Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Storia completa
I am a lesbian and a woman of color, and I have been posting in this community since at least September 2019. I have never transitioned and have no personal detransition story of my own; what brings me here is my conviction about who I am and my anger at what I see as the erasure of homosexuality.
I first started commenting in September 2019, mostly giving skincare advice. I recommended a maximum-strength over-the-counter retinol — something like SkinCeuticals maximum strength refining night cream 1.0 — for extreme acne and the scarring it leaves behind, warning that the first month brings severe dryness and peeling and that people should not increase the amount even when they see results quickly. I mentioned that one of "my subjects" developed cystic acne very similar to testosterone-induced acne, and that the peeling was not mild but the results were outstanding. In that same month I also commented on someone who had "permanently destroyed their reproductive organs," responding with "Every cloud has a silver lining?"
My real engagement began in January 2020, when I responded to a trans person who had not disclosed their biological sex to a lesbian partner. I told them they were not a fool but that failing to disclose is sexual assault: "If you are having sex with people and not disclosing you're a rapist! Period!" I identified myself plainly: "I'm a lesbian and I have to tell you, a trans woman doing this to me is my biggest nightmare! I've literally had this nightmare." I said the deception would mess the lesbian up in ways she couldn't fully grasp and that she might need therapy. In the same thread I stated that neovaginas are not real vaginas, that they do not self-regulate or clean, and that they are "just an artificial hole in the body which is why it's always trying to close up on itself." I relayed what bisexual friends of mine had reported about the smell and taste of neovaginas.
In April 2020 I entered a long, heated exchange with a person who identified as a "transbian." I told them directly: "Ok first understand that you're not a lesbian. You will never be a lesbian, and no lesbians will ever be with you." I said the closest they could come is "transbian," and that the dating pool for that is very small. I argued that a fauxgina is not a vagina — it does not act, smell, or taste like one — and, more importantly, that "Women are a sum of our experiences we are a heart and mind not just sex. You don't have a woman's heart or mind. You and I have no common experiences." I told them their comments about getting "my gay on" looked like a fetish for being seen as homosexual, and that "It's ok to be straight. There's nothing wrong with it, but a lesbian you'll never be."
I pushed back hard on the idea that attraction could be redefined. "No lesbians are fine with penises! NONE! If they are then they are not lesbians. They are lying fakebians." I rejected the thought-experiment about a cyborg future where genitals are interchangeable: "This is not the future and even then there will be homosexuals!" I told them they had no frame of reference for what a female core is, and that everything they had written came from a male perspective with a fetish for lesbians. When they said they were a gay woman "prenatally overexposed to testosterone," I answered, "You're not our sex and no matter what you do you will never be our sex." I also said I was not personally attracted to transmen because they look like men and I find men physically repulsive, while acknowledging I couldn't speak for lesbians who date them.
I objected strongly when the person sexualized me in debate: "You completely sexualized me! Notice I did nothing of the kind to you... This is something only men do to women." I wrote, "You do not have a female core," and called their behavior male entitlement. In blunt exchanges I called them "a mentally ill fetishist" and said transwomen are "born mentally ill men" — "They are MEN! PERIOD!!" I rejected the claim that transwomen are "defective women" as an insult to every woman who has suffered. I also rejected brain-based definitions of woman: "That's stupid... So would this be before hormones or after and how does this jive with your if I say I am then I am ideas?"
I described my own position on disclosure and "stealth" in stark terms: "Stealth is rape!" I warned that a transwoman who went stealth would be "branded a rapist and a fetishist" and become "a pariah within the community," and that lesbians warn each other about "the latest transbian rapist." I said that if a lesbian is with a man, "she is not a homosexual therefore she is not a lesbian," and that "If a woman has ever enjoyed or been happy with men she is not a lesbian. That's the biological wiring! PERIOD NO EXCEPTIONS!" I argued lesbians have historically been beaten, arrested, raped and murdered for how they love, and never for being with cross-dressing men, using the Middle East as an example: "If I go to the Middle East with my girl, and he goes with his. We may both be arrested on suspicion, but only I will be thrown off a building once he pulls his pants down."
I also relayed a story from a bisexual man I know who dated post-op transwomen and found that neovaginas felt "more like an anus" because there are no muscles, with a nauseating smell. I said of Gigi Gorgeous, "Gigi is a man, and his wife is bisexual. PERIOD!"
On why I engage at all, I wrote: "Why is this my problem? I suffer as a woman, a person of color, and a lesbian. I don't expect anyone else to take this on for me. Their problems are their own, and I have no obligations to validate them." I framed my activism as defending a definition: "LESBIANS ARE SAME SEX ATTRACTED!! WE EXIST!" and "STOP ERASING WHAT HOMOSEXUAL MEANS!! I FUCKING EXIST!!" In my most recent comment, in April 2020, I argued that homosexuals should not be erased for what I called trans people's "mental issues," and that trans people need to invent a new word for themselves rather than redefine us: "We homosexuals have been around for centuries we exist in nature even."
I have not described any personal experience of dysphoria, transition, hormones, surgery, therapy, or detransition. My participation is that of an advocate defending lesbian identity and same-sex attraction, and I have not reported any change in that position over the course of these posts.