Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto detransizione, ho preso testosterone per poco più di due anni dopo la transizione, come scudo contro una grave ansia sociale infantile e una brutta esperienza con un uomo da giovanissima. Ho fatto detransizione prima con famiglia e amici, poi pubblicamente, dopo aver capito che volevo essere trattata come una donna dal mio ragazzo più di quanto volessi essere trattata come un uomo. Gli ormoni hanno riportato le curve, capelli più folti, un viso più femminile e una voce che passa per femminile grazie all'allenamento vocale, ma mi restano cicatrici della mastectomia che odio e tre chirurghi che rifiutano la ricostruzione perché sono detrans. Con la TOS ho anche sviluppato fluttuazioni inspiegabili della tiroide e calcoli renali, che credo siano stati causati dagli ormoni. Ora sono critica verso la transizione per gli altri e sfido senza giri di parole chi dice di voler essere donna per i motivi sbagliati.
Storia completa
I struggled with extreme social anxiety from a very difficult childhood — it got so bad that I hated when anybody would look at me at all, and I was always so uncomfortable in my own skin. When I was roughly fourteen, I was exposed to the transgender community through social media, and I thought I had found a solution: I felt more comfortable when I presented myself as male because it took away some of the edge of my social anxiety. Looking back, I used being "male" almost like a shield — a way of stepping outside of my own identity, which I was so insanely uncomfortable with, and into one where I had more protection.
I also had a bad experience with a man at a very young age which took a heavy toll on how I wanted to be perceived in society as I grew up. Instead of confronting that fear and learning to accept and love myself, I shrank into it and found a shield that worked for me.
I was on testosterone for a little over two years. I did IM injections and then switched to 4mg patches so my levels were tapering off before I stopped completely. I was 100% male passing before detransition. I had top surgery at some point during my transition.
Signs I now recognize that I was not truly transgender: I hated talking about my gender identity — if people asked deep, introspective questions, I knew the answer I was supposed to say, but I didn't know what answer I actually felt with my heart. I was uncomfortable being perceived as a girl, yet even in my darkest, most misguided days I still clung to my femininity in small ways — cute stuffed animals, cute clothes, sometimes makeup. Deep down I had a longing to be connected to those feminine things. And I never wanted my boyfriend to call me "he" — I wanted him to treat me like a princess. One day he told me, "if you want to transition that's fine but you can't transition and still expect me to treat you like a girl whenever you want." That struck home. I realized I wanted him to treat me like a woman more than I wanted him to treat me like a man. Once I accepted that, it became much easier to accept other feminine parts of myself, and very slowly I gained confidence until I decided I 100% did not want to continue transitioning.
A question that stuck with me was: how do you want to die? When you're being lowered into your grave, do you want your loved ones gathered around the body of an old man, or an old woman? When I pictured it, I just couldn't see myself as an old man — it didn't fit. I saw me as an old lady.
I detransitioned to the people close to me first: my family, then my friends. Then, when I realized I genuinely did not like being referred to as male, I made the decision to openly start correcting people everywhere. I had been presenting fully feminine and it just didn't feel right to be referred to as male anymore.
The first thing I noticed after stopping hormones was fat redistribution — I looked in the mirror one day and realized I was getting very curvy and my butt was getting way bigger. I was naturally very curvy before HRT and my hips were the most noticeable thing for me; I remember looking at myself naked and thinking "wtf? Is that really me?" My hair got much thicker and grew probably four inches in the year I had been off HRT. My face became more feminine within the first three months, and later slimmed out further. My period came back very quickly, about a month after stopping, but I started birth control to stop them because I have an autoimmune disease that makes my periods really painful and long-lasting. Within the first four months off HRT I lost a lot of weight due to a shift in eating habits — I wasn't as hungry — and as I lost weight I saw a lot more curves.
My voice had deepened substantially on testosterone. I started trying to speak in a higher register; it took a lot of time and frustration and there were times I cried and cried over my voice, but with practice I was able to train my vocal cords to talk in a higher pitch that passes regularly as female. I think it sounds more androgynous, but I never get misgendered. My acne flared up badly after stopping but has since evened out — today my skin looks really great, way better than it ever did on HRT. I got laser hair removal on a lot of my body and on my face, and I use electric razors for my arms and face. I didn't wear makeup for a while after detransition, then when I started I became obsessed with it; it's died down but I've gotten pretty good at it and do a basic look most days. About six months off HRT I saw an endocrinologist and my hormone levels were normal for a female my age.
Even post-top surgery, fat has come back to my chest — I can wear an A-cup push-up bra and look completely natural. But I still hate the scars and the appearance under clothes, so I want revision/reconstruction surgery. I've met with surgeons about options including DIEPFLAP (an incision along the waistband, essentially a tummy tuck, with the abdominal fat placed in the chest), which is very invasive with a lengthy hospital stay, and implants (saline or with a tissue expander). I live in the DC area so I have access to DC surgeons and Johns Hopkins, but Johns Hopkins has a very high consultation fee. The problem I've run into: all 3 surgeons I met with told me they specifically will not operate because I am detrans — they consider it a gender reassignment surgery in their eyes. It's very sad, but I can't force a doctor to perform surgery and I wouldn't be comfortable with a surgeon performing if they weren't comfortable either. I've been looking into surgeons with experience in both reconstruction and transgender patients, hoping they'll be more willing, and I've seen some detrans women successfully get reconstruction.
Health-wise, I had no problems before HRT. Thyroid problems run in my family, but after HRT I discovered fluctuating levels from hypo- to hyperthyroidism and went through radioactive iodine scanning because my doctors have no idea why my thyroid is hyperactive. One year on HRT I also struggled with recurring kidney stones, which the doctors couldn't explain — nothing had changed about my diet, lifestyle, medications, or health history besides the hormone medication. I truly believe HRT has long-lasting health effects that could be more dangerous in people who are predisposed. I also have an autoimmune disease that causes hair loss and difficult periods.
I have found community and resources helpful — I recommend YouTubers like Elle Palmer who break down their detransition timelines, and blogs by ftmtf women, often promoted through Twitter.
I care about other people questioning transition. Recently I responded bluntly to someone claiming the world is evolved around making girls' and women's lives better, telling them they don't want to be a woman — they have no idea what that entails — and that wanting an easier life or more support doesn't make you a woman. I recommended books like I Am Malala, The Bell Jar, and The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks, plus TED talks, and urged them to look internally at why they're having those wants. I believe your way of thinking is harmful to you and others, and detrimental to your future happiness — you can achieve the goals you want without being a woman, you just have to put in the work.