Tutte le storie

Un nulla osta, una carriera e un anno di estrogeni

Maschio · Detransizionato/aPrima disforia 12 → Transizione 19 → Detransizione 21893
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un uomo che ha fatto detransition (MtFtM) e che ha vissuto come donna con gli estrogeni per circa un anno in totale, in più periodi, e che ha fatto detransition quasi interamente per ragioni esterne — una carriera delicata nell'ingegneria della difesa/nucleare, requisiti di nulla osta, viaggi, sicurezza e paura della solitudine — non perché essere trans mi sembrasse sbagliato. Non rimpiango la transizione in sé ('il primo atto di amore per me stesso che mi sono concesso') e a volte desidero ancora di essere trans, ma ho imparato a stare bene da uomo e mi identifico come detrans, non come repper. Ho ancora il seno dovuto alla HRT, intendo fare la top surgery anche se la temo, e sono sul punto di rifare la transizione, con solo il lavoro a trattenermi. Ho notevoli problemi di salute mentale — sbalzi d'umore, problemi di rabbia, essere 'alla fine della corda', paura di una diagnosi di depressione — ma nessuna ideazione suicidaria o tentativo dichiarati dalla detransition. Mi batto molto contro la transfobia all'interno della comunità detrans e mi considero (o vengo considerato) un 'transfobico' per aver sostenuto dei paletti medici invece di opposizione alle persone trans.

Storia completa

I was born male. Since childhood I had daydreams about being a girl, and almost every fictional character I felt connected to were women. I had a male socialization but was always somewhat different — I was short, nerdy, early-developed, and isolated with few friends and a somewhat toxic home situation. My father was old-school and pushed me toward an outdated masculinity I never adhered to. I was bullied hard, forced to fight back, did lots of martial arts (mostly kickboxing, later also karate — around 15 years total), got into fights, almost lost my licence twice, had a finger snapped in half. Middle school sucked. From my earliest sexual fantasies I was a girl in them — about 80% of them — and I was introduced to porn very late, so fantasy was my way of getting going. I found myself extremely unattractive, was obsessed with hair loss from around 15 (I have a hairline that looks like MPB since I was about 8, though no one in my family is bald). I turned to toxic stoicism: cold showers, working out until I passed out and puked every single time, punishing myself for bad grades (usually 18/20), 200 pushups a day. Later I got invested in TG fantasy and in those contexts 'just knew' I was trans in a way — I was amazed that regular sad dudes could become confident and attractive after transition. But every time I went back to school or work my brain flipped back to boymode instantly. Desires to transition went on for at least 5 years. Late 2025, a work situation so intense and stressful made any discomfort impossible to ignore. I got into a very big city with access to trans associations, and my girlfriend was extremely accepting — even excited at the idea. I went to support groups, talked to a gender therapist, and everyone told me to just go for it. I knew something wasn't right at around 12, admitted to myself I was trans at 15, but between my first consult at 21 and getting my script it had been only about a month. I started HRT (estrogen) at around 19-21, hoping to boymode until I passed. I never experimented with social transition publicly because I was in a non-welcoming environment. I never wanted bottom surgery — I have no trace of bottom dysphoria and I'm concerned about functionality. My ideal was a feminine body doing male stuff; I've been told my gender goal is 'basically a non-passing trans man.' About 3 weeks into HRT my gender dysphoria 'totally disappeared' and I felt fine. I liked how I looked, had a bigger emotional range, felt emotions more broadly (I used to feel almost nothing except anger), liked having smooth skin, and enjoyed the diminished libido. Breast development started about 2 months in — the first permanent change — and I absolutely loved it in the prospect of transition. I was on E for about 2.5 months when I began seriously questioning. What tipped me into reconsideration was a practical career dilemma (choosing between Beijing and Atlanta) and realizing what being trans would actually mean beyond growing breasts. My reasons for detransition were almost entirely external: career (I'm a nuclear/defense engineer — being visibly trans would compromise my clearance and my ability to lead a team in a sensitive field), travel, safety, wanting to blend in anywhere, fear of loneliness and never being in a relationship again (my body reads female and very few women are into that, and I don't see myself dating men). I tried boymoding at work but was spotted by security and 'kindly asked to tone down' my presentation. About a third of my country votes far right and we'll have a far-right president next year. I detransitioned back to living as a man. I've been on and off HRT since: I stopped, then got back on E for about a year, then stopped again after 'losing everything.' Every time I try to get off HRT, GD comes back, and every time it fades after about a week back on it. I still have breasts (I bind, which 'sucks and hurts like hell') and I intend to get top surgery 'asap' though I dread it — I've said I'm 'almost crying thinking about getting top surgery.' I'm very feminine for a man and get 'm'am'd occasionally. I've been sterile even before transition. I've never had SRS. I'm a detrans man. I don't resent my transition — 'transitioning was possibly the first act of self love I gave myself.' I liked my body better that way at the time and just changed perspective. I identify as detrans, not a repper, and I've 'got to like being a guy.' I might retransition if I leave my job. My gender has fluctuated: 'being a regular man felt wrong, being a man felt wrong, being NB felt right, then being a woman felt right... now being a man feels right.' I think I have a form of gender fluidity. I couldn't get properly diagnosed for anything — not even autism — because I work in defense; a psychiatric diagnosis would revoke my clearance. I spent my entire childhood in therapist offices; doctors tried for years to diagnose me as autistic and didn't succeed. I've attempted therapy 7 times and given up: gender-specialized therapists gave me nothing, others had no clue. I can't afford or access therapy now. I have obvious mental health issues, huge mood swings (which stopped on E and likely come back off it), anger management issues, and I've described myself as being at 'the end of the rope.' I said 'I don't know if I'll survive this' and 'I'm at the end of the rope here tbh. Won't handle another radical reorganisation.' I've been in intense stress, essentially functioning in burnout 'thanks to drugs,' having lucid nightmares. I have a history of self-punishment (working out until passing out, punishment for bad grades) but stopped harming myself for punishment at some point. I fear a depression diagnosis ('stuff's a terminal illness'). I was bullied as a kid, had a toxic home, sisters who scared me, an old-school father. Family kicked me out at some point. I've had a pansexual girlfriend. I've been sexually assaulted — I'm 'one of them' among trans women assaulted — and I've said 'I've had to deal with that issue myself on a level that would make anyone lose faith in humanity.' I've received death threats from religious people and fascists as a militant. I was harassed IRL by a far-right student group and by my local detrans support group. I've attended trans support groups for about 5 years and am still active in my local LGBTQ+ org (about 70% cis lesbians). I have trans friends including a trans woman goddaughter's mother, a former partner who came out as trans, a childhood friend who's a trans man marrying in May. I have detrans friends too. I've been open about being detrans and never harassed for it IRL. I've been banned from almost every mainstream trans community for advocating medical guardrails. I've argued constantly on r/detrans against what I see as transphobia there, posting a thread titled 'I think this community should focus more on supporting detrans people instead of hating trans people' (score 0). I've said 'I'm considered objectively a transphobe... therefore I accept this.' I regret detransitioning under external pressure rather than by choice: 'What I regret isn't the act of detransition in itself... but it's to have done it under external pressure.' I don't regret the transition itself. I still sometimes think 'damn.. too bad I'm not trans that would've been great.' I'm 'on the edge with retransitioning and all that's keeping me is that job.' I'm straight, always been into women, and I'm currently able to date bisexual women. I'm a nuclear engineer; submarines and ITER interest me. I have a photonics degree and multiple degrees. I speak French (English is not my first language) and live in France.