Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono un uomo che ha fatto detransition: ho vissuto come donna trans per circa 4,5 anni con ormoni mtf dopo aver fatto la transizione a metà dei vent'anni, e ho fatto la detransition intorno al 2020 dopo un crollo mentale. Ora mi identifico come uomo effeminato e non conforme al genere e mi oppongo con passione alla transizione per chiunque, vedendola come una setta e come un abuso. Ho il BPD, una storia di anoressia (in remissione), un anno di psicosi legato a marijuana e transizione, autolesionismo, e penso regolarmente al suicidio. La mia sessualità è passata da omosessuale a in gran parte eterosessuale in circa cinque anni dopo aver smesso il porno, e convivo ancora con disfunzione erettile, attaccatura dei capelli arretrata e tessuto mammario residuo causato dagli estrogeni. Sono contro la transizione, sostengo la «conversione» verso l'accettazione di sé e sto costruendo un videogioco con un personaggio detrans.
Storia completa
I was born male and I've always been gender nonconforming. As a kid I loved Barbies and other "girl toys," I hated getting my haircut and loved how long wigs made me feel, I had a naturally high voice that sometimes got me told I sounded like a girl, I had a small build, and I leaned feminine in personality. I was also forced at 12 to mow my family's huge backyard even though my personality suited indoor chores, and my sister never had to mow — I still hate lawns because of it. I also developed an eating disorder in my early teens; I now understand that restricting/dieting was my way of separating myself from my overbearing mother who had "let herself go."
I identified as genderqueer before transitioning — this was before "non-binary" was popular. The more I focused on "what gender I felt like," the more female I felt, and it got more pronounced over time, so I decided to transition. I transitioned in my mid-twenties. I saw transition partly as a way to escape aging poorly — I didn't want to become a "wide, leathery, hairy, unkempt old man" like my dad and other men I'd seen. I thought estrogen would stop me from aging into them. Everyone around me affirmed me and pushed back not at all; my parents are classic liberals. I saw a gender therapist and got access to hormones; I can barely remember the conversation. I was on mtf HRT for 4.5 years. I had childhood gender issues that I'd learned to suppress, then after a bad life event I started looking under that rock again and was consumed by what I now call trans ideology — the lie that gender nonconforming equals trans.
While trans I was obsessed with a self-portrait I drew — my body broken into angular pieces, minimalist and abstract so I could avoid depicting my "obviously not female face." I also had full laser hair removal; my beard was thick and full before and is now too sparse to keep long. I obsessively measured my waist while on estrogen. I did not get bottom surgery — that near miss haunts me. I also did not lose my genitals.
I detransitioned about 3 years before these posts (so around 2020, given posts dated 2023). My story is unusual: I detransitioned due to a mental breakdown — I wasn't thinking clearly and decided to detrans on a whim — and only afterward realized transition was 100% a mistake. I did not regret transition until after I detransitioned. After detransing I first went right back to being a "trad male," cut my hair, and then slowly realized gender norms are all bullshit. Now, 3 years later, I'm growing my hair out again, I keep long painted nails (black with a bright sparkly indigo underside), I wear dangly earrings and pastels, and I plan to experiment with skirts and dresses. I have a receded hairline and take finasteride to keep it from getting worse. I still have "moobs" from the estrogen and hope to look into medication for that once I lose weight.
I gained a significant amount of weight after deciding to stop starving myself, and I needed an entirely new wardrobe. Shopping for "male" clothing felt like being a child about to get my hair cut because "boys have short hair" — I couldn't stand men's fashion (button-ups, flannels, jeans, khakis, polos). I eventually searched for "tall women's clothing" (I'm 5'10") and found things that fit and that I liked.
On causes: I now believe transition was driven by my gender nonconformity, strict gender norms, an overbearing mother, fear of aging as a man, my eating disorder's desire to be small (I still look at men and think "they look so large... I don't want to be large"), and a culture that tells feminine boys they aren't real men. I was "consumed by trans ideology." I also say transgenderism "made me insane" — I was psychotic for about a year, half before and half after detransition, which I attribute to a combination of my actions (including being trans) and marijuana usage. I was dependent on being high all the time, had mega social anxiety, cognitive decline, psychosis, and neurosis; compared to now I was "the epitome of a shell of my current self." I also cut daily for 5 years. I have BPD. I struggle with anger — "transition is trauma" — and I say I have something like PTSD from it: thinking about being back there puts me in fight-or-flight. I couldn't stand being alone and felt all the pain when alone.
On therapy: every therapist I could see would gaslight me because I'm anti-trans or because I'm GNC. My current therapist brought up "discrimination against trans people" and it irritated me. A friend was trying to use his connections to find me a therapist, and I contacted GenSpect for therapy help. I said I cannot even call a crisis line about this. I posted in r/mtf about regret and was shadowbanned from Reddit entirely.
On sexuality: I was gay before/during transition — I followed that desire until I found my fantasy guy, "the man of my dreams," and he didn't want me. I started becoming attracted to women while I was trans, and it grew over time as I focused on it, while same-sex attraction diminished as I focused less on it and stopped watching porn. Over about 5 years I went from homosexual to heterosexual; I'm still "kinda bi," but all my masturbatory fantasies now involve me and a woman. I say I "desisted from being gay." I stopped watching porn and stopped having sex with randos; I made my sexual fantasies more positive. I now say heterosexuality is normal and healthy and that I'll call myself "normal and healthy" rather than straight.
On medical recovery: my testosterone was relatively normal at last check. My penis function has "largely returned after 3 years" but isn't totally there yet; my "lil guy" still isn't back to full strength, though I can get it to work when I want. Quitting porn helped the erectile dysfunction. I believe fertility returns within a year or so if there were no surgeries, and that libido came back "full force" in about 6 months, though E damages genitals.
On my current views: I am passionately opposed to transition for anyone. I say transgenderism is a cult, that it's "the left's version of sexism," that transition is abuse and self-harm, that bottom surgery is genital mutilation in any and every case, and that transition medications and surgeries should be banned everywhere. I believe "true trans" is a myth used to gaslight detransitioners — if you transition, you are trans, and detransitioning doesn't retroactively unmake it. I don't have a gender identity and reject the word "cisgender." I believe gender = sex, that gender identity is nonsense, and that the answer to gender dysphoria is to fight gender norms and be GNC as your birth sex. I support "trans conversion therapy" (self-acceptance and integration of GNC behavior) as distinct from gay conversion therapy. I hold critical views of homosexuality based partly on my own experience and my aunt's, and I ground my moral views in the Bible (I am religious, and I've been a target of religious abuse for my long painted nails in my conservative state). I emailed the Missouri government in support of an anti-transition bill — the first time I'd ever done that. I consider advocacy my life purpose: to destroy the attitude that makes feminine boys feel safer in a "costume" than as themselves. I'm making a video game in RPG Maker with a trans/detrans self-insert character. My art has flourished since detransitioning.
Current status: I am a detransitioned, gender nonconforming man. I still experience gender dysphoria sometimes, and I still sometimes "feel female," but I don't pay attention to it. I feel more at peace than I have in the past, though I still feel confused about who I am sometimes and wonder if I should just go full trad. I think about suicide on a regular basis but say being trans was so much worse, and I'm thankful I didn't transition as a kid. I am not anti-suicide but think it must be "completely logical."