Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono un uomo gay che ha fatto detransizione, ho fatto coming out ai tempi dell'era GLB e ora credo che il genere stesso sia una finzione. Ho fatto la transizione soprattutto per il disagio e il trauma legati ai ruoli di genere maschili e all'invisibilità della sofferenza degli uomini, e ora leggo gran parte di ciò che si chiama disforia come disagio sociale o, in alcuni casi, un feticcio sessuale che si è indurito in identità. Rimpiango il tempo perso e l'isolamento, e ho scritto apertamente di sentirmi non benvenuto persino su r/detrans, dove credo che lo sfogo degli uomini che hanno fatto detransizione venga accolto con noncuranza mentre quello delle donne trova sostegno. Sono critico verso la transizione per gli altri, sostenendo una diagnosi rigorosa prima del trattamento medico, e non descrivo esigenze mediche in corso. Non descrivo ideazione suicidaria, autolesionismo né tentativi di suicidio.
Storia completa
I have never posted a thread of my own here — 64 comments over roughly two years is my whole footprint, and honestly most of it is me arguing with people. I'm a detransitioned man (MtFtM), and I came out back when the community was still called GLB; the word 'queer' then meant the person saying it was about to punch you or was scared of catching AIDS, so I've never felt any kinship with the modern acronym soup. I'm gay — I've only ever been male-attracted, and I say that in a couple of exchanges about how rare it was to meet other homosexual men in trans spaces.
I transitioned because of distress and trauma around gender roles and expectations — that's how I've always framed it, and I've written that 'many males here transitioned due to distress and trauma of gender roles and expectations.' I don't give dates for hormones or surgery anywhere in this transcript, so I'll leave those blank, but the emotional arc is clear: I spent a lifetime feeling that men's issues are invisible, that nobody acknowledges male suffering the way feminism organised around women's, and that this invisibility 'can play a large role in wanting to choose to be a woman.' Transition, for me, was partly a bid for recognition.
What I regret most is the time and the position it left me in — non-passing, caught between sexes, and told in the very space set up for people like me that I should basically be quiet about it. In June 2023 I wrote a long, raw stretch of comments about how r/detrans had become, in practice, a space for detransitioned women, where a woman venting gets an outpouring of support while a man venting gets 'you're fine, your life is actually advantageous because of your sex,' '#whataboutwomen,' 'don't let it upset you,' and finally 'it's healthier for you if you leave.' I admitted my heart was in my throat just posting it, that I'd spent 'so so long of being too afraid,' and that I'd log off and try to take my mind off it. That thread is the closest I've come to saying how isolated I've felt.
On causes, I'm fairly blunt and clinical. I think a lot of what gets called gender dysphoria is either discomfort with one's place in society or, in some cases, a sexual fetish that got fed until it hardened into an identity. I've argued that dysphoria is 'nothing more than a manifestation of discomfort of one's place within society rather than an innate condition,' and I've written at length about AGP — that it starts as arousal, gets normalised, and 'begins to form as an identity,' which is why I tell people asking me about crossdressing that they're describing a paraphilia, not dysphoria, and should go to an AGP support sub instead. I've also said that asexuality and other non-sexual factors can be valid causes for wanting to transition, so I don't think it's one single mechanism.
I don't believe in gender at all. I've said plainly that non-binary is 'a cope bandaided over deeper underlying issues,' and that GNC is not an identity but a description of how someone looks or behaves — 'a GNC woman is a woman and a GNC man is a man.' My advice to a woman asking what it makes her if she'd 'rather be a woman who looks like a man but enjoys feminine things' was simply: 'It makes you a woman... I think this path is the way to a sense of peace with yourself.' I define sex by the reproductive system the body was developing toward, argue it isn't a spectrum because every intersex condition comes with high infertility — 'an utter evolutionary dead end' — and I've pushed back hard on the claim that trans people are being murdered at epidemic rates, doing the CDC arithmetic myself to show the rate is about three times lower than the general population. That got me permanently banned from r/confidentlyincorrect, which I found darkly funny: correcting misinformation with data is only welcome when the data confirms the politics.
I've also been banned elsewhere for linking an on-camera interview in which Marsha P. Johnson said 'I'm a boy, I'm just a TV' — I'd used it to mock someone calling that claim bigoted, and the ban proved my point about who's allowed to say what. I've argued that detransitioners deserve a refuge, that men should be able to speak about male-specific suffering without prefacing it with 'women have it worse, but...', and I've defended a university friend whose parents forced him into an arranged marriage and sent him back to China at 20 — 'the look of someone who has had everything taken away from them.' I told a woman in that male-flaired thread that she was doing exactly what men do in women's threads, and I apologised for coming across as antagonistic while standing my ground.
Mental health-wise, the transcript doesn't give me diagnoses, but the emotional texture is there: chronic fear of speaking, isolation, a sense of powerlessness, and a habit of logging off to cope. I don't describe self-harm or suicidal thoughts. I don't describe therapy. I don't describe hormones stopping or surgeries reversing — I have no medical timeline to give. What I have is a slow, public argument with a community I expected to hold me, and a fairly settled conclusion: I'm a detransitioned gay man who thinks gender is a fiction, that transition was a response to unacknowledged male pain, and that the only workable path is for individual organisations to sort out spaces case by case because 'there is no workable solution within the current culture.'
On transition for others, I'm critical rather than absolutist — I don't campaign to abolish it, but I think proper diagnosis should precede medical treatment (a knee surgery analogy: 'if an x-ray confirmed a healthy knee it would be denied to me'), that bodily freedom doesn't include the right to demand someone else perform the procedure, and that the current informed-consent culture lets fetish and social discomfort masquerade as clinical dysphoria. I've never done formal advocacy or activism; my 'activism' is arguing in comments and getting banned for it.