Tutte le storie

Il server creato per chi ha fatto detransizione, e il ban che l'ha chiuso

Femmina · Desistito/a43
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una femminista radicale e amministratrice di un server Discord gender-critical, non una persona che ha fatto detransizione; seguivo r/detrans e ho offerto ai suoi membri un server moderato con leggerezza con un canale sulla detransizione. Sono stata bannata dal subreddit dopo che il mio thread d'invito era stato invaso da utenti che vedevo come incel che sviavano la conversazione. Gran parte della mia attività consisteva nel difendere la teoria femminista radicale da quella che vedevo come una reazione misogina, comprese le argomentazioni secondo cui la misandria non equivale alla misoginia. Nell'agosto 2019 ho bannato un membro maschio del server dopo che, a donne che dicevano che avrebbero votato per una presidente donna, aveva risposto dicendo loro di praticargli sesso orale, ed è tornato con un secondo account. Resto gender-critical e solidale con chi ha fatto detransizione come comunità, identificandomi però come femmina e non come detrans.

Storia completa

I never identified as detransitioned or desisted — I want to be clear about that up front: I am a woman who follows the r/detrans community but is not detrans myself. My involvement with that subreddit came entirely through my role as the creator and administrator of a Radical Feminist/gender-critical Discord server, which I opened in late June 2019. I created the server because I wanted a space for inter-generational Radical Feminist dialogue among gender-critical people, and I deliberately included a channel specifically for detransition topics and detransitioned folks. I advertised it publicly on r/detrans on June 30, 2019, describing it as "open to anyone GC" with "Age diversity encouraged." My intention was good-faith: I wanted to offer a lightly moderated alternative to what I saw as over-moderated Reddit spaces, where detransitioners and gender-critical feminists could talk without "the usual zealous over moderation." What followed was a sustained conflict. Within a day of posting my invitation, I was trolled in the thread by users I characterized as "obvious incels" — people who called feminists "obnoxious and loud," and one who, I felt, tried to blame radical feminists for transgenderism. The subreddit's moderators banned me, which I took as a betrayal: "These mods burnt a bridge." I was frustrated because I felt I had extended a gracious invitation and had it thrown back in my face with what I saw as misogynistic hostility. The bulk of my comments in this transcript are arguments defending radical feminist theory against users on the subreddit. I made clear, repeatedly, that I was not detrans: "I follow this sub, I'm not detrans, and made space where they can discuss their issues if they want to." I pushed back hard against anyone who used the word "misandry" unironically, arguing that "There is absolutely no valid equivocation of misandry and misogyny," and that men as a class "perpetuate and support a system of oppression that subjugates females and elevates themselves." I rejected the framing of radical feminism as a "lifestyle," comparing it dismissively to "your average male who thinks he's superior to women but no one challenges their blatant misogyny regularly." I was confident in the theory and somewhat amused by the resistance I encountered: "My post invitation became somewhat entertaining lol." I also clashed with a user who I felt was trying to derail the thread by implying he would hide or report my post. I read his comment — "I haven't done anything to hide your post... Other users who see it and are interested will still join" — as "very clearly an implied threat," and told him he seemed unaccustomed to men being criticized openly. By August 2019, the conflict had moved into my Discord server itself. A male member of the server reacted to women saying they would vote for a female president by throwing what I called a "mantrum" and telling the women to "suck his dick," and accusing us of "vagina voting." I banned him, told him I had screenshots, and called him a "rapey pos" and a "homophobe." He returned using another account, and I accused him of being a racist as well, citing his use of the n-word: "When you are a rapist it makes you a rapist. Sorry. Racist rapist." Overall, my engagement was political and ideological rather than personal. I was not working through a detransition of my own; I was an ally and organizer trying to build a Radical Feminist space that included detransitioners among its constituency, and I ended up in a series of heated disputes both on Reddit and in my own server with people I perceived as misogynistic, chauvinistic, or acting in bad faith.