Tutte le storie

Gender Trouble nel 2022 e un'adolescenza perduta

Femmina · Desistito/a90
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna detransizionata che ora si identifica come lesbica. La lettura di Gender Trouble di Judith Butler nel 2022 ha innescato i miei dubbi, e mi sono avvicinata agli spazi femministi radicali senza adottare davvero l'etichetta, anche se il separatismo mi ha influenzata. Mi pento che le preoccupazioni sull'essere trans abbiano consumato la mia adolescenza e mi abbiano tolto hobby e creatività, ma cerco di tenere quel rimpianto in prospettiva. Mi espongo sulla violenza maschile contro le donne e sono critica verso le relazioni con grandi differenze di età e le dinamiche eterosessuali. In questi post non ho descritto dettagli medici, interventi né diagnosi di salute mentale.

Storia completa

I was born female. Looking back, I can see that my whole adolescence and young adulthood got consumed by trans-related preoccupations, and it took reading Judith Butler's Gender Trouble in mid-2022 to shake me out of it — I described having "a moment of acute self-awareness because it was so ridiculous." That anger sent me into radical feminist online spaces, where I said the worst I encountered was "some fear-mongering consisting mostly of AGP Twitter screenshots." I've been careful to say I don't identify as a radical feminist and I'm not a big fan of Dworkin, though I called her pornography writings "pretty based," and I admitted that a couple of radical feminist tenets had influenced my life over the previous couple of years — above all separatism, which I said "probably says all that needs to be said." On sexuality, I've been openly lesbian for a long time. I got my first boyfriend at 14 and remember being in my bedroom with him, looking at his body and thinking, "I do not feel an ounce of attraction toward this guy I'm crazy for." That was the moment I realized I didn't want to kiss or have sex with him or any guy — "it's just not the anatomy I'm into." I told another user that "vibes" are an invalid and highly subjective way to evaluate sexual orientation, and that for a long time I never entertained the possibility I was a lesbian because I wasn't "an outdoorsy butch with a wrench attached to my hip" — no obvious lesbian vibes. I called those conceptions "deeply homophobic" and said they hinder your own path to self-acceptance. I also said I believe all heterosexual attraction to men is "toxic," because the patriarchy will never not play a role in opposite-sex relationships. On regret and what might have been, I wrote in April 2022 that my negative side says I'd be "a lot more well-rounded" without the constant trans obsession — more hobbies, more creativity, likely happier — but I countered that myself: "if not trans stuff, it would have been something else I obsessed over to fill the void." I added that for all I know I "could have tripped down an even worse rabbit hole." That's a fairly measured, ambivalent kind of regret rather than a raw one. I've been vocal about male violence and women's safety. In April 2022 I wrote in all caps, "Wherever you are in the world, IT IS EASIER AND SAFER TO BE MALE. Only a man would think otherwise." When pushed back, I clarified I never said that makes men safer than women, but I defended my claim by citing femicide, existing at nighttime, and different rates of sexual assault and harassment, and I accused others of acting as though "male supremacy ended when American women got the right to vote." I also told someone, "no woman you've ever seen on an online space hates men more than men in real life hate women," and asked for space for women to talk about our issues, suggesting an MRA group might better suit them. I pushed back hard on a commenter who minimized women's victimization, calling it a "dumb comment" and telling them to "get a grip" because women are regularly raped by invading soldiers and civilians die in wartime. I've commented on age-gap relationships, saying that someone being 21 and a partner 32 "tells me all I need to know." I've also endorsed stepping back to see reality — "One of the best things we can do for ourselves is step back and take it all in...including reality" — and summed up a debate as "Impact over intent. Different motivations lead to same result." In February 2024 I thanked someone for "articulating beautiful responses to these arrogant men."