Tutte le storie

La top surgery la tiene, l'ideologia no

Femmina · Detransizionato/a1K
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna detransizionata che ha fatto la detransizione sociale ma non si pente della transizione fisica, in particolare della mastectomia e della voce mascolinizzata. Mi sono identificata come uomo trans, ho fatto testosterone e top surgery, ma sono arrivata a vedere l'ideologia di genere come radicata nel sessismo e nella pseudoscienza dopo aver assistito a quello che consideravo gaslighting e negazione della realtà biologica nelle comunità trans. I miei sentimenti suicidi sono peggiorati con l'affermazione di genere man mano che riconoscevo la distanza tra la mia immagine di me e il mio sesso femminile immutabile. Oggi mi identifico come donna neutra rispetto al sesso, gender-critical e neutra rispetto al corpo, e come bisessuale con preferenza per le donne, anche se resto socialmente isolata e a volte desidero ancora di essere maschio, riconoscendo quei sentimenti come problematici. Sostengo l'autonomia corporea, ma credo che la neutralità verso il corpo e l'accettazione di sé vadano incoraggiate rispetto alla transizione.

Storia completa

I was born female and identified as a trans man for a period of my life. I don't have exact dates for when my dysphoria first started, but I remember feeling intensely unhappy with my female body and being jealous of male voices for many years. I came out and socially transitioned, using masculine pronouns and a masculine name, and I felt in my place only when referred to that way. I genuinely adapted toxic masculinity because I thought of myself as a male and hung out in communities that upheld patriarchal gender norms rather than encouraging gender abolitionism. I believed gender was a psychosocial yet objective phenomenon, like personality, and that being a trans man meant subjectively experiencing life from a male perspective, even if my body wasn't male. I was borderline suicidal about having a female body instead of a male one. I underwent testosterone HRT and had a mastectomy. I don't regret the mastectomy because my breasts were neither physically nor socially convenient for me, and I don't see a reason for breast reconstruction. I was jealous of my girlish voice that embarrassed me and made me feel terrible, and when I finally achieved a male voice I was and still am really glad about it; I started feeling confident in myself and comfortable when talking. However, my expectations weren't fully met: I wanted to be a handsome guy, not what I perceived as an ugly and short parody of a male who couldn't look the way I imagined and dreamed of. I don't have exact dates for when I started or stopped hormones, or the exact timeline of my surgeries. My suicidal feelings got worse due to 'gender affirmation' because the more affirmation I received, the more I saw the abyss between my picture of myself and the sex I actually am and can't change. Things started changing for me when trans-identifying or supporting people suggested you don't need to transition to be trans, and when I wasn't welcome in transmed spaces because I understood gender is a social phenomenon. I witnessed what I saw as gaslighting from both transmed and tucute sides, saw biological facts like the binarity of human sex denied, and saw feminists advocating for female privacy physically assaulted. I realized I couldn't genuinely believe I was male without social validation from people I saw as out of touch with reality. I found desisters and detransitioners who experienced similar or worse gender dysphoria but got rid of the opposite sex identity once they changed the sexist way they viewed men and women and realized sex is immutable. It took time to accept the truth and work on my misogynistic perception of womanhood and female people. I also had AAP (autoandrophilia) inclinations, so sometimes I didn't understand whether I wanted someone or wanted to be someone. I'm bisexual, and as a gender nonconforming woman who believed as a minor to be male inside, I preferred to consider dating only female people because I wanted to perform the gender role assigned to male people. Almost every het relationship I saw implied male domination, so I was sure dating a guy would equal being subjugated myself. I wanted to dominate myself and didn't know actual equality was possible in relationships until I encountered detailed criticism of porn and rape culture. Objectification and humiliation of women in mainstream culture made me repulsed by female anatomy, and I thought relationships inherently implied dominance. I was traumatized by the idea of het relationships because male people tend to socialize in patriarchal ways. My path to recovery involved realizing romantic relationships are supposed to be equal companionship first, discovering gender nonconforming men who respect women, cutting off triggering content, and surrounding myself with smart and gender nonconforming people who shared my values. It changed a lot over time. I still sometimes feel like I'd rather have been a man, but I recognize the problematic roots of these feelings instead of supporting gender affirmation. I now accept that I'm a woman (adult female human) as a neutral medical fact, I'm not triggered by female pronouns anymore, and I intentionally stopped attributing social meaning to female pronouns and associating them with inferiority. I'm sex-neutral and gender critical, and I'm now genuinely body-neutral and gender-neutral, which I appreciate a lot, though I wouldn't say I'm totally body-neutral. Being only in the company of other desisted, detrans and generally gender nonconforming women with anti-patriarchal views helped me a lot to get rid of dehumanization and sexual objectification of our bodies. I'm not a lesbian but a female-preferring bisexual woman, and I sometimes miss when I thought of myself as a het guy, though I know it's not objectively true that girls will love me only if I'm a man. I'm now socially isolated, which is a crucial reason for it. I don't encourage any kind of transition; I think it's definitely not for everyone and can have tragic consequences regarding biological health and psyche. I don't think I was born like this or destined to transition, and I don't think it would be right to encourage anyone to transition or detransition as if it's the only correct choice. I support bodily autonomy for adults but believe we should encourage body-neutrality more. I've met a few gender-critical transitioners in person. I don't identify as a man anymore. I've had a hard time fitting into social standards of both men and women, so I once felt that meant I'm non-binary. As a teen I had similar sadistic feelings and desires but decided not to indulge severe anti-social urges because I didn't want to accept unfair cruel treatment I faced as legitimate.