Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I was born female and transitioned to male medically and socially for about 3 years, starting around age 20, and began detransitioning in 2022 at age 23. I first came to Reddit in May 2022, saying I was new to the platform and starting to detransition after transitioning from female to male.
Looking back on what led me to transition: I was always uncomfortable with my femaleness and drawn to male things, and I was always attracted to women and dated only women. I had a misogynist father who painted being male as superior. I both despised him and wished to be accepted by him as a tomboy, but was often dismissed because I was a girl. I was always compared to the brother I didn't have. I'd beg him to take me golfing and fishing but he'd go easy on me and be awkward around me, and I could tell he didn't really want to hang out with me. I needed a strong male lead. I fought with him a lot in high school and developed a real disdain for men; I was through and through a radical feminist. I also felt othered in my home life when young, so I created a worldview that continued to make me feel that way because it was all I knew. I briefly identified as non-binary before identifying as a trans man. FTM trans YouTubers contributed toward my decision to transition when I was 20, 5 years prior to 2024 — I was a big fan of Miles McKenna and bought their merch, and also watched Noah Finnce, Jackson Bird, and Ty Turner. I got very spiritual before and during my transition; in my city the queer community is very into crystals and witchcraft, and I was a complete stoner. I lost touch with reality, trusting anything that could have been 'a sign' to transition instead of myself. I found community at first, like everything clicked, then became a loner stoner with my brain on overdrive. I gave myself my first T shot at a super intense terrible moment and felt rushed into the whole process. I felt like I was unrightfully playing God and something in me knew transition was wrong for me. I had a detransition dream after beginning transition that I never forgot even though I tried to shake it off so I wouldn't detransition: I woke up from a surgical table, looked in a mirror, and had the head of someone else I knew rather than myself, which was terrifying. I got off T during the pandemic but continued smoking, then got back on T because I wanted my transition to be right so badly. I was in and out of psychosis when I started something at 20 (mood stabilizers/antipsychotics came later). I was invested in an unhealthy relationship and barely recognized myself; I stopped smoking in August when that relationship ended horribly, then went into a deep isolation period, was put on mood stabilizers and anti-psychotics, and only went to work and slept. I moved out of a bad living arrangement back in with family. A therapist told me to stop punishing myself in a way that finally got through.
I decided to stop testosterone while working a Mother's Day brunch — I had to sit in a bathroom stall to breathe, frozen and heavy. The feeling of playing god never left. The idea of being a mother is terrifying but is such an innate desire, and it was devastating to take that away from myself. I quit my serving job (which paid well and I enjoyed) where everyone knew me as male and I was stealth, putting in two weeks in May 2022. Living as male gave me a fragmented self that could compartmentalize things overwhelming to my psyche, and everyday tasks became easier and fear disappeared, but it never sat right with my soul and the cognitive dissonance caused major anxiety leading to compulsive substance abuse. Only my family knew about my detransition initially; they kept using he/him pronouns and told me to take it slow, which made me feel powerless. My mom was shocked I quit my job. I've had top surgery (at age 21) and they did not understand my grief. I felt alone in my experience. I got my period for the first time after stopping T for 4 weeks, on my last day of work after downloading the Holy Bible app and praying — I took it as a sign from God that my body was working as it was meant to.
Socially, I told people slowly, one-on-one by text rather than mass messaging, and didn't change social media at first. I texted people individually from all stages of my life, including an old neighbor who had still used my trans name/pronouns even when I was presenting female in a one-piece bathing suit. People from my trans circle were supportive. Eventually I made a long, honest post on Facebook that got really positive feedback. I went to the DMV to change my license back to my birth name using a passport from before my transition; to change my gender marker back I needed a physician's note. Even while changing my name back, wearing jean shorts, makeup, and filling out my top surgery with a bra, I still got called 'sir' — which confirmed to me that hearing 'sir' isn't right for me. I told my sister casually, 'Is this something I really want? I don't know, and I've been feeling that way for a while.' My sister took it really hard and my family initially freaked out, but ultimately I'm a lot closer with them now than I was. I later told the surgeon who performed my mastectomy and the gender clinic where I got hormones about my detransition.
Medically: I was on testosterone for about 3 years (roughly 2019-2022, with a break during the pandemic), had top surgery (double mastectomy) at age 21 (around 2019-2020), and stopped T in spring 2022. My doctor told me if it's more than 6 months to get checked, and my levels were good. The mastectomy is the main irreversible change I grieve — I cried in my car because I won't be able to breastfeed my future babies, something my mom didn't do with me and I wish she had. I felt awful given the formula shortage at the time for what I chose to do at 21. I'll never experience that bonding moment in the hospital. I worried I'd never find a husband because I have no breasts of my own choosing, and I was still paying off the surgery. Four years after the mastectomy (2024) I was still processing it. I started researching breast reconstruction, had a consult with a doctor who specializes in mastectomy reconstruction for breast cancer survivors, and planned to talk to more doctors, audio record consults, and sit on the decision — estimating it might be a year and a half before doing anything. I noted insurance covers breast reconstruction. I also started laser hair removal on my face and grew my hair out. I did a remote software engineering bootcamp 40 hours a week for 3 months, going by my birth name on camera, then spent months applying to jobs until I got a good job in that field.
