier than top surgeries, cannot be reversed, and can never be functional like natural genitalia.
I have engaged with the community actively: I warned others about a creepy guy DMing people in the detrans subreddit asking sexual/BDSM/feminization questions (he reached me from a different account after I blocked him, and I contacted the mods); I mistakenly accused another commenter of being that person and apologized publicly; I started a thread asking for opinions on retransitioners; and I've discussed regret rates, noting I didn't know transgender women's regret percentage was that high compared to transgender men's.
Current status: I identify as a woman again — a detransitioned/desisted woman, proud of my female body, in a heterosexual relationship, bisexual, wanting to become a mother. My eating disorder is something I am still working on (I asked for tips to get rid of it). My regret is not about medical changes since I never medically transitioned, but about the time and identity spent socially transitioned and the near-miss with a psychiatrist who almost pushed me into medical transition after one session. I feel relieved and grateful I didn't. I am critical of transition for others, especially when underlying trauma, eating disorders, body dysmorphia, or mental illness are untreated, and I advocate for therapy before any medical intervention.