Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I came to this community as a desisted man — someone who had lived through identifying as trans and has since gone back to living as the man I was born. I don't share many specifics about my own timeline publicly, partly because of the embarrassment and shame I still feel about the whole episode; as I put it, we detransitioners 'barely tell anyone.' What I do talk about is what I've learned, and what I think we owe the people who stood by us.
Looking back, I think the core mistake I made was obsessing over the visual and emotional trappings of gender. I was so focused on what makes a man *look* like a man and *feel* like a man that I lost sight of the fact that being a man is not a feeling. Feelings are fleeting and unreliable. I now believe that most of us who ended up here felt some type of way and, instead of doing the hard, unglamorous work of improving ourselves on the things we could actually control — our bodies, our responsibilities, our skills — we looked for a shortcut or ran in the opposite direction. My advice to others in that headspace is blunt: lift weights, take on more responsibility at work, learn a trade, find older men to talk to, maybe religion if it suits you, and above all learn to control your emotions. Once you can do that, the rest falls into place.
I also have to own the harm I caused along the way. I ask other detransitioners to think about how many times they called friends and family the 'wrong pronouns' or made a scene over being deadnamed, and how much gaslighting it took to get people who loved us to disbelieve their own eyes or what the doctor said when we were born. I know I caused trouble for others and assumed they were against me when, in reality, most of them were just trying to help me see reason. Many people went along with my transition not because they believed it, but because they were afraid I would hurt or kill myself if they didn't, or because they wanted to keep their job or social standing. Some of my true friends actually tried to stop me or refused to play along, and I treated them dismissively, waving away dissenting perspectives as 'transphobia or bigotry.' Then I ran to the circles that validated me — other confused people, or people chasing a fetish — instead of the people telling me the truth.
That's why I now push back hard on the 'if anyone has a problem with what I'm doing, fuck off' attitude. That attitude is part of why so many of us are here in the first place. I think we need to give the people who stuck around through what I called our 'madness' grace and patience; they aren't going to be angry that we changed back — they're probably relieved not to have to pretend anymore. The anger we do get will mostly come from the people we gave a hard time to, or from people who can no longer get what they wanted from us sexually. Either way, we need to take responsibility for our actions and be as kind to them as we want them to be to us.
I'm also convinced this isn't just about us. I watch this subreddit grow every day — one of the fastest-growing communities out there — and I see how many people bought into these lies and are now in pain, mentally and physically, from surgery or drugs. The lie we were fed is too powerful not to talk about, uncomfortable and embarrassing as it is. If someone asks, I want to tell them what was going on in my head and how I came out of it, so they have the tools to push back when they encounter it in others. We were vulnerable to this ourselves; the TikTok generation, which gets celebrated and gains social currency the more identities they pile on, doesn't stand a chance. The only buffer we had was that this was new to us and we used to get bullied for it — which in hindsight probably made the delusions worse and gave us a persecution complex. We told ourselves we were martyrs, renegades, black sheep raging against the machine, when really we were raging against the truth and have all paid a toll for our ignorance and arrogance.
I'm not telling anyone what to do — we all know how futile that would be — but I do ask people to consider these things. Comforting lies have done nothing for us in the long run and only made us worse off. The real empowerment comes from accepting yourself as the man you were always meant to be and from the accomplishments and goals you set for yourself, not from seeking validation from others, which led us down this path in the first place. Now I try to follow my own judgment.
I have little patience for people who make their trans identity their whole presence online, and I'm struck by the irony that we detransitioners get accused of making detransition our whole personality when we barely tell anyone because of the shame, while they broadcast theirs across every platform. Their bios are filled with identities, political affiliations, flags, and astrology signs; their whole personality is built around defending and promoting it. They're terminally online because that's where their validation comes from. Most people who detransition, by contrast, actually form a real personality — we face reality, find ourselves in different circles, make new friends, have new experiences, and move through the world the way we always should have. The people who get mad at us are the ones whose delusions we're pushing against. I've seen detransitioners in their comment sections trying to prevent them from suffering a worse fate, but I know it's mostly moot: nobody could tell us anything either, and we fought tooth and nail against the wisdom of our family and friends. This is a conclusion they'll have to reach themselves, and one day they'll realize the people pushing back were the ones who actually cared.