Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna bisessuale che ha fatto detransizione e che ha vissuto per 12 anni come ragazzo trans senza mai prendere testosterone, e ora vivo come donna non conforme al genere senza etichette. Il mio percorso verso la transizione è stato plasmato dal disagio di genere nell’infanzia, dal grooming di una donna trans più grande a 17 anni e dagli abusi da parte di partner donne trans, insieme a una comunità trans che trovavo superficiale e poco solidale. Ho lasciato la comunità trans perché l’enfasi su aspetto, pronomi e slogan faceva scattare la mia disforia e mi sembrava staccata dalla realtà fisica. Sono grata di non aver mai preso ormoni né fatto interventi, anche se ho problemi di salute persistenti, tra cui mal di schiena e problemi respiratori. Ora sostengo spazi solo LGB e sono critica verso la transizione pediatrica, i bloccanti della pubertà e l’attivismo trans mainstream.
Storia completa
I was born female. I had a childhood phase where I hated skirts, hated girls, and wanted to be a boy because boys seemed 'cooler' and 'better,' but it never got to the point of 'I am a boy.' I got more comfortable with my sex as I got older, until I learned about the whole trans thing and had to seriously consider transition as a real option — for me, having the option actually made my dysphoria worse. I came out to my ex-boyfriend's mom many years ago, telling her 'I'm more like a boy on the inside,' and she replied by gesturing to her body and saying 'I'm a woman because I'm female. It doesn't mean anything else.' I had no comeback at the time, and I now look back on those words as a pearl of wisdom.
I lived as a trans guy for 12 years. I passed decently well even without testosterone, and I'm now really thankful I never took T, because I'm living as a woman and that probably would have been impossible if my voice had dropped or I'd grown a full beard. My health is already precarious, so I'm sure I'd have had atrophy, acne, and panic attacks on T, plus the difficulty of navigating dating. I also tried binding when I was trans but found it way too painful — I have back pain and respiratory problems to begin with, so I instantly knew how much it would hurt my body, which is why I now worry about young people being pushed to 'just try binding.'
I made a ton of friends in the trans community very quickly, but they were fake friends — they overwhelmingly only wanted to sleep with me or thought associating with me made them look cooler. When I broke up with my abusive ex, they were all gone in a flash, because even though he was abusive, he was a 'kinky poly transgirl' with more social capital than I had as someone moving in a 'vanilla monogamous desisting direction.'
I was also groomed by a 40-year-old transwoman when I was 17; she solicited underage nudes from me, and 'it all went downhill from there.' I was abused and raped by one transwoman ex, and then a second, and I observed how these transwoman rapists and pedophiles abuse others. Recently I found a site for people who experienced this kind of violence in the trans community, which was a big relief — evidence that I'm not crazy and not just unlucky, and that this is an epidemic. I planned to submit my story once I finished writing it out.
Since I stopped identifying as trans, I've become more and more uncomfortable with mainstream LGBT subreddits — it triggers my dysphoria to see everything focusing on pronouns and timelines 24/7. I've found it extremely important to get outside the trans bubble. I feel a lot better since I left the labels behind and just started living as a female. I don't tell, I show. I'm still 'technically non-binary (although most people technically are)' but I only mention that in rare contexts online. I now live as a 'bisexual tomboy weirdo' — my hair is long, I never wear makeup or women's shoes, I wear women's jeans and men's t-shirts, I shave my legs and armpits sometimes, and I like crochet, gardening, and being handy with computers. I'm not as sensitive to society's perceptions anymore; I find it fun to blow people's minds by defying their assumptions.
The pronouns question makes me extremely dysphoric — it suggests I even have the option of choosing pronouns. Everyone calls me 'she' because I put some effort into passing as female to save people awkwardness, but I'd rather be called anything than be asked to interrogate my feelings. I've spent 12 years living as a trans guy trying to control what people thought about me, and I'm done with it.
I'm critical of mainstream trans activism: I think the trans community has appropriated narratives of others (hate crime rates of black and latino gender non-conforming gay men, intersex people's lives, the concept of misogyny), and that travestis in Brazil are gender non-conforming males who don't identify as trans but whose murder rates are used as a cudgel. I think gender identity discourse has become indecipherable nonsense detached from physical reality. I support gay people and everyone's right to marry, vote, have health care, education, job security and a livable wage, but I don't see how that relates to giving drugs to kids or biological males playing women's sports. As a detrans bisexual woman, I hate that we're not allowed to discuss the nuance of trans issues without having accounts deleted. I've advocated for LGB-only spaces, promoting r/LesBiGay as a subreddit free of trans posts so it can't be banned for transphobia. I believe severe childhood dysphoria can fade or be coped with in other ways, and that there's no test that says 'you are a Real Trans.'