Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I was born female and I have never medically transitioned — no hormones, no surgeries, no puberty blockers — so my story is one of desistance rather than detransition. I grew up as a happy, confident tomboy with no discomfort about my sex characteristics at all as a child; my difficulties were social, with problems relating to my peers, and I was always deeply unfeminine — I never liked dresses or skirts, and on the rare occasions I wore one I felt weirded out and self-conscious about how to sit, whether I'd expose myself, and how much I hated tights. Other girls were more feminine than me and never looked as out of place as I did.
I don't look feminine — my body shape and face aren't it — and because of that I could never perform femininity or blend in with other girls. I have PCOS, which adds body hair, hair loss, and other masculine-coded features; I've used topical minoxidil and a wide-tooth comb for hair shedding, and I've had to pluck hair. The only time I grew my hair long I got misgendered the most, because I looked like a typical tween metalhead boy. I've been taken for a guy often enough that it happens regularly — once a lecturer emailed asking whether I was trans because of how I spoke and offered accommodations, and I ghosted the email. Being read as male was never affirming; it always felt like "another person sees I fail at being a woman" and made me sad. I've also been called everything other than she in meetings and budding friendship groups where people could plainly see I'm female but treated my short hair and clothes as grounds to eject me from womanhood — that angered me because of the sexism in it. By contrast, being mistaken for male by busy counter staff who barely hear me speak doesn't upset me at all.
I always felt like a failed woman and an Other, lost among women who adhere to traditional femininity, and I envied people whose identity feels stable, cis or trans. I'm bisexual with a preference for men. I definitely wish I had been born male — not to be treated better as a man, just to have a cis male body — and that wish was present for so long I don't remember when it started. But I don't have the inner conviction of being a man that trans guys describe: "I wish I were born one, but I'm not one" fits me best. I have body dysphoria, mostly about my breasts, and it peaked when I gained COVID weight and became someone who doesn't look like a woman but now also with a big bust and hips, which made me feel grotesque. I don't need a penis either, though I noted it's a curious fantasy.
I seriously considered transition and talked myself through the list of changes testosterone would bring: more body hair (I hate what I have), facial hair (absolutely not), voice drop (my current voice doesn't bother me and I don't want "trans voice"), receding hairline (would make me feel worse than I already do), body odour, skin texture, acne — all no's. I already deal with PCOS-related hair issues, and I have vaginismus that I consider hell, so the prospect of an atrophied vagina was another no. I imagined myself going through transition the way happy trans guys do — watching my body change and anticipating each shift — and felt "pure fucking terror." What I wanted was a completely different person: taller than me, no hips, an entirely different face — a guy who doesn't share a single physical quality with me. T wouldn't make me taller or my hips narrower; I'm an adult. Realising I didn't actually want to transition, rather than that I was a dysphoric coward too repressed to do it, made my body image problems far more manageable. Knowing I don't want to transition removed the feeling that I was missing out on something.
My first post about dysphoria was in September 2021. I tried being more feminine and felt like a clown — wearing makeup makes me feel like a clown, and I don't advise it. I considered the non-binary/agender route but dismissed it as something I'd only be doing on the internet, since my native language is fully gendered — "another schizophrenic existence that's not sustainable." I decided instead to get physically stronger through weight training, hoping the strength itself would give me the masculinity I was seeking and that losing weight would shrink the breasts and hips that caused me most discomfort.
What moved me toward desistance was largely a reframe. I read an excerpt from Ian Goddard's (cited via) "Cracked: Why Psychiatry Is Doing More Harm Than Good" about the "symptom pool" — the idea that cultures carry a set of legitimate symptoms people unconsciously gravitate toward to express distress, and that if enough people talk about a symptom and an accepted authority legitimises it, more people manifest it. That explained my situation far better than a secret, inherent trans identity: I'm an anxious twenty-something with no history of childhood sex dysphoria who could have internalised dysphoria's symptoms as they became widely discussed. I'd also had a "gender crisis" around mid-2021, roughly half a year before I described it in January 2022, and I was genuinely angry at myself for falling into it, because I could see how much time spent online played into it. I had watched many butches disidentify, and even gender-conforming people start identifying as non-binary for not fitting strict roles, and I was ashamed to say it shook my confidence as a gender-nonconforming woman. I had also internalised symptoms before: on Tumblr, when self-diagnosing was encouraged and people blogged symptom lists, things that had never been my problem started appearing in my life; removing those people from my dash made me feel much better. My first exposure to trans narratives was an early-2010s Tumblr blog by an ftm person from my country who said they'd been "diagnosed" with a male nervous system in a female body via psychotests — I accepted that at the time without question.
