Tutte le storie

Il disagio di sua sorella verso il proprio corpo è diventato uno specchio

Femmina · Desistito/a90
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha desistito/detransizionato: ho avuto disforia di genere da adolescente e ho preso in considerazione la transizione, ma non l'ho portata avanti, in parte perché mia sorella mi ha aiutata a vedere i parallelismi con il suo disagio nel suo corpo femminile. Nel 2019 avevo 33 anni e avevo ancora disforia, cosa che ho notato non passa necessariamente con l'età. Non ho descritto né ormoni né interventi. Ora avverto con spirito critico gli altri sulle conseguenze mediche della transizione e consiglio ai genitori di adolescenti con disforia di prendere sul serio il dolore dei figli senza spingerli verso la transizione. Non ho descritto pensieri suicidi né autolesionismo.

Storia completa

I experienced gender dysphoria as a teenager, before the explosion of the internet and trans culture. I also went through a period of considering transitioning myself — my sister at one point talked me through the ways she had never felt right in her own female body (hers manifesting differently from mine; she wanted to be more feminine), and over time I mulled that over and saw the parallels, which helped me step back from the idea of transitioning. As of August 2019 I was 33 years old and still dealing with gender dysphoria, which I noted does not necessarily go away with age. I have not had any hormones or surgeries that I've described, and I don't describe a formal detransition — rather, I seem to be someone who considered transition and did not go through with it, and who now thinks critically about the decision. In my comments I try to warn others about transition's medical realities: I tell people that even if someone is '100% true trans,' that will not let them escape the negative medical consequences of hormonal and/or surgical transition, and that this is important to realize. I also believe that all female people carry some internalized misogyny because it is unavoidable in media and society, regardless of how they were raised, and that this could contribute to feeling more 'at home' in a male body. Much of my posting has been in response to a mother of a 15-year-old daughter with gender dysphoria. I pushed back hard on the mother's framing. I told her she was alienating her daughter, that she should stop calling her daughter's social scene 'stupid,' and take the dysphoria seriously 'fad or not,' warning that she was setting up a false dichotomy between 'the welcoming and super-understanding trans community' and 'my angry and super-critical mom' — and that the daughter would choose the former. I also cautioned the mother against telling her daughter that her dysphoria was 'normal,' comparing it to calling depression 'normal' and arguing that diminishing the girl's pain would cost the mother her trust. I acknowledged that dysphoria may be more common than people realize but insisted it is not normal in the statistical sense, and that even if it were, it wouldn't matter — something needs to be done for the daughter rather than just waiting for her to grow out of it by her mid-20s, which I called too much to ask of a teenager. I also suggested the mother give the trans question less attention, get her daughter involved in other passions (guitar, writing, sports, lifting weights), respect her autonomous identity development, drop the idea that she 'knows her better than she knows herself,' keep the trans question open rather than pushing her own view, and remain a trustworthy, non-judgmental person so the daughter would feel safe voicing doubts — even after starting testosterone — rather than doubling down out of fear of judgment and 'I told you so's.' On dating, I've commented that it gets harder over 30, that women are more confident and selective than in their 20s, and that people dating men who present as cis are likely encountering more 'traditional'/straighter women than in the queer world. I have not described any specific mental health diagnoses, trauma, or adversity beyond the gender dysphoria itself. I have not described advocacy work beyond participating in these online discussions.