Tutte le storie

Una terapeuta, una madre e una figlia di 16 anni a cui non permette di fare la transizione

Femmina · Desistito/a402
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una terapeuta e la madre di una figlia (ora 16enne) che si identifica come FTM; io non ho mai fatto la transizione, anche se alla sua età provavo cose simili e avrei pensato di essere trans se avessi saputo che era un'opzione. Scrivo qui per capire che cosa avrebbe aiutato gli adolescenti a ritardare o evitare la transizione medica, perché mia figlia ha DOC, depressione, tratti ADHD, una storia di bullismo sul corpo e una terapeuta affermativa che ha ignorato il suo DOC. Io e mio marito rifiutiamo ormoni, interventi e cambi di nome finché è minorenne, usando i pronomi maschili solo in casa per ridurre la sua ansia. Temo che al diploma cercherà testosterone e interventi e che se ne pentirà, e credo che il gruppo LGBTQ che frequenta e la sua madre biologica (che spinge per il testosterone) contribuiscano al problema. Al momento sostengo il rinvio della transizione medica per i minori e la priorità alle questioni di salute mentale di fondo; mi identifico come femmina e sono sempre stata una donna a cui non piacevano gli stereotipi di genere.

Storia completa

I am a therapist and the parent of a 15-year-old (later 16-year-old) daughter who, about a year before my first post in December 2019, decided she wants to be a boy — she says she wants to be a boy, never that she is one. Before that, and before she started attending an LGBTQ group for kids while exploring whether she was into girls, she was fiercely feminine, experimenting with makeup, dressing up, wanting to attend NOW (National Organization for Women) meetings, and we had talked about feminism. She has OCD and depression, and a history of being bullied about her body: puberty hit her hard — a bigger body, a period that would not end, and DD cups at 15. Her biological mother started commenting on her needing to lose her tummy in elementary school; bio mom has a history of bulimia and has made detrimental comments about the kid's body since elementary school. The kid is now dressing like a boy, binding her breasts (to the point of difficulty breathing — she told me she couldn't keep up with me walking because she couldn't fully breathe), cutting her hair short, and avoiding anything she used to love that is 'girly.' Being feminine causes her increasing anxiety. She asked to use male pronouns because they make her less anxious, and we agreed as a way to reduce anxiety while she builds coping skills. She is saving her allowance with the goal, on the day she graduates high school, of getting her breasts cut off and going on testosterone before college. When I raised concerns about her binder, she told me her only other choice would be suicide. She also shuts down conversations about her anxiety and body disgust by immediately mentioning feeling suicidal when looking at herself. I was extremely upset with her previous therapist, who for a year focused only on affirming her gender identity and never treated her OCD — the therapist even said to me, 'I didn't know she had OCD.' I am a therapist myself and saw that as a huge red flag: no work on history, self-esteem, or coping skills for anxiety and depression. It felt like the therapist was just excited to 'work with a trans kid and help them transition.' The kid is open to therapy but not clicking with her current therapist; we planned to find a new one once leaving the house was safer during COVID. I believe the LGBTQ teen group has been harmful. Kids in that group had bullied her for being a 'Lipstick Lesbian' after she wore a dress and makeup, and the adults did nothing. The group also gave her a lot of positive reinforcement for being trans. Her sexuality has shifted: she first came out as bi (after watching the Lady Marmalade video), then lesbian (after a boy she liked upset her), then started dating guys, and now says she is gay — she has been in a relationship with a guy for a year, kept apart by COVID. There are several contraindications to testosterone that I have not been able to raise because she immediately shuts down the conversation; my husband just says 'well I don't know' when I ask him to bring it up gently. My husband has difficulty when she cries about her body but is on board with not allowing hormone therapy, surgery, or name changes while she is a minor, and he supports therapy. Her bio mom is a different story — she takes the kid to the LGBT group, has asked about testosterone on the kid's behalf, and I think she enjoys the attention of having a transgender child. Custody has only been a loose agreement for 16 years; the kid resulted from friends with benefits with nebulous birth control, and bio mom wasn't much part of her life until she was around 5. I suspect more emotionally abusive behavior in bio mom's home, and as a mandated reporter I once had an ethical conversation about whether to report her — it didn't quite reach that level. Psych testing teased out OCD rather than autism, though OCD, ADHD, and autism share traits. I have some traits that could be considered autism but they align more with OCD. I try body positivity and self-compassion exercises — asking her to name two things she likes about herself — but the other parent doesn't encourage body positivity, and she could only come up with one thing. On my own side: I have never been very girly. I hate cooking while my husband loves it; I fix things, love cars, and worked on a car myself. I have always hated gender stereotypes and we bond over that. At her age I felt very much like she does now — my parents thought I was a lesbian for a while, and I would have thought I was trans if I had known trans was a thing at her age. I had to start wearing a bra in fourth grade because I had B-C cups, and my favorite coping skill was denial. I didn't become even slightly comfortable with my breasts until the end of junior year/beginning of senior year of high school. Binding wasn't a thing when I was younger, so I existed in sports bras and baggy shirts. My periods were heavy, long, and painful, and I was tired of being angry at my body for 'being an asshole' because my brother and male friends didn't have to deal with periods, breasts, or hips. My self-esteem improved when I focused on what I was good at rather than my appearance, and I realized those things didn't limit me. I recognized I needed mental health care but couldn't access it, so I made it a goal for college; in college I got mental health care and birth control, which were 'life savers,' and I started allowing myself to think of myself as attractive. Getting a properly fitting bra completely helped me feel better about myself, and I made sure to help the kid get fitted, quietly 'losing' the ill-fitting training bras bio mom bought when she was just shy of a C cup. I have advised other questioners that if you think you would regret transitioning, that is a good sign you would regret it; that not feeling 'good at being a girl' does not mean you are male; that androgynous and butch women are still legitimate women; and that you should be careful not to box yourself in. I have also suggested to others that dissociating from unwanted pubertal changes is a valid short-term coping skill but not healthy long-term, and recommended body scans and mindfulness. I encourage caution about believing everything read on the internet, and I have discussed with the kid whether wanting men's clothing makes you a man (my answer: not necessarily) and whether she wanted a penis — she said she didn't think so then but later questioned that answer; knowing OCD, I believe the thought got stuck and grew. I do not see myself as having detransitioned — I never transitioned — but I am a detransition-adjacent parent writing in this community, advocating for delaying medical transition for gender-questioning minors with untreated mental health conditions.