I also came to see that the idea of being trans had offered a tidy explanation for lifelong struggles — "of course you felt x about z, you were supposed to be a man" — and that we're wired to latch onto things that appear to explain the world. I concluded I most likely have body dysmorphia rather than gender dysphoria, and that my male fantasies are a maladaptive coping mechanism rather than something I actually want made real. I also identified autohomoeroticism (linked to Blanchard's typology) as a relevant concept, and reflected that when you want a relationship with a man but feel being a woman means constantly fighting to be seen as equal, you can end up idolising same-sex relationships for the equality they seem to offer — which is where slash fiction and fandom come in for me. I noted that transitioning can function as a form of extreme depersonalisation: "these awful things are happening to girl-me, but she's not real, I don't claim her."
I never stopped believing in transsexual people — those who actually undergo medical transition — but I no longer accept the common immaterial understanding of gender. I describe myself as a "gender atheist" using classic definitions: male and female are the sexes defined by gamete size, men and women are male and female people, no strings attached. I reject the label "cis" because it presupposes an inner gender identity I don't think exists; most cis people, in my experience, simply answer "I was born this" and never think about gender, so either everyone is non-binary/agender or the concept is flawed. I say I'm just human, female, wearing and doing whatever I want. I do recognise sex dysphoria as real, and I'd accommodate trans people socially where possible, but I don't accept that dysphoria equals a fixed trans/cis dichotomy — I prefer "dysphoric" and "non-dysphoric," with "trans" reserved for those who actually medicalise. I was a transmed at one point. I've also argued that grouping intersex people with LGBT was a mistake: intersex conditions are disorders of sex development in male or female people, not a third sex.
I have no history of childhood dysphoria and I'm now in my late twenties. As of February 2023 I described myself as "desisted, not detransitioned," saying I'd dissected and outgrown my dysphoria — the familiar pang still comes but is much rarer, and I no longer consider transition beneficial. I wrote in February 2024, over two years after my first post, that it gets better: from feeling bad all the time, to worse and better days, to maybe one bad day a week, and that in terms of being a functional person, "Hell yes. I am doing fine." I don't dwell on wishing to have been born male anymore; the hardest part had been feeling I was missing out by not transitioning, and knowing I don't want to fixed that. I'm content because I worked through and outgrew my discomfort rather than repressing it, though I wish I hadn't had to do it alone. I rejected the idea that embracing femininity was necessary to feel okay as a female, since femininity doesn't come naturally to me and framing it as necessary would only make me reject being female.
I've been active in detrans and questioning communities since 2021, offering my perspective as a female desister, and I've posted at length criticising the current popular understanding of gender, gender influencers, and gender ideology. I've shared Jamie Reed's Free Press whistleblower article in full on the sub, criticised gender-affirming therapists for talking over people with reasons not to transition, and pushed back on the idea that anyone is trying to legally bar adults under 25 from transitioning. I'm critical of trans influencers who say you don't need dysphoria to be trans, that you can just try hormones, or who treat teenagers on short-term HRT as authorities. I'm hostile to conservative and religious framing of gender too — I say I could never work through my troubled feelings about being female in a sexist society if the solution were championed by people who want me to align with that sexist society. I've advocated for exploratory therapy for dysphoric people as a baseline position, warned an mtf poster not to undergo what I called the most strenuous surgical intervention available to them without clarity, and suggested weight training and physical activity to others dealing with dysphoria. I've also expressed support for female-only events and spaces, and frustration that women can't advocate for single-sex spaces without being cast as right-wing colluders.