Tutte le storie

Tre anni da agender, poi i conti con la misandria sottostante

Maschio · Desistito/a208
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un uomo gay asessuale, nato maschio, che ha fatto detransition/desistenza, e mi sono identificato come agender/non binario per circa tre anni, facendo la transizione sociale con i pronomi they/them ma senza mai prendere ormoni né fare interventi. Ho fatto desistenza a gennaio 2022 dopo aver individuato come cause della mia disforia la misandria interiorizzata, l'omofobia, l'odio per i ruoli di genere, la vergogna per l'autismo e l'asessualità e la difficoltà a socializzare con gli uomini. All'inizio la desistenza mi ha fatto stare peggio, e faccio ancora fatica con la sensazione di «fingere di essere un uomo» e con il disagio per i pronomi he/him. Temo che fare la transizione porterebbe a un rimpianto, ed è per questo che sono rimasto indeciso sul piano medico. Attualmente sono un uomo gay in desistenza che lavora sull'accettare il proprio corpo maschile.

Storia completa

I was born male and I am gay — romantically attracted to men — and I'm also asexual, feeling no sexual attraction to anyone of any sex. I'm neurodivergent: I was diagnosed with ASD (autism spectrum disorder) as a child, had an IEP in elementary school, and was pulled out of it in 7th grade for reasons I never learned. I'm 6'4", I have very large feet (men's size 14), a defined angular jawline, a thin build, and a pectus excavatum — a chest cavity, possibly genetic — that leaves less room inside and makes some cardiovascular activities harder. I also have a naturally higher-pitched voice and have been mistaken for a woman on the phone multiple times, and rarely in person, which I found annoying at best and disturbing at worst. I started questioning my gender midway through high school but didn't tell anyone until my first year of college. I identified as agender for about three years internally and told people close to me about half a year before my first post here in December 2021. I've been gender-nonconforming my whole life: not into sports, vehicles or mechanical things, more interested in writing, academics and the arts than my male peers, and more sensitive and emotional. I usually excelled intellectually or academically but was never athletically oriented. I was picked on and teased by other males in high school, though never physically bullied, and I never felt safe in male spaces. My body caused me a great deal of discomfort — features ranging from slight dislike to intense loathing. I felt defective for not conforming to expectations, and eventually became disgusted with the fact that I was male at all. Sometimes I wished I never had a penis, and I found the immutability of my body frustrating, which made transition appealing. Intrusive thoughts told me I didn't deserve a penis because I wasn't a "real man," or that having a penis made me an oppressor given patriarchy and sexual-assault statistics — thoughts I knew were false but which kept intruding. I felt trapped: "My body will never stop being male, and until it does I will keep feeling trapped." I also felt I could never really be between male and female, nor a real woman, so I concluded "I may have a penis, but I'm not male." My transition ideals included taking feminizing hormones to make at least part of me less masculine, possibly an orchiectomy, androgynous or unisex fashion, and they/them pronouns. I never started estrogen and never had trouble passing as my birth sex. I socially transitioned to those around me — using they/them — but never completed a medical transition because of medical and financial barriers. I described myself as stuck in mid-transition. I didn't have a sense of being internally female, but I did have a sense of being somewhere outside the binary, and I wanted to be neither male nor female rather than to be a man who calls himself non-binary. I wanted to exist as just a person at the base level rather than as a man or a woman, without expectations attached. Several factors drove my dysphoria, which I identified through introspection: internalized misandry and internalized homophobia; a burning hatred of gender roles, stereotypes, and toxic masculinity; fear of shame and abuse for being even a little gender-nonconforming; the synthesis of my gender-nonconformity into the idea of gender itself; wanting to be an ally as non-binary identity became mainstream (not from interacting with other LGBT people); and general difficulty socializing with other males. Later I found more extraneous reasons: shame over my autism, shame over being gay and asexual, and hatred of and lack of interest in fitting gender roles. I also felt that being not male would make my lack of sexual interest acceptable to others — I'd been told I was broken and pressured into sex throughout much of my adolescence, starting in high school, with comments like "what is wrong with you?" and "what man/teen boy doesn't want to have sex?" My culture's male socialization values sexual attainment and stigmatizes men with no interest in it. I had my sex hormone levels tested and they were completely normal. I researched a lot, both for school and personally, reading literature and interacting with people with relevant experiences — which is how I found r/detrans and its Discord server, where I was more active than on the subreddit itself. My mother recommended professional help when I told her, but I didn't know which route to take; she also said she didn't know where my feelings were coming from and thought I was pretty unambiguously masculine. People close to me who knew about my body image issues didn't take them seriously because of my height and supposed attractiveness. On January 22, 2022, I posted that I was desisting (which I tagged "MtXtM"). I wrote that it would take a while to fully accept that I am male and to claim my proverbial space as a gay man, and that a part of me felt like I was accepting defeat. I described myself as a gender-nonconforming gay male whose dysphoria and mental condition had been clouding that. Part of my motivation was also being shamed out of it by a parent who I didn't want to antagonize or mock me about it anymore. I also felt I couldn't pass as anything other than male, so identifying as non-binary might be futile. Desisting initially made me feel worse. By February 4, 2022, I posted that insisting I am a man felt more futile and misogynistic by the day — I felt that by desisting I was reinforcing patriarchy and holding onto something I didn't deserve, and that I was undermining women and non-binary people. I feared I was just trans and in denial or repressing my true self. As an autistic person, behaving in a normally masculine manner on even a basic level wasn't accessible to me. I felt I couldn't relate to men at all and lacked societally masculine traits. I also worried people would dismiss my non-conforming traits as just autism symptoms, which I found presumptuous and reductive. I said neither desisting nor transitioning felt right, and that I was exploring living in the body I was given before making huge decisions with my body. I greatly feared transitioning and then regretting it, and knowing myself, I probably would — which is why I stayed indecisive. I never fully resolved my pronoun feelings: they/them remained my preferred pronouns, while he/him became "I'll be fine if you use these but I don't like them." I still felt hesitant and uncomfortable being referred to with male pronouns and titles. I still sometimes felt agender. On March 30, 2022, around my 20th birthday, I asked how to deal with feelings of wishing I could be the opposite sex or neither, saying I get a strong feeling that I'm faking being a man. Things I wished I had most were shorter height, wider hips, and female genitalia. I hid my genitalia with baggy or cargo pants, though I'd lately been wearing slimmer clothes at the cost of an obvious bulge. Women's clothing didn't fit my body well since they don't make clothes for women who are 6'4". I never had surgery, never took hormones, and have no medical complications or fertility concerns documented. I don't describe therapy as having helped or hurt — I never clearly entered it. I don't report suicidal ideation, self-harm, or attempts. My mental health struggles center on dysphoria, shame, and exhaustion rather than a named diagnosis beyond autism. I don't describe a current relationship, career beyond being a sophomore studying applied linguistics at university, or a specific advocacy role, though I did engage with detransition communities online and answered questions about asexuality for others.