Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I have never identified as transgender, and I want to be clear about that up front — my perspective here comes from my own life as a woman who questioned gendered expectations growing up, and from what I have observed more recently online.
I am a millennial. In high school in the early 2000s, homosexuality was not illegal or medicalized, but socially it was somewhat frowned upon. I went through my own phase of questioning things because I was into things that were not as "girly" — science, autos class, and similar subjects. I do think the social structure at the time helped enforce that I was a girl, just one who liked "guy" things. That framing mattered to me: it let me be a girl who didn't fit the mold without needing a new category.
Over time I've come to think that gender dysphoria is a serious, sometimes debilitating condition that needs to be addressed, but I don't think surgeries are the best way to address it for the majority of people. I also don't think encouraging dysphoria the way it currently gets encouraged is the best approach.
A few years ago I noticed a surge in transgender-related cases, especially at younger ages, and wondered when the major shift in approach occurred. I've also been struck by how few non-conservative or centrist outlets report on detransition or transition regret. It feels like there's a forced dichotomy: my conservative friends dislike that I think abortion should be allowed in cases of rape, incest, risk to the mother, or fetal deformity, while my super liberal friends dislike that I think there should be any limits at all. Many of the conservative outlets that do cover detransition also hate immigrants, Muslims, refugees, and poor people — backgrounds I have some connection to — which makes it hard for me to follow them. I've looked for outlets that acknowledge dysphoria but disagree with the current treatment model, and found it difficult. I did check out one writer's work that was recommended to me and found it not bad.
On specific cases, I noted that Kristin Beck detransitioned after documentaries were made and it was front-page news, yet nobody talks about how he detransitioned.
More recently, in 2026, I entered perimenopause. I made an Instagram account to follow doctors who discuss perimenopause symptoms and treatment. Hormones there were always discussed in the context of physiological levels for a woman. My own HRT regimen uses tiny doses and even that has to be fine-tuned — which is part of why I take the potency of hormones seriously.
Almost immediately I started getting tons of trans influencers in my feed. No matter how many times I clicked "not interested" or "made me uncomfortable," more and more appeared, some quite vulgar. The content is all rosy — people removing old photos, life looking perfect. Some accounts might even be fake; nobody is checking. I saw clips framed like "we are going out to find guys who don't know what surprises are in store for them," which struck me as really creepy — I can't imagine if guys posted stuff like that. I also noticed a takeover of intersex content being lumped in; someone literally told me "trans people are like intersex people but just in their brain." I find the focus on exceptions like intersex conditions confusing, because they are exceptions — rare, and hence not the rule.
I also noticed what looked like autogynephilic patterns: creators who seem turned on by the idea of being seen as an attractive woman, some with gynophilia where it is a sex thing, and clips where they act like they are still the penetrative partner — "I hope he isn't sore tehehe" type comments, which I found unethical. There is also an extreme, almost costume-like idea of femininity on display: most women do not regularly dress in tight cocktail dresses and high heels. I live in a blue state and have traveled all over the US, and most people dress the same regardless of region.
Seeing this firsthand showed me how dangerous social media can be. I can't imagine being a teenager with access to modern social media. My head hurts from it, and I will probably delete Instagram or make a new one.
Separately, I've engaged with debates about language in everyday settings — salons being sued for stating there are "men's cuts" and "women's cuts," or estheticians being told that saying male versus female anatomy is incorrect because "a man can have a vulva and a woman can have a penis." I think pricing should be based on time and complexity rather than gender, and I understand practical objections — it would be unfair to a barber charging for a short cut who then spends an hour struggling with long hair. But wanting to sue and feeling "triggered" and traumatized by a sign that simply says men's vs. women's cuts seems like a bit much. It feels like no matter what you say it is offensive, and I say that as a liberal person. I also noticed people who seem obsessed with "the struggle."
Currently I identify as a woman, centrist politically, supportive of dysphoria being treated compassionately but skeptical of the current surgical-first model and of how social media presents transition.