Mental health: I had anxiety, depression, a deep isolation period, was on mood stabilizers and anti-psychotics, and was in and out of psychosis around age 20. I struggled with guilt and rumination over my mistakes, compulsive substance abuse (heavy marijuana use), and an unhealthy relationship. After detransition, my mental health improved substantially — I described being much more peaceful and healthy 2.5 years in, and said things make sense again even if they aren't perfectly peaceful. In the beginning of detransition I was bawling every day and spent a lot of time heads down processing. A therapist helped me stop punishing myself.
On causes: I think my sexuality was a factor — I was a lesbian before transitioning and dated women while presenting as a trans man, and after detransitioning and processing everything I've felt differently about my sexuality. I think being drawn toward women in a lot of ways is a trauma response for me because of my awful father relationship. My relationships with women haven't felt balanced — they weren't abusive but were 'sorta crazy.' I also experienced fear of sexualization, inner misogyny, and black-and-white thinking as possible factors in considering transition. I described my whole transition as not truly contemplated — like living out some weird processing thing, in a fog, depersonalized and far removed. I also said the masc identity can serve as a defense mechanism to fight/flight feelings, and that I had a dissociative split I haven't fully understood. I described feeling like I had to transition as being like some form of OCD and anxiety.
On what moved me toward detransition: I had many pivotal moments and glimpses of clarity. I got off T during the pandemic, then back on, then finally stopped in spring 2022. Therapy helped (the therapist who told me to stop punishing myself). Faith became central — I downloaded the Holy Bible app, have always felt called to a relationship with God, and my personal relationship with God has been my driving force to keep going. I changed my religious identification (not officially). I also watched the documentary 'What is a Woman' and was fired up about it, wanting to speak my truth. I've become critical of gender ideology, saying I refuse to be part of it and that it will go down in history books as a failure. I've also noted that I had glimpses of clarity during transition but became disoriented and would interpret the sinking bad feeling as a good one.
Regret: I regret the mastectomy deeply — 'it was pure lies and I wish I never did it' — and I grieve not being able to breastfeed, the loss of my breasts, and the money I'm still paying. I feel guilt for not accepting myself as I was, regret over distancing myself from peers, and grief over lost time. I also regret the rushed nature of my transition and that I didn't fully consent because my mental health was so horrible at the time. The grief comes in waves and time does make things easier. I also feel guilt for people I unknowingly steered during my transition. Regret, while painful, I see as healthy because it's a sign of growth, but I make sure it doesn't eat me.
Socially, I put a wedge between my friends when I transitioned and I'm closer with them now. Sometimes I feel internally disconnected from them because I feel like I went to hell and back and can't relate to their dramas, though I never lead with a victim mentality. I have nieces and plan to be honest with them when they're older. I teach Sunday school. I'm mid-20s now (25 as of April 2024). I've dated since detransitioning, disclosing my detransition on dates 1-3 and debating putting it on my dating profile; I'm self-conscious about the mastectomy in relationships. I've never been with a guy, only girls, my whole life, though I've become open to the possibility. I'm looking for a serious relationship.
On attitudes toward transition for others: I'm critical. I believe adults have the right to live how they want but that others shouldn't be forced to define them as the opposite sex. I think transition shouldn't be defaulted as the treatment for dysphoria, that gender therapists aren't helpful, that the affirmation model isn't real therapy, and that rushed decisions by young people or those with mental health issues are especially concerning. I've advocated for protecting children, women's spaces, and biological sex in legal/medical records. I've spoken up in online discussions, debated gender ideology extensively on Reddit, and want to be a voice rooted in reality. I'd refer to a trans person by their chosen name and use neutral 'they' to be polite, but keep some distance. I'm wary of non-binary identification, viewing it in my experience as often a clique, fad, or way to avoid working on underlying issues. I support the idea of therapy before transition (real therapy, not affirmation). I've grown a lot more empathy for men than I once had after living as male, and I now think the feminist movement has turned awful and that masculinity shouldn't be demonized.
Current status: I am a detransitioned woman, 2.5 years into detransition as of August 2024, living out of my parents' house with a good job, at peace and feeling healthy, with a deepening relationship with God. Some family members seem to prefer me being transgender and look at me like I have three heads, so I'm working on boundaries.