Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna detransizionata che da adolescente e ventenne si è identificata come trans ma non ha mai fatto la transizione medica, e ho desistito più di due anni prima del 2023. Oggi credo che l'identità trans sia un modo di evitare le difficoltà del crescere da femmina e che l'identità di genere non esista: esistono solo maschio e femmina, e la non conformità di genere va benissimo. Conoscere il dottor John Money, gli scritti di Abigail Shrier e la mentalità da vittima che vedevo nel movimento mi ha fatto uscire dal sistema di credenze. Perdere amicizie, tra cui una migliore amica diventata terapeuta di genere che ora mi evita, è stato doloroso, anche se ho un partner che mi sostiene. Sono molto critica verso la medicalizzazione dei minori, incoraggio attivamente chi sta valutando un intervento irreversibile a ripensarci, e faccio fumetti e arte per aiutare gli altri a mettere in discussione l'ideologia.
Storia completa
I was born female and I desisted — I never medically transitioned, which is something I've said explicitly when discussing detransition: 'I didn't medicalize myself so I'm not about to gatekeep or judge anyone for their choices when coping with the aftermath of their medicalisation.' I came to identify as trans during my teens and twenties, and I now describe that period as one of 'confusion and turmoil and denial for years.'
Looking back, I think what led me there was 'a misunderstanding of gender non conforming behaviour + running away from / avoidance of the struggles growing up female in this generation.' I was first introduced to these ideas in art school, inside 'this very alternative subculture.' I also feel that the confusion, anxiety, stress and crisis I experienced in my teens and twenties 'could have been easily avoided and I probably would have been totally fine had i not been spoon fed utter delusion.' I've said trans identity 'is merely an avoidance behavior' and that transition 'feels like fighting against the current.'
What snapped me out of the belief system, I wrote in a post I made, was hearing about histories like Dr John Money and the origin of the idea of gender identity, plus Abigail Shrier speaking about how this affects teenage girls — 'it just made sense to me.' I've also said that realizing how many people in the movement 'act like victims but meanwhile they will treat you like shit and feel justified for it' was 'a huge part that snapped me out of this worldview.' I've been reading and watching widely, including the podcast Gender: A Wider Lens, and I've been making comic strips about historical social contagions like the glass delusion and dancing mania as a way of red-pilling people on the trans issue.
I desisted more than two years before April 2023, since I said 'for over 2 years I keep expecting for people to come to their senses.' The aftermath has been socially painful. My trans friends and ally friends 'became super distant when I desisted which has been very very frustrating.' My best friend is now a gender therapist; I tried warning him about detransitioners 'for his own sake' and 'he just avoids me now.' I'm still struggling with the loss of friends and said 'my framework of the world kind of fell apart after realizing that.' I posted a detrans thing on my Instagram story and then removed it 'to avoid social awkwardness,' frustrated that I feel I have to keep quiet. I live in Canada, where 'every other person I meet is non binary'; I left for a few months in Europe last year and found it a relief because there was much less queer ideology. I work at a large company and encounter this stuff in paperwork and corporate culture — I once wrote 'no pronouns' on a bank form and the clerk responded 'so they them?'
I have an amazing partner I can speak to openly about all this, which I consider myself lucky for. I'm bisexual, but I've distanced myself from the LGBT community because 'it is so toxic and I couldn't live in that mentality forever' — I no longer care to call myself bi, seeing it as a side detail of my life and nobody's business. I've found some comfort in r/gayconservatives as a refreshing alternative. I'm a little older than the younger cohort on the subreddit.
On my own body, I've said I'm 'extremely small chested' and don't have the same issues others describe, but that working out has helped me feel better about myself and 'in control of my body.' I also reflected that I was on birth control in the past and wonder how much it played a role in my distress and other health issues at the time. As I get older, I've said my sex 'just becomes increasingly obvious and how I tried so hard to run away from the inevitable when I was young due to fear and trauma.'
I am strongly critical of youth medicalization. I've called it 'utterly delusional and offensive' that people equate wanting to end harmful medical practices with genocide, and I've said Jazz Jennings' story is 'very sad' and that her family 'really disturbs / disgusts me.' I've repeatedly urged young people considering surgery not to go through with it: 'It's an irreversible surgery... If you have any doubts seriously listen to your gut.' I don't believe in 'true trans' — 'I think trans is something people do not something people are' — and I argue there is no gender identity, only male and female, while gender non-conformity is fine in itself. I think transition should be an absolute last resort for a very small, deeply dysfunctional minority after all other therapy has failed. I'm skeptical of clinicians who show up in detrans spaces; I accused one of manipulation and gaslighting and warned others to be wary of his advice. I've also described a former friend who used HRT like a drug and said that experience 'hit me with the reality of this ideology and that transition is not really how they advertise but something a lot darker.' I've said it's 'without doubt a social contagion' and noted patterns of passive women with pushy boyfriends coming out as non-binary after breakups. I encourage detrans people to keep telling their stories and I'm making art and comics toward that end.