Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono un uomo che ha fatto detransizione e che è arrivato a vedere la disforia di genere come una categoria inventata e il movimento più ampio per i diritti trans come un'ideologia simile a una setta. Intorno al 2019, a 23 anni, sono diventato attivo nelle comunità di detransizione, sostenendo che le procedure di transizione fossero appropriate solo per rare condizioni intersex e che la maggior parte delle persone che si presenta con disforia di genere abbia problemi di fondo come autismo, trauma o depressione, etichettati in modo sbagliato. Incoraggiavo gli altri a detransizionare, dicendo loro «non c'è/non c'era niente di sbagliato in te, a parte il fatto che pensavi ci fosse». La mia retorica si è fatta più dura nel corso del 2020, e ho definito il movimento una «setta sessuale della morte», esprimendo pessimismo su una reazione delle istituzioni. In questi post non ho dettagliato procedure mediche personali, ma mi sono identificato con forza con la comunità della detransizione e mi sono visto nella stessa situazione degli altri.
Storia completa
I was born male and I have been vocal in detransition communities about my belief that the entire framework of gender dysphoria is flawed. My views crystallized around 2019, when I was 23 years old, and I have consistently framed transition as an ideological and almost cult-like phenomenon rather than a legitimate medical need.
I first started publicly articulating these views in June 2019, arguing that children were being taught false information about what I called 'irredeemable adult choices' without parental consent, and thanking someone for 'admitting transitioning/transgenderism is an ideology to you.' I have consistently maintained that trans-related medical procedures were originally intended for 'a fringe group of people with an extremely rare birth defect,' not for children questioning their gender.
By July 2019, I was deeply engaged in trying to understand why people transition in the first place, framing my interest anthropologically. I cited a '1900% increase in transgenders in Europe in just the last five years' as evidence of something alarming. I was interviewing detransitioners, asking pointed questions about how they got drawn in: 'How did you end up watching such videos or following such channels? Was it in your feed? In the news? Who are really selling this fantasy?' I was trying to identify the mechanisms of what I saw as recruitment.
In July 2019 I also pushed back against the idea that increased visibility was simply about people feeling safer to come out, citing Christine Jorgensen's celebrity in the 1950s as evidence that trans people were not historically oppressed. I was skeptical of the narrative that more people were transitioning simply because society was more accepting.
My most substantive statement came in September 2019, when I told another detransitioner: 'Few here will admit it, but gender dysphoria is bullshit.' I argued that the original reason for trans procedures was an 'extremely rare birth defect where the genitalia did not match the chromosomes,' and that the DSM's definition of gender dysphoria was so broad 'everybody fits that bill.' I compared it to ADD/ADHD, claiming 'only the Western populace suffers these made-up afflictions' and that 'No one has ADHD or gender dysphoria in places where they can't afford it or where it wasn't heavily promoted to them.'
I explicitly told this person, who I understood to be 23 years old like me: 'There is/was nothing wrong with you apart from the fact that you thought there was and that you made life choices inspired by that presumption.' I encouraged them: 'It is not too late to revert those choices. At least you didn't mutilate your genitals. At least you're not part of the 40% of transgenders that commit suicide.' I compared leaving transition to leaving Scientology and said 'anyone who leaves a cult and/or re-invents themselves deserves respect.' I ended by saying 'You're only 23, with your whole life ahead of you. You could be the leading example to your online friends but honestly if I were you I wouldn't even poke those people with a stick.'
In October 2019 I refined my position using a medical analogy: I argued that 'gender dysphoria' is just a presenting complaint category, like 'patients with headaches,' and that the actual underlying causes vary widely — 'one needs psychiatry, another needs therapy, another has Asperger, another is autistic, another was abused at young age, another has daddy issues, another has a fetish.' I stated plainly: 'Gender dysphoria is the category the patient's complaint falls under. It is not the definition for the actual ailment(s).'
By mid-2020, my rhetoric had intensified. I described the trans rights movement as a 'sex cult of death' pandering to teenagers, called it 'cruel and counter productive,' and argued that the movement had 'gone from cult to culture.' I expressed pessimism about the possibility of political pushback, noting that 'There are also no leaders to point at, no scriptures to declare illegal and no headquarters to bomb.' I was dismissive of what I saw as weak opposition strategies, comparing them to launching a studio called 'Fuck Disney' to compete with Disney. I also said 'The reason you cannot blame doctors is because the neophytes will continue searching for alternative doctors, psychiatrists or therapists until they found the one that states what they want/need to hear to fulfill their initiation rite.'
In June 2020, I told another commenter 'Why is it so hard for you to get that I find myself in the exact same predicament,' indicating I saw myself as trapped in the same situation as others in the community.
Throughout this period I was highly active in critiquing the medical and cultural apparatus around transition, framing it as ideological capture of institutions. I did not describe specific personal medical interventions, surgeries, or hormone use in these comments, but I clearly identified with the detransition community and spoke about 'reverting choices' as a general possibility. My tone was combative and polemical, and I saw myself as someone willing to point out 'the elephant in the room.'