Tutte le storie

Cinque anni di consigli schietti da dietro un muro di privacy

Femmina · Detransizionato/a103
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna detransizionata che scrive negli spazi detrans almeno dal 2019, offrendo consigli critici e dal tono schietto a chi si interroga sul genere e ai genitori di bambini che si interrogano sul genere. Sostengo che nessun intervento, ormone, abito o pronome cambi il sesso biologico, e avverto in modo dettagliato dei rischi di bloccanti della pubertà, ormoni e interventi. Cerco di sostenere chi sta male incoraggiandolo a ricostruire la propria vita attorno a cose diverse dal genere. Non condivido pubblicamente la mia cronologia medica, le mie diagnosi né dettagli familiari.

Storia completa

I was born female. I don't have a detailed public timeline of my own transition or detransition in these posts, but I have been active in detrans and critical-of-transition spaces since at least early 2019, and by that point I had already gone through a process of questioning and stepping back from identifying as trans. In January 2020 someone replied to me with 'But you were a real one none the less :)' after I asked rhetorically 'Is someone who falls off their bike really a cyclist?', which suggests I had identified as trans and then stopped. I have spent a lot of time advising parents of gender-questioning children. In August 2019 I laid out a list of questions a parent could ask a son who wants to be a girl, including 'What's wrong with your body?', 'Why would being a girl be better than being a boy to you?', and 'What can girls do that you feel that you can't?'. I told the parent to explain that 'There is no such thing as being born in the wrong body' and that a child can wear what they want and express themselves without becoming someone else. I also warned about surgery and puberty blockers, describing blockers as 'off label, experimental drugs with unknown long-term side effects' that can cause sterility, halted sexual function, and endocrine disruption, and describing bottom surgery in blunt anatomical terms. I have strong, critical views about medical transition. In October 2019 I wrote that 'There is no surgery, medication or styling that will ever make you something that you're not. If you can accept that and play permanent dress-up, then good luck.' In April 2020 I wrote a longer passage about cutting and attaching body parts, injecting drugs to maintain an appearance 'your body isn't built for', and crushing breasts, ending with 'In the end you'll still be female.' I have also raised concerns about specific medications, telling someone to 'look into the women and girls who have been harmed taking Lupron' and listing risks of bottom surgery, hysterectomy, double mastectomy, and off-label medications. I try to be supportive of people in distress while steering them away from transition. In September 2019 I used a metaphor of glasses filled with water, stones or glitter, telling someone to mourn what was lost but rebuild: 'You can build something beautiful from that blank slate.' In March 2020 I wrote 'Clothes are cloth, hair is keratin, pronouns are communal, none of it is you' and encouraged someone to get out of their head and into life through biking, hiking, pets, volunteering and community. I also told people to weigh the real-world costs before transitioning, listing 'Dating, STDs/STIs, accidents, bills, lay offs, weddings, divorces, kids, adoption...' and urging them to 'REALLY weigh the costs, there are always unforeseen costs.' I have also pushed back against adoption being framed as an easy alternative for trans people, calling that 'a rude and biased opinion of adoption' and noting it is expensive and heavily scrutinized. On sexuality I have encouraged people not to over-pathologize it, suggesting they stop 'chastising yourself for being attracted or unattracted.' In one exchange I pointed out that a person with a loving partner, good sex, community belonging and pregnancy plans might not have a problem to solve, and that transitioning would turn a 'GNC lesbian' into a 'gender conforming heterosexual.' I don't publicly discuss specific surgeries, medications, dates, mental health diagnoses, or family circumstances of my own. I don't discuss my current relationship status, sexuality, or career. My overall stance is critical of medical transition, especially for minors, while still acknowledging that an adult who has weighed the costs may choose it.