Tutte le storie

Un esterno cis su r/detrans, che offre ciò che poteva

Maschio · Desistito/a106
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un maschio cis etero, non un detransizionato, che ha frequentato r/detrans alla fine del 2022 e all'inizio del 2023 offrendo sostegno e condividendo le mie esperienze di dipendenza (Adderall), insicurezza sulla mascolinità, vergogna sessuale e di crescita in una famiglia distrutta. Ho consigliato alle persone di aspettare prima di fare la transizione, di spezzare i circoli di pensiero ossessivo e di concentrarsi sull'accettazione di sé invece di vedere la transizione come la risposta all'infelicità. Ho consigliato Jordan Peterson, ho reagito a quello che vedevo come il tacitare domande oneste con accuse di transfobia e ho riconosciuto i miei limiti di esterno rispetto a questa esperienza. Resto un uomo cisgender che sostiene i detransizionati come persone pur essendo aperto sulle mie opinioni personali, tra cui il fatto che non potrei uscire con una persona trans.

Storia completa

I'm a straight cis male who ended up spending time in r/detrans not because I transitioned, but because I wanted to offer support to people going through detransition and because I found the conversations there worth engaging with. I've been open about that from the start — I told people upfront that I hadn't transitioned and that they should take what I said with a grain of salt and form their own opinions. I'm 24 years old (as of December 2022). I told an 18-year-old poster that when I look back to that age I was mature for my age but still made decisions whose long-term consequences I didn't understand, and that I'd tell them to wait before transitioning, while acknowledging I couldn't tell them what to do. I asked them to consider whether they could live with regret, whether transitioning now was worth more than waiting a few years, and whether their feelings were about gender dysphoria or a deeper problem. I related to obsessive or fixated thinking patterns. I told people that when I become infatuated with a concept or with something someone said, I step away for a few days — a hiking trip, a weekend out with friends — and come back with a clearer sense of where I stand, sometimes even changing my opinion. I suggested others try breaking the routine that keeps pulling them back into the same questions: playing games after work, taking a few days off, hanging with family, or going to the bar and getting into random conversations. I also reassured one poster that playing as female characters or drawing and creating female characters is done by many guys and doesn't mean someone is the wrong gender. I shared a personal medical experience with medication dependence. A few years ago I was prescribed Adderall and it made me confident, skilled, and focused, but I came to rely on it. That reliance became an addiction — I'd take more than prescribed depending on whether I had work or wanted to be good at a game that day. I tried to convince my doctor I needed a higher dose because I'd taken it so much I was losing the effect. I've now been off it for two years. It was hard at first, but I came to the conclusion that I had it in me the entire time and the Adderall just made it easier. I used this to draw a parallel to someone's concerns about hormones, while being clear I wasn't making a direct comparison. I talked about my own struggles with masculinity and sexuality. I described myself as a skinny guy who has always had doubts about himself because of it — how people look at me, what I'd do in a fight — and said that still crosses my mind. I also described having felt 'dirty' whenever I had a sexual urge: I would send dick pics and look at women imagining fucking them, then look back and feel disgusted. I said I'm now 'beyond respectful' and listen to women, that I've realized the sex drive itself is normal but how I act on it is my choice, and that women actually like that sex drive if they're into you first. On relationships and family, I said I could not date a trans person, but framed that as an honest personal limit rather than a judgment, and told a poster their fear that dating would be harder was justified — while saying I'd take that risk in their position because easy hookups won't make you happy in the end. I said I want kids and a family, because when my parents and grandparents die the closest relationship will be with my kids, and if I have kids I want to know for certain the mother will be around. I grew up in a broken home and said it destroyed my outlook on how men should treat women and what healthy relationships look like. I speculated, cautiously, that a poster's discomfort with body hair 'for sure sounds like autism' and might explain their bodily discomfort, while admitting that was territory I had no experience in. More broadly I suggested that maybe the discomfort is 'all in the head' — that people fixate on transition and detransition because those are tangible things they can point to, when the real work is self-acceptance. I said most detrans posts I saw were really cries for help from people who want to accept themselves, and that it's hard to accept yourself if you feel an old you died with a decision you made. I compared it to how we study airplane crash survivors to pass on knowledge and save lives. I recommended Jordan Peterson to someone who felt their life had no purpose, saying his talks had saved my life. I pushed back on a comment I thought was disingenuous for dismissing concerns about looks as 'a little shallow,' arguing that watching the old you fade away is extremely striking. I also defended an original poster against a 'transphobia' jab, asking whether it's transphobic to ask these questions and, if so, how anyone is supposed to ask them. Toward the end I told someone that a lot of their struggles seemed based on how they wanted to be perceived, that gender isn't all they are, and that they seemed to be seeking a middle ground that appeases everyone, which may not be possible. I offered to message with anyone who needed to talk and kept the door open for further conversation.