Tutte le storie

Otto anni da ragazzo trans, senza alcun passo medico

Femmina · Desistito/aPrima disforia 15 → Transizione sociale 15 → Desistenza 23814
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha desistito: mi sono identificata come ragazzo trans dai 15 anni e poi come non binaria fino ai 23, quando ho desistito dopo otto anni senza mai prendere ormoni né fare interventi. La mia disforia nasceva da abusi sessuali nell’infanzia, anoressia, dismorfia corporea, misoginia interiorizzata e anni passati nei circoli di adolescenti trans su Tumblr, e sono arrivata a vedere la mia identità trans come una fuga dalla realtà. Rimpiango gli anni persi e piango ancora la mia adolescenza, ma oggi sono molto più felice e libera e la mia disforia si è in gran parte risolta. Non credo più nell’identità di genere, anche se continuo a sostenere chi decide di fare la transizione e ho ancora amici trans. Ho avuto ideazione suicidaria legata alla disforia per il petto e alla dissonanza cognitiva dell’essere trans, ed è stata una spinta decisiva a fermarmi.

Storia completa

I was born female. I first started questioning gender at 15, when I joined online LGBT/trans teen circles on Tumblr; before that I had not thought much about gender. I identified as a trans boy for about 3 years starting at 15 (ages 15-17), then identified as nonbinary (cycling through agender/genderfluid/genderqueer labels, sometimes 'nonbinary guy' or 'nonbinary lesbian') from about 17 until I was 23. I only ever socially transitioned — I never took hormones or had surgery — though I made appointments at Planned Parenthood for testosterone consultations three times and was tempted to start T repeatedly. I presented super masculine for about 2 of my 8 years identifying as trans; I started using binders at 15. I desisted at 23, in late 2021/early 2022, and stopped identifying as nonbinary about 10 months before November 2022. I went back to my birthname, which felt 'like coming home,' though it was initially uncomfortable. I am now a desisted woman. What led me toward transition: I experienced childhood sexual abuse (CSA) and my female body was heavily sexualized as a child/teen, which made me feel trapped and scared in my body. When I first came out to my mom, the first thing she asked was whether it was because of the CSA — I was hurt at the time, but she turned out to be right. I also developed anorexia as a trauma response (control over my body), have large breasts and body dysmorphia, and struggled with internalized misogyny — I have broad shoulders, thick eyebrows, hormonal acne, and felt 'not womanly enough.' I was autistic-adjacent in that I have ADHD and anxiety and would fixate obsessively; I noted autistic people often don't relate to gender. I was deep in trans/mentally-ill teen Tumblr circles. I also had a period where I thought women were 'better than men' and felt I could never live up to other women, so being a man felt like less pressure. I was hospitalized as a teen for severe mental health issues and was diagnosed with PTSD while institutionalized (until I was 18). I sometimes imagined myself as a man during sex and wanted a penis, but imagining dating as a man felt wrong. I identified as a nonbinary lesbian for years and was scared of being 'The Girl' with a man. What moved me toward detransition: I got burnt out from identity crises every two weeks, going back and forth on hormones and top surgery for years. I realized there would never be an end point — I would never feel like a 'real man' or be seen as nonbinary. I made appointments for T three times and backed out. About 2.5 years before desisting I tried going back to being a woman for a few weeks and changed my mind. Ultimately I decided the doublethink and cognitive dissonance (public seeing me as female vs. trans friends saying I was valid) was making me miserable and I 'put my foot down... just so I wouldn't off myself.' I also realized my reasons for not being a woman relied on sexist ideas, and that gender identity isn't real. Reading gender-critical/detrans perspectives hurt at first but I later concluded 'part of me knew they were right.' Radical feminist ideas about female bodies helped my chest dysphoria. Intentionally befriending more cis women (queer cis people especially) helped me feel less tied to gender roles. Medical: I never took hormones or had surgery. I was on hormonal birth control from age 13 (or 14) to 23 (~10 years) — started for horrible period pain, continued to suppress periods due to dysphoria; Depo-Provera eliminated my sex drive and carries osteoporosis risk. I have since stopped birth control and my periods returned normally and are far less painful than in childhood (ages 9-13 I would lie on the floor in excruciating pain for 2 days a month). I may have an inherited blood clotting disorder (factor V leiden, like my mom) and was advised against estrogen-containing birth control. I have large breasts (D to DD after weight gain); binding barely worked better than a sports bra for me. I no longer want any surgery — at desisting I thought I'd need a reduction someday, but now I don't want cosmetic surgery at all, partly after learning breasts contain lymph vessels. I still can't wear underwire/normal bras (they make me feel ill); I only wear sports bras to work and go braless otherwise. Mental health: PTSD (diagnosed while institutionalized), ADHD, anxiety, anorexia (recovered as a teen), and periods of suicidal ideation related to chest dysphoria — my breasts were sometimes the #1 dysphoric thing 'to the point of feeling suicidal or feeling physically ill and not wanting to leave the house.' I also said the cognitive dissonance of being trans made me feel like my brain was shattering and that I needed to stop 'just so I wouldn't off myself.' Since desisting, my dysphoria has gone away almost entirely; I am no longer suicidal about my breasts and the dysphoria is 'wayy more manageable than it was 10 months ago.' Adversity: CSA, sexual harassment throughout my life, being sexualized as a child/teen, institutionalization as a teen, family issues caused by my trans identification. Social: My family was not religious; my mom asked about CSA when I came out. Transition caused familial issues. My partner is nonbinary (mentioned Jan 2022); I dated an ex-girlfriend whose relationship helped me accept my body, and I dated a transbian during my 'nonbinary lesbian' era whom I now view as a bad relationship. My best friend is a trans woman; I am still friends with almost all my trans friends, though two tried to convince me not to use the word 'detrans.' I have made new friends who don't care about gender. I was very isolated during the pandemic with mostly online friends. Sexuality: I thought I only liked women and called myself a nonbinary lesbian for years, but realizing I am bisexual was part of what helped me realize I'm not trans. I have only dated women in my adult years so far but want to try dating men; I would date a detrans man or woman but not a trans person of either sex now. Regret: I resent my transition and the 8 years I spent identifying as trans. I am 'kind of mad that I let it take over my life for so damn long,' and I wish the earlier attempt at desisting 2 years prior had lasted. I am mourning lost time and think I could be happier, better off, and have more friends if I hadn't focused so much on gender — but I also have sympathy for myself, recognizing trans identity was an escape during my most unstable period, and acknowledge it might have been a mental escape that kept me alive. Regret is present but I am much happier and freer now. Outcomes: I am a desisted woman, braless most of the time, reconnecting with dance/gymnastics/fitness, working an active job, making art, gardening, and focusing on hobbies and my future. I feel 'whole again' and 'truly free from a cycle of agonizing identity crises.' Attitudes: I still support trans people and think transitioning is good for some people, but I no longer believe in gender identity and don't think a man can become a woman or vice versa. I take issue with trans-identified people demanding everyone change how sex/gender are viewed. I am critical of gender-critical/radfem people too — I say they often use detransitioners for their agenda and that their cruelty hurt me — though radical feminist ideas about bodies helped my dysphoria. I advocate for detransitioners being able to speak freely about surgery outcomes and for female-only spaces. I participated in a trans survey (2022) and argue detrans people should participate in research. I have pushed back on misogyny in detrans spaces.